View Full Version : Street-Brown Holland-Opinions
bionicsasquach
5 Oct 2003, 19:44
Reported in the Herald Sun today, Bulldogs have expressed huge interest in Street and looks almost certain to be united.
The problem is Bullys and Catters have the same problems, gun midfielders, no great KPP. Possibly a 3 way trade seeing Brown to Richmond Holland to Geelong and Street+pick6 to Bulldogs.
Watta ya think about that?
Geelong are easily the big winners.
They offload Street, a guy who isn't in their best 22, for Ben Holland who would slot comfortably into any of their key positions.
Originally posted by DaveW
Geelong are easily the big winners.
They offload Street, a guy who isn't in their best 22, for Ben Holland who would slot comfortably into any of their key positions.
but don't geelong also lose pick 6? or is that the tigers pick?
Originally posted by feher
but don't geelong also lose pick 6? or is that the tigers pick? I was assuming the Bulldogs get Richmond's first pick.
Richmond have pick 6, Geelong have pick 7.
bionicsasquach
5 Oct 2003, 19:54
thats richmonds pick 6
rfctigerarmy
5 Oct 2003, 19:58
1st - Bulldogs Brown isnt worth #6 in the first place. To get Street as an add on is wrong.
2nd - Geelong Street is pretty terrible but hey he is still a player. To get Ben Holland in return is a win.
3rd - Richmond Brown for #6 and to also give up Holland is shocking but thats what the dogs will be asking for come trade week,
Originally posted by rfctigerarmy
1st - Bulldogs Brown isnt worth #6 in the first place. To get Street as an add on is wrong.
Why does your club want him so much then? Obviously because he is a dud.
Fall Out Boy
6 Oct 2003, 00:18
Originally posted by DaveW
They offload Street, a guy who isn't in their best 22, for Ben Holland who would slot comfortably into any of their key positions.
Any of their key FORWARD positions.
Wouldn't get close to a position in defence.
manutd/dogs
6 Oct 2003, 07:43
Originally posted by rfctigerarmy
1st - Bulldogs Brown isnt worth #6 in the first place.
Funny how no other tiger supporter (or anyone else on BF for that matter) seems to agree with you.
I don't agree with pick 6 and Holland for Brown though. Pick 6 and Street is probably ok, but I think Richmond would be looking for something more from the Cats to balance this deal up a bit.
Alternatively pick 7 and Street from the Cats to the Bulldogs, Brown to Richmond and Holland to Geelong, but then Richmond would need to throw something extra Geelong's way. I doubt the Cats would give up the number 7 pick for this deal though.
rfctigerarmy
6 Oct 2003, 19:33
Originally posted by manutd/dogs
Funny how no other tiger supporter (or anyone else on BF for that matter) seems to agree with you.
Whats that matter? These are forums arent they.. or.. am I on the wrong website?
fo·rum ( P ) Pronunciation Key (fôrm, fr-)
n. pl. fo·rums, also fo·ra (fôr, fr)
The public square or marketplace of an ancient Roman city that was the assembly place for judicial activity and public business.
A public meeting place for open discussion.
A medium of open discussion or voicing of ideas, such as a newspaper or a radio or television program.
A public meeting or presentation involving a discussion usually among experts and often including audience participation.
A court of law; a tribunal.