View Full Version : would a mjor trade like this ever be considered?
melbournemartin
13 Oct 2003, 20:42
i am talking major players here
buckley-voss
pavlich-goodes
hird-black
basically even for both sides
this would be good to spice up the afl :)
Originally posted by melbournemartin
i am talking major players here
buckley-voss
pavlich-goodes
hird-black
basically even for both sides
this would be good to spice up the afl :)
I'd take Hird for Black, thank you very very very much.
evertonfc
13 Oct 2003, 20:52
Originally posted by Stevo
I'd take Hird for Black, thank you very very very much.
Essendon get to dominate the midfield for another decade.
Be nearly as good as the Wells/Carey trade.
Mattlowry
13 Oct 2003, 21:00
buckley-voss
Would never happen...
pavlich-goodes
Freo would want more
hird-black
lol i would do this but i dont think Brisbane would like it very much.. Lol.
moe sizlak
13 Oct 2003, 21:02
Cmon mate, post something with a little more substance to it.
The Shev
13 Oct 2003, 22:21
Freo would want more?
Goodes is the damn Brownlow Medalist, and a very similar player to Pavlich? I think that's an even trade.
Yeah they're all even, but they would never happen... Be good to see them though :D
evertonfc
13 Oct 2003, 22:46
Here's a super mega trade deal that could actually work:
Port:
Gain - Didak + #18
Lose - Stevens + #46
Kangaroos:
Gain - Rawlings
Lose - Motlop + #24
Hawthorn:
Gain - Brown + #24
Lose - Rawlings + #10
Western Bulldogs:
Gain - Jacobs + #6
Lose - Brown + #34
Essendon:
Gain - Motlop + #10 + #34
Lose - Soloman + Jacobs
Collingwood:
Gain - Stevens + #46
Lose - Didak + #18
Richmond:
Gain - Soloman + Wheatley + Pick #52
Lose - Pick #6 + Holland
Melbourne:
Gain - Holland
Lose - Pick #52 + Wheatley
Edit:
Collingwood's deal was too good, Port were getting ripped off.
As an Essendon supporter I would never even consider Hird for Black, Hird is the best player I've ever seen, the day Hird retires I'm going to be lost, what will the Essendon Football Club be without James Hird?
Mattlowry
13 Oct 2003, 23:18
Originally posted by rama_9
As an Essendon supporter I would never even consider Hird for Black, Hird is the best player I've ever seen, the day Hird retires I'm going to be lost, what will the Essendon Football Club be without James Hird?
Well according to that guy with a player who is less injury prone and is going to be playing for a much longer time.. :rolleyes:
grinspoon
14 Oct 2003, 03:00
essendon would still have there best player in matthew lloyd.
Originally posted by melbournemartin
i am talking major players here
buckley-voss
pavlich-goodes
hird-black
You don't trade players that are the heart and soul of your club. Whatever gains it might make list-wise would be more than off-set by the disillusionment caused to players and fans.
Originally posted by evertonfc
Be nearly as good as the Wells/Carey trade. Of course, a champion could be traded when there are extraordinary circumstances.
Originally posted by evertonfc
Here's a super mega trade deal that could actually work:
Port:
Gain - Didak + #18
Lose - Stevens + #46
Collingwood:
Gain - Stevens + #46
Lose - Didak + #18
Edit:
Collingwood's deal was too good, Port were getting ripped off.
Wouldn't this then be a separate deal from the rest?
Now the trade is not so mega. ;)
Heck, you could even separate the Holland for Wheatley + pick #52 (as it only involves two clubs) from the rest.