Richmond SNR & RES Lineup (what do u think?)

[wrennyboy]

Ok guys since we know what players are on our list i thought it was best to put ur best 22 senior players and who will be playing for coburg. I will start it off

B: Luke Weller ~ Darren Gasper ~ Chris Newman

HB: Mark Chaffey ~ Shane Morrison ~ Andrew Kellaway

C: Nathan Brown ~ Kane Johnson ~ Greg Tivendale

HF: Joel Bowden ~ Brad Ottens ~ Wayne Campbell

F: Andrew Krakouer ~ Matty Richardson ~ Ty Zantuck

FL: Greg Stafford ~ Mark Coughlan ~ Justin Blumfield

IN: David Rodan~ Aaron Fiora ~ Duncan Kellaway ~ Tim Fleming


B: Chris Hyde ~ Kelvin Moore ~ Matthew Rogers

HB: Brent Hartigan ~ Ray Hall ~ Alex Gilmour

C: Shane Tuck ~ Simon Fletcher ~ Mark Dragacevic

HF: Daniel Jackson ~ Jay Shultz ~ Rory Hilton

F: Nathan Foley ~ Kyle Archibald ~ Kane Pettifer

FL: Ben Marsh ~ Thomas Roach ~ Andrew Raines

IN: Joel McDonald ~ Adam Houlihan ~ Billy Nicholls ~ ????(Hart)

Let me know what u think?

[mighty tiges]

I would have roughly the same side but with a few positional changes. Otto definitely in the ruck to start. I would still have Ty in a BP and move Newman to a HBF. Swap Cambo and Blumfield and have Brown swapping b/w FP and midfield as part of the midfield rotation. Similarly Newman and Cambo rotating. I wouldn't have both duncan and fleming in the same side.

B: Ty Zantuck ~ Darren Gasper ~ Andrew Kellaway

HB: Mark Chaffey ~ Shane Morrison ~ Chris Newman

C: Aaron Fiora ~ Wayne Campbell ~ Greg Tivendale

HF: Joel Bowden ~ Matty Richardson ~ Justin Blumfield

F: Andrew Krakouer ~ Greg Stafford ~ Nathan Brown

FL: Brad Ottens ~ Mark Coughlan ~ Kane Johnson

IN: David Rodan~ Duncan Kellaway ~ Luke Weller ~ (Hall/small - Hilton, Hyde, Tuck, etc...)

A couple of the interchange spots aren't obvious to me. Opportunity for one of the new guys to surprise and make a claim.

Going by what the Club has said publicly - They want Richo at FF :confused: , Morrison at CHF and Razor at CHB. Not what I would do.

wrenny your Coburg side is pretty spot on.

[CJH]

As for the starting 22, I too wouldn't have Fleming and Dunc in the same side. This would be the only change to the starting 22.

Hall would go to CHB (in reality, the 3rd tall defender) with Morrison going to CHF. Ottens to play ruck changing with Stafford in the forward line alongside Richo who plays FF (against my wishes!)

Hall aside, there isn't anyone in the 2nd XVIII who is demanding of a straight up senior spot.

[Rodgerramjet]

B: Luke Weller ~ Darren Gasper ~ Ty Zantuck

HB: Mark Chaffey ~ Andrew Kellaway ~ Wayne Campbell

C: Justin Blumfield ~ Kane Johnson ~ Greg Tivendale

HF: Nathan Brown ~ Shane Morrison ~ Joel Bowden

F: Andrew Krakouer ~ Matty Richardson ~ Greg Stafford

FL: Brad Ottens ~ Mark Coughlan ~ Chris Newman

IN: David Rodan~ Aaron Fiora ~ Duncan Kellaway ~ Ben Marsh

[jeka]

Mines not much different

B Ray Hall ~ Darren Gaspar ~ Andrew Kellaway
HB Mark Chaffey ~ Shane Morrison ~ Chris Newman
C Greg Tivendale~ Wayne Campbell ~ Josh Blumfield
HF Nathan Brown~ Matthew Richardson ~ Joel Bowden
F Andrew Krakouer~ Brad Ottens~ Ty Zantuck
R Greg Stafford ~ Mark Coghlan ~ Kane Johnson

Int David Rodan ~ Ducan Kellaway~ Luke Weller ~ Aaron Fiora

[Snibbo_TJS]

B: Luke Weller ~ Darren Gasper ~ Ty Zantuck

HB: Mark Chaffey ~ Andrew Kellaway ~ Chris Newman

C: Justin Blumfield ~ Kane Johnson ~ Greg Tivendale

HF: Nathan Brown ~ Shane Morrison ~ Joel Bowden

F: Andrew Krakouer ~ Greg Stafford~ Matty Richardson

FL: Brad Ottens ~ Mark Coughlan ~ Wayne Campbell

IN: David Rodan~ Aaron Fiora ~ Ray Hall~ Ben Marsh

[rfctigerarmy]

Mines a bit differnet..

- AK at CHB
- Blummers up in the forward line
- Rodan in Forward Flank
- Brown on a wing
- Richo CHF
- No Ben Marsh
- Fiora for Weller

B: Aaron Fiora - Darren Gasper - Ty Zantuck
HB: Mark Chaffey - Andrew Kellaway - Wayne Campbell
C: Nathan Brown - Kane Johnson - Greg Tivendale
HF: David Rodan - Matthew Richardson - Joel Bowden
F: Andrew Krakouer - Greg Stafford - Justin Blumfield
R: Brad Ottens - Mark Coughlan - Chris Newman
IN: Shane Morrison - Luke Weller - Tim Fleming - Ray Hall


BTW; jeka - Josh Blumfield..? Does he play like his brother?

[wrennyboy]

Actually me myself love seeing andy at CHF but i would prefer him to do the danny jacobs roll and just float back in defence and take the strong marks. Its good that Most people have included weller and Morrison in their sides other than the houlihans,pettifer and hiltons like we had to cause we had no depth last year. Also i hear that josh blumfield is a twin like his brother :p

[Cuneyt]

B: Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan
HB: Mark Coughlan- Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan
C: Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan
HF: Mark Coughlan- Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan
F: Mark Coughlan- Mark Coughlan- Mark Coughlan
R: Mark Coughlan- Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan
IN: Nathan Brown- Nathan Brown- Nathan Brown- Nathan Brown
EME:Matthew Richardson

:) :) :) Finals coming in 2004

[jeka]

originally posted by rfctigerarmy
BTW; jeka - Josh Blumfield..? Does he play like his brother?


If I could think and type at the same time I'd be dangerous:D

[rfctigerarmy]

Originally posted by jeka
If I could think and type at the same time I'd be dangerous:D

lol ;):D

[CJH]

Originally posted by Cuneyt
B: Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan
HB: Mark Coughlan- Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan
C: Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan
HF: Mark Coughlan- Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan
F: Mark Coughlan- Mark Coughlan- Mark Coughlan
R: Mark Coughlan- Mark Coughlan - Mark Coughlan
IN: Nathan Brown- Nathan Brown- Nathan Brown- Nathan Brown
EME:Matthew Richardson

:) :) :) Finals coming in 2004

Surprised that Ottens couldn't at least force a way onto the bench in that side! :eek:

[rfctigerarmy]

Originally posted by CJH
Surprised that Ottens couldn't at least force a way onto the bench in that side! :eek:

Johnson and Campbell surprise exclusions aswell :confused: :eek:

[One-eyed Tiger]

F. Zantuck Richo Krak
HF. Rodan Morrison Bowden
C Blumfield Johnson Tivendale
HB. Chaffey Hall Campbell
B A.Kellaway Gaspar Newman
R. Ottens, Coughlan, Brown
I/C. Stafford, Fiora, ?, ?

last 2 spots form players from:
Weller, Tuck, D.Kellaway, Rogers, Hyde, Fleming, Fletcher, Nicholls, Hilton, Shulz

[sante]

Backs: Zantuck Gaspar A. Kellaway
Half Backs: Chaffey Hall Campbell
Centres: Tivendale Johnson Newman
Half Forwards: Rodan Morrison Bowden
Forwards: Krakouer Richo Blumfield
Rucks: Ottens Coughlan Brown
Int. Schulz Fiora Stafford Fleming
Emerg. Weller Hilton D. Kellaway