"Black Kavanagh"
Debutant
- Apr 10, 2012
- 52
- 86
- AFL Club
- Essendon
id say pendles and swan and id back em to bear murphy and judd this week
Best Midfield Combo?
- Thread starter Juddbemetron
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Badtemperedbadger
Team Captain
Ha ha your bitterness is getting the better of you Squodge Podge.
Settle down and have a nice warm Horlicks.
There's a good boy
Judd and Murphy punished collingwood last night and in turn taught swan and pendlebury a lesson
GriddleCakes
Team Captain
- Apr 18, 2012
- 401
- 121
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Deflatriots, Celtics, Red Sox
Murphy / Judd by a mile.
As much as I want to hate Judd for shafting West Coast, he truly is one of the greats. Murphy is starting to surpass him as Carlton's best midfielder and one of the best in the game.
I really enjoy Pendlebury's game, but I really am not a fan of Swan at all. To me, he doesn't contribute much to the side aside from over-the-top possession counts. He racks it up but his presence is never really felt, unlike Judd, Murphy and Pendlebury.
Bartel had a couple of good seasons and is a really good marking midfielder/half-forward, but I wouldn't put him up as one of the greats. The whole "Brownlow" argument isn't substantial, considering Adam Cooney won a Brownlow, but no one carries on about him being one of the great midfielders. Joel Selwood is good in-and-under and influential at times but again, doesn't compare to Murphy/Judd.
So it's definitely a Murphy/Judd win, a combination which reminds me a lot of Cousins/Judd of 04-06.
As much as I want to hate Judd for shafting West Coast, he truly is one of the greats. Murphy is starting to surpass him as Carlton's best midfielder and one of the best in the game.
I really enjoy Pendlebury's game, but I really am not a fan of Swan at all. To me, he doesn't contribute much to the side aside from over-the-top possession counts. He racks it up but his presence is never really felt, unlike Judd, Murphy and Pendlebury.
Bartel had a couple of good seasons and is a really good marking midfielder/half-forward, but I wouldn't put him up as one of the greats. The whole "Brownlow" argument isn't substantial, considering Adam Cooney won a Brownlow, but no one carries on about him being one of the great midfielders. Joel Selwood is good in-and-under and influential at times but again, doesn't compare to Murphy/Judd.
So it's definitely a Murphy/Judd win, a combination which reminds me a lot of Cousins/Judd of 04-06.
I can't believe Bartel and Selwood are so far behind.
Similar threads
- Poll
