Size up the trade value of your list

[Periphery]

Could I get a price check on David Armitage please? I'd be interested to know what opposition supporters think he is worth since there seems to be some pretty different opinions among Saints fans.

 

[Daz]

Could I get a price check on David Armitage please? I'd be interested to know what opposition supporters think he is worth since there seems to be some pretty different opinions among Saints fans.

10-20. Though if I had a pick in the 6-10 range I wouldn't be against taking Armitage if he were in the draft for some reason.

 

[sunsofanarchy]

Picks 1-10
Ablett
Swallow
Prestia
O'Meara
Martin
Kolodjashnij
Bennel
Thompson
Lynch

Picks 10-20
Day
Dixon
Nicholls
McKenzie
Matera
Lonergan
Tape

Picks 20-30
Smith
Lemmens
Sumner
Leslie
Rischitelli
Gorringe
Stanley

Picks 30-40
Cameron
Hall
Russell
Shaw
Broughton

With all due respect..
Bock
Hunt
Sexton
Warnock
Schade
Taylor
Allen
Murphy
Hutchins

 

[timtamWB]

Picks 1-10
Ablett
Swallow
Prestia
O'Meara
Martin
Kolodjashnij
Bennel
Thompson
Lynch

Picks 10-20
Day
Dixon
Nicholls
McKenzie
Matera
Lonergan
Tape

Picks 20-30
Smith
Lemmens
Sumner
Leslie
Rischitelli
Gorringe
Stanley

Picks 30-40
Cameron
Hall
Russell
Shaw
Broughton

With all due respect..
Bock
Hunt
Sexton
Warnock
Schade
Taylor
Allen
Murphy
Hutchins

This sickens me, so much talent on the one list. You could also probably make a case for pushing Nicholls up into that range as well.

 

[Sanders]

Picks 1-10
Ablett
Swallow
Prestia
O'Meara
Martin
Kolodjashnij
Bennel
Thompson
Lynch

Picks 10-20
Day
Dixon
Nicholls
McKenzie
Matera
Lonergan
Tape

Picks 20-30
Smith
Lemmens
Sumner
Leslie
Rischitelli
Gorringe
Stanley

Picks 30-40
Cameron
Hall
Russell
Shaw
Broughton

With all due respect..
Bock
Hunt
Sexton
Warnock
Schade
Taylor
Allen
Murphy
Hutchins

Reckon you sold a few blokes short too

 

[MightyTiger]

I'm prepared to offer the RFC for a low price of a bag of Twisties (cheese flavor) and a can of red bull.

Sent from my HTC_PN071 using Tapatalk

 

[timtamWB]

I'm prepared to offer the RFC for a low price of a bag of Twisties (cheese flavor) and a can of red bull.

Sent from my HTC_PN071 using Tapatalk

High asking price, don't think there will be any takers.

 

[Deanos]

Martin was up for grabs last year and got no interest based on his wage demands and off-field baggage. Nobody's questioning that he's a gun on the ground but any club giving away a top 10 pick for him would be very, very silly.

As for Deledio why would you want a flashy but inconsistent player who disappears at big moments? He'll also be 28 early next season so could well only have 2-3 more good years in him. Any club with a decent development system would back themselves in every time to get more from their top 10 pick than that.

You couldn't be more wrong. Martin was never up for grabs. He was going to GWS or re-signing with Richmond. As he wanted to be closer to his dad, who lived in Sydney. Shane his dad, ended up moving down to Melbourne.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Players I would be prepared to lose
Bryce Gibbs, top 10 compo pick
Chris Yarran, 1st rounder
Andrew Walker, 2nd rounder
Jeff Garlett, 2nd rounder
Mitch Robinson, 2nd rounder
Matthew Watson, 2nd rounder
Josh Bootsma, 3rd rounder
Kane Lucas, 3rd rounder
Dennis Arnfield, 3rd rounder

 

[Ambrosia]

Plenty of clubs would be lining up to give their second rounder for Walker

 

[HeHateMe]

Plenty of clubs would be lining up to give their second rounder for Walker

Was thinking the same thing. Pass on the rest.

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

 

[benbanjo]

Players I would be prepared to lose
Bryce Gibbs, top 10 compo pick
Chris Yarran, 1st rounder
Andrew Walker, 2nd rounder
Jeff Garlett, 2nd rounder
Mitch Robinson, 2nd rounder
Matthew Watson, 2nd rounder
Josh Bootsma, 3rd rounder
Kane Lucas, 3rd rounder
Dennis Arnfield, 3rd rounder

Done! and ill trow in a 4th rounder!!

Done! and you give me a 1st rounder and my 4th rounder back!

 

[Levi_Hawk]

Plenty of clubs would be lining up to give their second rounder for Walker

Yep I'd love Walker for our 2nd rounder

 

[etsal1]

Walker just re-signed for 3 years. Indicating neither he or the club have any plans of parting ways. Whether that is the right or wrong move for Carlton for the future is another story. But he was an unrestricted free agent so we ran the risk of losing him for nothing.

 

[timtamWB]

Done! and ill trow in a 4th rounder!!

Done! and you give me a 1st rounder and my 4th rounder back!

Throwing in a 4th rounder is the equivalent of saying "Here! I had most of these chips but there are some down the bottom! I mean they're a bit soggy now, and most of the sauce is gone, but they're still good!'

 

[Winter]

Jeez, tough ask. Trying to take age into account with some of these...

Pick 1 - 3
Ben Cunnington

Picks 4 - 10
Scott Thompson
Andrew Swallow
Todd Goldstein
Aaron Black
Jack Ziebell
Luke McDonald
Lindsay Thomas

Picks 11 - 20
Ryan Bastinac
Lachlan Hansen
Aaron Mullett
Shaun Atley

Picks 21 - 30
Brent Harvey
Drew Petrie
Nick Dal Santo
Daniel Wells
Sam Gibson
Majak Daw
Brad McKenzie
Mason Wood
Taylor Garner
Trent Dumont

Picks 31 - 45
Leigh Adams
Jamie Macmillan
Robbie Tarrant
Kieran Harper
Cameron Delaney
Nathan Grima

Picks 45 - 60
Scott McMahon
Levi Greenwood
Sam Wright
Ben Jacobs
Tom Curran


Picks 61 - 90
Dan Currie
Taylor Hine

Picks 90+
Michael Firrito
Liam Anthony
Robin Nahas
Joel Tippett
Ben Brown
Mitch Wilkins

 

[jackess]

Reading most of these lists I wouldn't trade for what anybodies asking just about.

 

[MightyPies1]

> Pick 1
C. Judd
M. Murphy
B. Gibbs
M. Kreuzer

Picks 1-3
J. Waite

Picks 4-10
B. Fevola

Picks 11-20
E. Betts
P. Bower
S. Hampson
M. Jamison
B. Thornton

Picks 21-35
S. Grigg
R. Warnock
J. Russell

Picks 36-60
A. Carrazzo
K. Simpson
D. Armfield
M. Austin
B. Fisher
M. Robinson
A. Walker
C. Yarran

Picks 61-90
J. Anderson
R. Houlihan
C. Johnson
H. Scotland
N. Stevens
S. Wiggins

Picks 90+
None

No Value
J. Bannister
A. Bentick
S. Browne
C. Cloke
J. Edwards
R. O'Keefe
S. O'hAilpin
C. Tiller
R. Hadley
A. Hartlett


Of this list, I would say that the following would not be traded for draft picks unless another club massively overrated their value:

Judd, Murphy, Gibbs, Kreuzer, Waite, Jamison, Thornton, Bower, Yarran, Walker, Fevola

These threads are great for exposing bias fans, reckon all fans are bias but the worst will be Carlton and Essendon.

 

[MightyPies1]

> Pick 1
None

Picks 1-3
None


Picks 4-10
Scott Pendlebury
Alan Didak
Dane Swan


Picks 11-20
Heath Shaw
Leon Davis
Darren Jolly
John Anthony
Dayne Beams
Steele Sidebottom
Travis Cloke

Picks 21-35
Dale Thomas
Harry O'Brien
Nick Maxwell
Paul Medhurst
Luke Ball
Tarkyn Lockyer
Cameron Wood
Ben Reid
Nathan Brown
Josh Fraser
Brad Dick

Picks 36-60
Brent Macaffer
John McCarthy
Alan Toovey
Tyson Goldsack
Sean Rusling
Sharrod Wellingham
Chris Dawes

Picks 61+
Ryan Cook
Anthony Corrie
Ben Johnson

Too old to be traded
Simon Prestigiacomo

Rest of the list not worth mentioning.

I highly doubt any club would trade away pick 1 these days, even picks 2 and 3. Theres probably only a couple of players in the league that would be worth pick 1.
Riewoldt and Ablett.
Anyone who thinks otherwise is crazy.

The days of trading away priority picks is pretty much over

Glad this guy wasn't our list manager.

 

[TheDyerLegacy]

> Pick 1
None.
Picks 1-3
None.
Picks 4-10
Cotchin
Martin
Deledio
Riewoldt
Vlastuin
Picks 11-20
Rance
Ellis
Lennon
Conca
Vickery
Astbury
Picks 21-35
Maric
Jackson
Griffiths
Houli
Chaplin
Morris
Picks 36-60
Elton
McBean
Hampson
Arnot
Batchelor
Grimes
Grigg
S.Edwards
Dea
Helbig
Lloyd
Gordon
Picks 60-90
Miles
McIntosh
O'Hanlon
Knights
Picks 90(delist) +
Foley
King
A.Edwards
Newman
Thomas
Petterd
Williams
Stephenson
Banfield

That seems fair.

 

[Daz]

Cotchin, Riewoldt and Martin in the 1-3 range.

Astbury and Vickery too high.

 

[TheDyerLegacy]

Cotchin, Riewoldt and Martin in the 1-3 range.

Astbury and Vickery too high.

I guess.. around that 3-6 mark...

I see Vickery and Astbury around that 20 mark... could go for a bit later i guess to the high 20s low 30s.. both are young KPP.. I know Vickery cops a bit but he has shown a fair bit in the past.. Astbury was one of the better FB in the comp before he got injured..

 

[Daz]

Ellis should be in the 4-10 range as well.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

> Pick 1
None.
Picks 1-3
None.
Picks 4-10
Cotchin
Martin
Deledio
Riewoldt
Vlastuin
Picks 11-20
Rance
Ellis
Lennon
Conca
Vickery
Astbury
Picks 21-35
Maric
Jackson
Griffiths
Houli
Chaplin
Morris
Picks 36-60
Elton
McBean
Hampson
Arnot
Batchelor
Grimes
Grigg
S.Edwards
Dea
Helbig
Lloyd
Gordon
Picks 60-90
Miles
McIntosh
O'Hanlon
Knights
Picks 90(delist) +
Foley
King
A.Edwards
Newman
Thomas
Petterd
Williams
Stephenson
Banfield

That seems fair.

Quite fair, except that if you gave us pick 28 for Hampson then Maric has to be worth at least a top 20. Would also have Cotchin in the 1-3 category.

 

[TheDyerLegacy]

Quite fair, except that if you gave us pick 28 for Hampson then Maric has to be worth at least a top 20. Would also have Cotchin in the 1-3 category.

With Maric's injury concerns dont know if he will fetch a higher pick.. isn't young as well.. pick 20-25 seems fair..
yeah I guess Cotch would be around that 3-6 mark...