Roast The never again list!

[OneEyedHawk]

Suckling was awesome value at 314k (priced at 60ppg) for an 83 season average to date. If he can get that average up over 85-86 by the end of the year it will have been a win for anyone who started with him and held onto him as their D6 or D7

Yeah, true. I keep forgetting he started at that price. I just tend to lump him in with the rest of my bunch of sh1t-kicker backmen who each seem to average around 80-85ppg (eg. Suckling, Burgoyne, Grimey etc).

Having not had Bartel, for me only McVeigh & Swallow can hold their heads high down back, with Mitchell about to re-enter my squad at Langdon's expense next week. A week late but had other pressing concerns this week.

 

[Jiska]

Cotchin 119 average from last 5. You'd be pretty happy if you traded him in for 471k in Rd 13

Wouldn't be happy holding him for the first 12 rounds tho.

 

[Goodo73]

Wouldn't be happy holding him for the first 12 rounds tho.

I had Cotchin for the first 14 rounds, but then traded him out for Prestia.

Prior to round 15:
TC - season avg 96.9, 5 rnd avg 88.6
DP - season avg 113.3, 5 rnd avg 127.2

On paper, a justifiable trade at the time. However, in the following three rounds:
TC - avg 137.6 (I was at the round 15 game where he busted out a 168 against the Saints ... FML)
DP - avg 80.3

Not to say I would never pick Cotchin again, but he certainly hasn't left me with a warm, rosy afterglow.

Pav's a gonner for me. Took him on this year hoping he was a premium FWD with the cost of a mid-pricer; sadly I was wrong.

 

[rocker_oz33]

It pays to sick fat with your premo's.most of the time.

Cotchin.
SJ.
Dusty.
Spuddy.
all have come good.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Never again.
Cheap rucks/Unproven rucks.


I will most likely go little cheaper down back to net a goldy/minson type ruck right from the get go.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Wouldn't be happy holding him for the first 12 rounds tho.

Cotchin 2014 is exactly why you never trade a premium.

My brother traded him to Fyfe 4 rds ago. Cost him $160k and so far, 40 points worse off for it. Not to mention the trade itself.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Suckling was awesome value at 314k (priced at 60ppg) for an 83 season average to date. If he can get that average up over 85-86 by the end of the year it will have been a win for anyone who started with him and held onto him as their D6 or D7

Yepz that looks like me at the moment although he is currently on my list.
He seems to be the weakest link in my team at D6 but if he can finish the season strongly, all is forgiven.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

It pays to sick fat with your premo's.most of the time.

Cotchin.
SJ.
Dusty.
Spuddy.
all have come good.

Those small fonts right at the end seem to reflect on a certain Collingwood player...

 

[rocker_oz33]

Those small fonts right at the end seem to reflect on a certain Collingwood player...

Maxwell is not a premo.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Maxwell is not a premo.

Not Maxy, the other one who did not retire...

 

[GOAUS!]

It pays to sick fat with your premo's.most of the time.

Cotchin.
SJ.
Dusty.
Spuddy.
all have come good.

Burgoyne? Pav's looking done too atm.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Burgoyne? Pav's looking done too atm.

Dont have him and unsure on hes scoring.
I think i am stuck with pav low trades no cash he wont be in my nest seasons team though.

 

[Lums23]

Has anyone been a smartarse and said Cox yet?

 

[MrNatural]

Heath Shaw

 

[Sir Skid]

No more 'oh he's got so much potential' MUPPETS!
Guns or rookies..... apart from cheap ruckmen of course.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

It pays to sick fat with your premo's.most of the time.

Cotchin.
SJ.
Dusty.
Spuddy.
all have come good.

Throw Murphy on to that list

 

[Jiska]

Throw Murphy on to that list

I had better not reply with my thoughts, otherwise Gingy may get upset

 

[Krujan]

Throw Murphy on to that list

I had better not reply with my thoughts, otherwise Gingy may get upset

110.4 season average from a starting price of only 498k #WINNING

 

[karaoke]

Sauce Jacobs - never again........





Wait a sec, that was 2013 sentiment..........

(never say never - at the right price, everything needs to be considered!)

 

[big bootaaaaah]

I'll never again trade out premo due to a bloody knee or ankle unless I personally see it hanging off or at dislocated at least 90 degrees Or a sore back unless I personally witness him in a wheelchair steering it with his chin!! I'm talking about you buddy and griffin!

 

[rocker_oz33]

And shoulder issues ^^.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

110.4 season average from a starting price of only 498k #WINNING

#doublewinning








For those that kept both Cotchin & Murph when everyone else was jumping off!!!

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Never again.
Cheap rucks/Unproven rucks.


I will most likely go little cheaper down back to net a goldy/minson type ruck right from the get go.

Took sandi and Lobbe.

Couldn't be happier.

Sandi is going to come back huuuge. 27 days off. Will come back breathing fire, spitting out bullets and tearing asses!

 

[Sir Skid]

I'll never take a Susan Boyle avatar bet with toxic again.

 

[Broar]

I reiterate SJ never again.