Luke Bruest Vs Chad Wingard

[Big Sauce 21]

103 votes vs 57 votes. All 57 votes probs hawk supporters
Breust better this year
Wingard better career and better player overall

Incorrect.

 

[King Of The Hille]

Wingard, easilly.

 

[HawkHeaven]

Wingard, easilly.

Bruest easily.

I sure debunked your compelling opinion.

 

[WWSD]

Luke Breust record vs the top eight teams is much better then Wingard's.

 

[cryptor]

Luke Breust times infinity plus one! I can't hear you so what you say next doesn't count! Lalalalalalala

 

[pacman]

Wingard, easilly.

Once again he struggled when the game was there to be won, he was non existent.

 

[Young Gun #6]

Add in a tall forward and Wingard will shine, too hard playing 85% at FF.

 

[Chrizzt]

Once again he struggled when the game was there to be won, he was non existent.

Yeah, appearing when the game is there to be won is probably what Wingard is known best for. He's had a down month, and still averaging decent numbers.

 

[ShanDog]

Bruest for me. Mostly because I think he is more effective in his role, but also a little bit because Wingard is a chest-puffer and I don't like that

 

[pacman]

Add in a tall forward and Wingard will shine, too hard playing 85% at FF.

WTF is Schultz?

 

[QPower]

Silly thread...Hawks supporters would argue Mitch Thorpe is better than Wayne Carey.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Brad Hill > Gary Ablett

 

[Young Gun #6]

WTF is Schultz?

Been playing up the ground half the game and when he isn't there is literally ONLY schulz as opposed to Roughhead, Hale, Gunstan etc at Hawks who all make Bruests job a lot easier than Wingards this year.

 

[pacman]

Been playing up the ground half the game and when he isn't there is literally ONLY schulz as opposed to Roughhead, Hale, Gunstan etc at Hawks who all make Bruests job a lot easier than Wingards this year.

Righto so Westhoff is invisible also.
Rough and Gunston both push up the ground or do you only watch Port?

 

[Nerflardio2424]

Lol some of these port fans are fair dinkum, wingard is flashy and acts like he's s**t doesn't stink, breust comfortably

 

[HawkHeaven]

Silly thread...Hawks supporters would argue Mitch Thorpe is better than Wayne Carey.

Port supporters would argue that Scott Hodges was better than Dunstall.

s**t this is an easy game you are playing young fella.

Who is Mitch Thorpe, no player by that name has ever been on the Hawks list.

 

[Young Gun #6]

Righto so Westhoff is invisible also.
Rough and Gunston both push up the ground or do you only watch Port?

Westhoff plays like 75% in defense..

 

[Young Gun #6]

Righto so Westhoff is invisible also.
Rough and Gunston both push up the ground or do you only watch Port?

Rough and Gunston would spend a lot more time inside 50 than westhoff and schulz, get champion data account if you want to verify PLUS you have Hale if not the case which is exactly what would help Wingard, just any tall.

 

[Big Sauce 21]

Westhoff plays like 75% in defense..

does being a loose man down back class as a defender.

 

[Young Gun #6]

does being a loose man down back class as a defender.

A utility mate

 

[HawkHeaven]

A utility mate

A utility is a car.

 

[Young Gun #6]

A utility is a car.

'utility player - refers to one who can be used or placed in many positions on the field'

 

[dvas987]

 

[Engimal]

Still Breust.

 

[pacman]

Been playing up the ground half the game and when he isn't there is literally ONLY schulz as opposed to Roughhead, Hale, Gunstan etc at Hawks who all make Bruests job a lot easier than Wingards this year.

Marks inside 50 is Hale, Rough & Gunston 87 and Schulz & Westhoff 87!
So it really doesn't help your argument as Wingard should just be at 2 players feet where Breust has to be at 3.