strange, i had been thinking lately that it isn't so much the songwriting (not that it's great mind you.. even on magnetic they still sound like they are stuck trying to write the 7 minute epics of yesteryear but now with their bottomless grab-bag of predictable rock riffs) that is 'holding metallica back', it's hetfield's vocals and their terrible lyrics. i think they would be much more listenable if james dropped the crooning bullshit and just barked it out ala RTL. it's like both his balls have been lopped off post black album, seriously an embarrassing listen.
Yeah 100% agree - his vocals are terrible and ruin even the older classics when they do them live. The recent live dvds they have put out are ruined by him unfortunatley. That plus his declared hatred of guitar reverb which I simply cannot fathom.