Rumour Goldsack on his way to Port / Geelong / Adelaide / St Kilda / etc / etc

[THATSGOLD]

Thanks for ur input, it's great how you mentioned how poorly we've been going for the 50tg time within a week

We should pay then all 500k a year so we can finish 10 and below again.

 

[Maggie5]

He will stay for less than has been reported and will get a three year contract.

 

[Pera]

So what? Frawley is UFA because he's not top bracket either, but Melbourne could pick up a first rounder for him. It's not about what they're earning now, it's about what they're leaving for.
And Young is on nowhere near $400k per year, so it's a poor comparison.

because he's on a front ended contact. Please do some research

 

[Seedsfan]

because he's on a front ended contact. Please do some research

But the AFL does not look at how much he was on 4 years ago when they are handing out compo picks

 

[Old Spice]

Agreed but the figures mooted are similar when comparing Goldy and Young. Frawley will be around 700K per year for mine, close to double.

Frawley doesn't mean double cost. You'd subtract Frawley's cost from Goldy's cost. If Goldy wants 400k p.a. then a 750k Frawley costs 350k in terms of wage difference.

 

[Gone Critical]

Frawley doesn't mean double cost. You'd subtract Frawley's cost from Goldy's cost. If Goldy wants 400k p.a. then a 750k Frawley costs 350k in terms of wage difference.

Surely Frawley is worth nothing like 750K

 

[Pera]

But the AFL does not look at how much he was on 4 years ago when they are handing out compo picks

Time will tell my man

 

[Old Spice]

Surely Frawley is worth nothing like 750K

700k maybe, hopefully cheaper

 

[THATSGOLD]

Can't remember one game where he dominated, what I can remember is a lot of critics slagging him off...so, Goldsack, don't let the door hit your arse on the way out !

Goldsack is remembered for one goal in his whole career. Apart from that he "filling a role."
Not good enough. Trade.

 

[Markfs]

People are still mentioning James Frawley. Everything being said by Collingwood says that this is not going to happen. It would completely compromise the plan of drafting young players while using more mature recruits looking for an opportunity to prove themselves. Frawley is looking for money and a premiership. This is a complete mismatch to the club's situation. I will eat my shorts if he comes on board...

 

[Markfs]

Goldsack is remembered for one goal in his whole career. Apart from that he "filling a role."
Not good enough. Trade.

"Trade" doesnt appear to be an option. He may leave as a free agent, or he may choose to stay. These are the options.

 

[frizzle]

"Trade" doesnt appear to be an option. He may leave as a free agent, or he may choose to stay. These are the options.

Yes the simple options that some just can't get their head around.

 

[Captivating]

Can be resigned and traded.

 

[Bay Pie]

People are still mentioning James Frawley. Everything being said by Collingwood says that this is not going to happen. It would completely compromise the plan of drafting young players while using more mature recruits looking for an opportunity to prove themselves. Frawley is looking for money and a premiership. This is a complete mismatch to the club's situation. I will eat my shorts if he comes on board...

Cunning plan isn't it? We've played it beautifully.

Bucks doesn't deny it.
Mark Slobbinson says it's a done deal.
Eade says we have no cap space.
As above, clearly doesn't fit our plans

We are so getting him.

 

[Apex36]

because he's on a front ended contact. Please do some research

I know that. Still irrelevant to compensation.

 

[Jdawgz]

please keep him

DO NOT WANT.

 

[Markfs]

Can be resigned and traded.

so he would re-sign so that he could be traded to a club that might give him a lower salary than what he would get if he took the free agency?.... lol

 

[rustyg70]

Read somewhere that he wants to stay but is chasing a three year deal and we are only offering a two year deal, with a third year clause.

 

[KJpie]

Frawley doesn't mean double cost. You'd subtract Frawley's cost from Goldy's cost. If Goldy wants 400k p.a. then a 750k Frawley costs 350k in terms of wage difference.

Totally Agree.

Via the same mathematical logic Goldy goes 400k Ball and Max retire 725K we pick up Frawley $625K and 2 rookies $100K as we only go with 38 on the seniors list and are therefor in credit to the sum of $400 - $500 in terms of wage difference.

Cant recall if rookies are part of the TPP's

 

[SpongePie]

please keep him

DO NOT WANT.

Neither do we

 

[HenrikLundqvist]

Can you take H with you Goldsack?

Seriously, Goldsack isn't a footballer's arsehole. Remember when everybody was raving about his immense pressure that lasted all of two weeks?

 

[DaicosianMarvels]

I don't understand the Goldsack hate, what do people expect from him, to be an All Australian? Kick 30 goals?

He is a role player and is worth around the 350 000 mark and I would be happy if we could keep him if not he is a pretty decent loss. Or let's just get another 18 year old to replace him and we will see how competitive we will be next season with a team full of kids.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Seriously, Goldsack isn't a footballer's arsehole.

I guess my question to you would be: How would you know?

 

[good4footy]

I don't understand the Goldsack hate, what do people expect from him, to be an All Australian? Kick 30 goals?

He is a role player and is worth around the 350 000 mark and I would be happy if we could keep him if not he is a pretty decent loss. Or let's just get another 18 year old to replace him and we will see how competitive we will be next season with a team full of kids.

Sanity - he is exactly that a role player. No team can afford a team of champions.

He is a player that exists in all teams - a role player. All our role players have had to step up this year because of injuries and people are bagging them for not being able to be something they are not.

The guy gives his all every contest and in fact has had games above what he has provided before. Baby... bath water some people. If he stays for the right money I will be very happy.

 

[gutsroy]

I like Goldsack, he plays a role which shouldn't be dismissed, can play up forward or down back and his pressure often does result in us recovering the ball or halting an opposition thrust, but the reported 3 yrs, 400/yr is too high, especially if it's true that we are struggling with our salary cap.