-
LIVE: St Kilda v Western Bulldogs - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Saints at 51% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
James Frawley v Ben Reid
- Thread starter HyperAgressiveDonk
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Upgrayedd
A Vote for Clive is a Vote for Justice
One played in a horrid team out of position and one couldn't break into a jog without pulling a hammy or a calf.
harsh call to bump this, Pure Stopper Frawley>>>>Reid. However Reid's football skill is vastly superior, excellent kick, Both are pretty crafty and can read the play well and provide some rebound. Reid is much more suited to CHB and Frawley to FB
harsh call to bump this, Pure Stopper Frawley>>>>Reid. However Reid's football skill is vastly superior, excellent kick, Both are pretty crafty and can read the play well and provide some rebound. Reid is much more suited to CHB and Frawley to FB
- Sep 8, 2014
- 16,971
- 23,295
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- There are no other teams
Yep not much thought went into that.
Reid is the better all round player but his durability or lack thereof is an issue.
When both fit, Reid.
When both fit, Reid.
Rana_swans
Debutant
Frawley appears better because of
Frawley appears to play better because of Roos defensive mindset and tactics, Ben Reid has better rebound hence is way more dangerous
Frawley appears to play better because of Roos defensive mindset and tactics, Ben Reid has better rebound hence is way more dangerous
Upgrayedd
A Vote for Clive is a Vote for Justice
Uh...You've quoted a post from 2 years ago when it was Mark Neeld who was in his first year of coaching, Plus Frawley played majority up forward for the Demons in 2014
What the hell are you on about mate? You've flat out lied.
Frawley but I think they are both overrated
Theseventhhamster
Brownlow Medallist
You'll change your mind when you see how badly he beats Jay Schulz.
Hope so
Theseventhhamster
Brownlow Medallist
Has murdered him more than once playing in a rubbish team.
Should be a good match-up as Schulz usually does well against us. Lake is not mobile enough for him and we prefer Gibbo to be able to zone off
Lynden Dunn played on him this year. Was the time Frawley murdered him in R1 2013 when Schulz had 20 touches and kicked 4 on him?
Theseventhhamster
Brownlow Medallist
If only I'd claimed that Frawley played on him every time you post might be useful.
I asked you a question, when has Frawley murdered him? Given I've seen every game they've played on each other I really am eager to find out which game Frawley smashed him. I reckon he's gotten the better of him before, never murdered him though. Schulz killed him the last time they played against each other. Maybe that's why Dunn got the gig on him in 2014?
Theseventhhamster
Brownlow Medallist
Yeah that's why Dunn played on him not that Frawley was a forward for nearly the entire season.
2011 or 2012 he held him to one touch in the first half and had a heap of it going the other way. Was the most comprehensive smashing you could have. Cant give you a date/tape/sworn testimony. The other times I remember them going head to head since he's been at Port Frawley blanketed him too. Couldn't touch it without chasing kicks out on the wing. Why are you watching Melbourne/Port games? Family member of Jay?
Yeah that's why Dunn played on him not that Frawley was a forward for nearly the entire season.
Calm down brother. If Frawley had the wood over Schulz like you suggest then he would have played on him. Yeah I do remember a game in Darwin where Frawley clearly beat him but that is the only time. Since he's been at Port he's played against Melbourne 7 times. In 2010 he played against them twice, first time out he was fairly ordinary but Frawley wasn't playing on him. Second time out he kicked 5 and tore ya's a new one but only 2 of those goals were on Frawley IIRC. Played against each other both times in 2011, Frawley beat him once (the Darwin game) and they broke even in the last game of the season at Adelaide Oval, IMO. Next time out was R1 2013 where Schulz gave him a thorough rectal examination. As I pointed out they didn't play on each other in 2014.
Now here is your original post. You can call me a family member of Schulzy's if ya want but this was the comment I disagreed with. He bathed him once in 2011 when both teams were rubbish. Other than that he hasn't had the wood over him at all.
Theseventhhamster
Brownlow Medallist
I'm perfectly calm thank you. I also didn't call you a family member I was just asking a question that I noted you dodged. I guess you could just be a super fan who couldn't let go. Understandable but it leads to a bias you're clearly showing for Schulz. If you are watching these Melbourne games and don't understand why Frawley was playing forward you probably aren't playing with a full deck, we we didn't spend the season hiding him from forwards we didn't think he could handle.
I'm perfectly calm thank you. I also didn't call you a family member I was just asking a question that I noted you dodged. I guess you could just be a super fan who couldn't let go. Understandable but it leads to a bias you're clearly showing for Schulz. If you are watching these Melbourne games and don't understand why Frawley was playing forward you probably aren't playing with a full deck, we we didn't spend the season hiding him from forwards we didn't think he could handle.
Obviously Frawley played forward because you had very few decent targets up there. Just saying that if he apparently murders Schulz every time he plays on him then maybe he would actually play on him
I proved your original statement wrong with facts. Don't change subject. Since you're on here talking about how good Frawley is, perhaps you're unable to let go. The * is a super fan btw brother?As for the thread's question - Ben Reid every day of the week
Theseventhhamster
Brownlow Medallist
You have unique definitions of the words "fact" and "proved."
