Round 4 Trades

[jjsmitty8]

I've got some decisions to make. Some help would be great. Things I'm weighing up are:
A) Should I run with Oxley, K-Mac and Saad all starting on field?
B) KK and or Goodes needs to go, but so does Wines maybe.
C) Keep Wines and get Krak, swap Martin/Swan with Lambert to the midfield and play Krakouer.
D) KK to WhiteX, Wines to Lewis or Sloane.
E) Other (Please specify)

 

[Banshee23]

Bartel --> Bonts or Swan? Bringing Bonts in will obviously get me a bit more cash to play with...

Then...

Who to trade out #2? Goodes, Griffen, KK or Newnes?

 

[SupaPhill]

Wines -> Sloane. Locked.

Who should I trade Bartel to? Anyone Mid/Fwd (650k in the bank)

I went with roughead because he seems to be starting in the midfield more often this year.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Bartel to The Bont.
Hold onto the cash for upgrades.

Might go Anderson to Krac as Anderson will struggle to get a full game and won't make anyone a cent.

Goodes long gone. Green vest tattoo'd on him for the year.
Back line of Smith, Simpson, Taylor, Johnson, Oxley and Saad got me 528 this week at an average of 88.
Macintosh and Brown on the bench making cash with great JS.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Bartel --> Bonts or Swan? Bringing Bonts in will obviously get me a bit more cash to play with...

Then...

Who to trade out #2? Goodes, Griffen, KK or Newnes?

Goodes has to go. The others at least play a whole game and have job security.

 

[SupaPhill]

I've got some decisions to make. Some help would be great. Things I'm weighing up are:
A) Should I run with Oxley, K-Mac and Saad all starting on field?
B) KK and or Goodes needs to go, but so does Wines maybe.
C) Keep Wines and get Krak, swap Martin/Swan with Lambert to the midfield and play Krakouer.
D) KK to WhiteX, Wines to Lewis or Sloane.
E) Other (Please specify)

View attachment 126123

Wines > Krak, goodes/kolo to hodge?

 

[Goats]

Can anyone make an argument for Goddard finishing the year as top ten forward in his current role?

 

[Lums23]

Bartel --> Bonts or Swan? Bringing Bonts in will obviously get me a bit more cash to play with...

Then...

Who to trade out #2? Goodes, Griffen, KK or Newnes?

Probably Bonts

Goodes, then kk. Hold the other two for the moment, they are more likely to come good

 

[Lums23]

Can anyone make an argument for Goddard finishing the year as top ten forward in his current role?

Doubt it

 

[Monika72]

Doubt it

Got rid of him last week for Swan, after the first 2 games alarm bells went off and out he went. I do like the Watson, he'll be in my team this week.

 

[SupaPhill]

I've got some decisions to make. Some help would be great. Things I'm weighing up are:
A) Should I run with Oxley, K-Mac and Saad all starting on field?
B) KK and or Goodes needs to go, but so does Wines maybe.
C) Keep Wines and get Krak, swap Martin/Swan with Lambert to the midfield and play Krakouer.
D) KK to WhiteX, Wines to Lewis or Sloane.
E) Other (Please specify)

View attachment 126123

even trade out wines swap a premo mid into the midfield and get in hogan. Still leaves you cash to get rid of kolo/goodes into a premo

 

[Jiska]

Can anyone make an argument for Goddard finishing the year as top ten forward in his current role?

Nope

 

[dUkezz]

is it worth bringing in whiteX this week?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

is it worth bringing in whiteX this week?

Too early. See how he goes next week against a decent side like Port I reckon.

 

[Lums23]

Got rid of him last week for Swan, after the first 2 games alarm bells went off and out he went. I do like the Watson, he'll be in my team this week.

He died off badly towards the end of last year, and seems to be getting less and less midfield minutes. Was never really considered in my team this year

 

[Jiska]

is it worth bringing in whiteX this week?

Nope

 

[dUkezz]

Nope

looks like ill have to stick with the butcher newnes and the spud bellchambers for a few more weeks and continue to watch goldy continually bend me over every weekend

 

[royeca]

Not a fan of sideway trades but what do people think of KK to Hunt?

 

[Asho81]

Thinking of;
Wines to Joel Selwood
Goodes to Jake Kelly (crows)

 

[Roy boys]

Any cheap backs not named Oxley, saad or mcintosh that I can swap in for Goodes to make some cash??

Whitecross

 

[GAsnr]

Bartel>> Roughhead
Bartel>>E Betts
Bartel>> Buddy

so caught up on who to choose , i feel roughead is the way to go , most consistent.

Reckon buddy is the go there

 

[Strahany]

Thinking:
Goddard to Krak
KK to Smith

Leaves me with a few hundred grand spare, in case I need to execute a trade on short notice.

 

[Kadog]

Those with Mummy; hold or fold?

Hold

Wines -> Sloane. Locked.

Who should I trade Bartel to? Anyone Mid/Fwd (650k in the bank)

Watson

 

[Chunderboy]

For now I've decided on

Bartel -> Bont
Newnes -> Hunt

Leaves me plenty of cash for next week to go
Griffen -> JPK
Swallow -> Ward/Lewis

Then the next few weeks, stay quiet while I manage rookies to raise cash then go bang around the byes

 

[Judd_Magic]

Bartel > Swan

Newnes > Hamling (if selected) and Oxley onto the ground.

$409,800 in the kitty now so I can piss off Griffen > Beams or JPK in the next week or 2.

Rest I'll use for quick upgrades.