Discussion Round 5, 2015: Guernsey Discussion

[Klim]

We are discussing all things for Round 5.
Friday, May 1
Carlton v Collingwood
Saturday, May 2
Richmond v Geelong
Sydney v Western Bulldogs
Gold Coast v Brisbane
North Melbourne v Hawthorn
West Coast v GWS
Sunday, May 3
Melbourne v Fremantle
St Kilda v Essendon
Adelaide v Port Adelaide

https://sites.google.com/site/bfjumpertipping/jumper-database

 

[Gibbsy]

Can we still have the tipping done in the megathread rather than this? I feel that'd be a better idea just to leave the two things separate. No issues with doing it 'manually' however.

 

[NM_Mitchell]

Spoiler

Port Showdown guernsey

 

[Klim]

Can we still have the tipping done in the megathread rather than this?

Megathread is for results and things. If you want you can make a separate thread for this weeks discussions.

 

[MKMatty]

Can we still have the tipping done in the megathread rather than this? I feel that'd be a better idea just to leave the two things separate. No issues with doing it 'manually' however.

Yeah. Have this thread for discussion, the megathread for tipping. Keeps them separate that way.

EDIT: Three thread?

 

[Gibbsy]

Megathread is for results and things. If you want you can make a separate thread for this weeks discussions.

Nah, we decided at the start of the season that the tipping and the discussion were to be in separate threads. It just so happened that the tipping occurred off-site for the first few rounds.

It's not like there's any chance of the discussion thread being low on posts, last week's got 300+ replies.

 

[Cody_]

Spoiler

Port showdown Guernsey

 

[NM_Mitchell]

not sure where to put this with the new jumpers for 2015 thread closed (all the more reason for a general guernsey discussion thread IMO)
Northern Blues moved on from Nike this year.

 

[Klim]

Can we still have the tipping done in the megathread rather than this? I feel that'd be a better idea just to leave the two things separate. No issues with doing it 'manually' however.

Nah, we decided at the start of the season that the tipping and the discussion were to be in separate threads. It just so happened that the tipping occurred off-site for the first few rounds.

It's not like there's any chance of the discussion thread being low on posts, last week's got 300+ replies.

Nah, I've found a way to open the external site. Round 5 is now open on it.

 

[rabbitoh21]

Nah, I've found a way to open the external site. Round 5 is now open on it.

He's got hax

 

[hitthepost]

At least if Collingwood wear the black guernsey with white strips and white shorts vs Carlton, it'll be consistent with what Hawthorn wore against Port

 

[Cainozz]

Port showdown Guernsey

So are GWS not wearing their clash as much any more? They wore the white clash vs west coast at subi last year

 

[Fizzler]

Spoiler

Port Home/Clash w/ Number Panel

 

[Gibbsy]

Nah, I've found a way to open the external site. Round 5 is now open on it.

Alright awesome. Proceed as usual!

 

[Gibbsy]

not sure where to put this with the new jumpers for 2015 thread closed (all the more reason for a general guernsey discussion thread IMO)
Northern Blues moved on from Nike this year.

Here's fine. It's still 'current'. Although I think we have a state leagues thread, it just hasn't been posted in in a while. It would probably fit best there.

 

[Cody_]

So are GWS not wearing their clash as much any more? They wore the white clash vs west coast at subi last year

i meant clash , my mistake thanks

 

[NM_Mitchell]

Here's fine. It's still 'current'. Although I think we have a state leagues thread, it just hasn't been posted in in a while. It would probably fit best there.

oh, i'd forgotten about that thread, i'll head there next time.

 

[undefined]

Matchday Strips Reflecting a Reasonably Professional Organisation

 

[MKMatty]

Matchday Strips Reflecting a Reasonably Professional Organisation

If only..

 

[Dylan8]

Matchday Strips Reflecting a Reasonably Professional Organisation

If only we had a permanent, white trimmed, white panelled, glorious away guernsey.

 

[undefined]

If only we had a permanent, white trimmed, white panelled, glorious away guernsey.

Yeah, like Hawthorn's inspired modern graphic guernsey.

 

[Lion Cub 16]

Is everyone agreed on the lions and suns kits clashing? This video shows what it would look like if we both wore our home jumper and I'm not 100% that our clash is required...

 

[undefined]

A clash guernsey isn't completely necessary, but it does make the matchup more visually appealing... something totally essential in today's day & age of Billion-dollar TV deals, news-orientated timeslots and an over-particular sporting society.

 

[hitthepost]

Matchday Strips Reflecting a Reasonably Professional Organisation

Agreed, except they should still let WCE wear the Tri-Panel as they're the home team and that's their chosen home guernsey at present.

 

[wing it]

Is everyone agreed on the lions and suns kits clashing? This video shows what it would look like if we both wore our home jumper and I'm not 100% that our clash is required...

I don't see any clash there