he gave us stability as a President. Can't blame what is happening now on him and he was well liked
never wanted him to leave
Opinion Mick Malthouse
- Thread starter Stamos
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
never wanted him to leave
Welcome to Collingwood 2011.
you can't be serious, who do you think sacked Ratten and appointed Malthouse ? the list management problems we face now were many years in the making, under his watch.
unfortunately injuries can bring a coach down, we could have no injuries and pretty much the same list next season and with a new coach and they start to win and everyone will laud the new coach...............which will be wrong because Mick has had no luck with injuries the past year and a half. Injuries are the reason we are not competitive
you can't be serious, who do you think sacked Ratten and appointed Malthouse ? the list management problems we face now were many years in the making, under his watch.
Ratten was a good offensive coach, not defensive and that was never going to get a flag. I'm amazed that the same people that wanted Ratten sacked, are probably now sticking up for him.
I agree about Ratten but I didn't agree that we should appoint Malthouse without an extensive interview process. Until the whole club changes from top (especially top) down, changing coaches is putting lipstick on a pig. I pity the next coach if nothing else changes.
I don't, it will just show that it wasn't the coaches fault and fans will call for his head as well
That signature would have been irrelevant had Carlton matched the Crows $$$. Suspect it was an agreement to terms if Carlton didn't cough up. That said, it would explain Eddie's form and headset in 2013, so perhaps people can cut MM some slack on this issue.
Nori
Club Legend
- Nov 16, 2014
- 1,606
- 3,824
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I just saw Mick's round 8 report.
It appears Malthouse's definition of a very good side is any side that beats Carlton. It's probably time to acknowledge that Carlton are actually making these sides look like very good sides.
... and that's a bit of an indictment on his performance I would have thought.
It appears Malthouse's definition of a very good side is any side that beats Carlton. It's probably time to acknowledge that Carlton are actually making these sides look like very good sides.
... and that's a bit of an indictment on his performance I would have thought.
Carlton should have gone to the AFL with it to complain or they should have traded Betts in 2012
Its not Mick's fault we are in this position. His game plan might not be the best in the country but its certainly not the worst.
And if you dont have faith that Malthouse can get the best out of players you dont understand what sort of coach he is.
Its unfortunate that we've tarnished a great coach with piss poor effort and skill out on the field.
My heart really goes out to Mick
I hope the players switch the * on and get a win for him before his time with us is over.
Sorry Mick - sorry on behalf of the Carlton football club
And if you dont have faith that Malthouse can get the best out of players you dont understand what sort of coach he is.
Its unfortunate that we've tarnished a great coach with piss poor effort and skill out on the field.
My heart really goes out to Mick
I hope the players switch the * on and get a win for him before his time with us is over.
Sorry Mick - sorry on behalf of the Carlton football club
They are equal 7th, there are about 13 good sides this season. This has been an even year so far
To be fair to Mick, the board does stink. But that doesn't absolve him of everything else that has happened on the field and with the list. He is daring the board to sack him, surely he will be gone by the end of the day.
it is not the length of the injury list, it is what depth you have to cover those players and what kind of core you have still. Geelong still had their main forwards and backs in the line up which helps
We really don't have the depth to cover our best 25 if we get injuries
They are still a finals team
At least you had an assistant standing in the wings ready to go and made the GF that year....
HBF
Flying Scotsman
- Sep 24, 2002
- 156,160
- 100,963
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Betts' agent tweeted that this statement is 100% untrue.
When has an agent ever said anything true?
He was s**t.
Been on the board and around the club the whole time these dickheads have been stinking the place up.
Well liked.
Good grief ...
HBF
Flying Scotsman
- Sep 24, 2002
- 156,160
- 100,963
- AFL Club
- Carlton
From the sounds of what Andy Maher said, there will be a challenge to the current board. And we need a strong board that isn't aligned to the Pratts or especially Mathieson.
Sarcasm?
Nope
jmac70
On the porch
Forgive my intrusion HBF but do you think your board might act on Mick today? Whilst the Betts thing may be true it does seem that Mick is determined to make Trigg look bad. It seems that the situation has reached such a damaging level that the club may have to take immediate action. If they install Laidley as the caretaker now you will at least have some stability for the rest of the year whilst giving young players more opportunity.
- Status
