Strategy Blair Hartley Project 2015 II

[Infamy]

Super interesting point you raise! As you say why trade him now for 25 when the AFL will give them pick 5 for him next year if someone throws enough coin his way.

A first round pick needs $600k+ per year, no way would he get that

 

[tigs2010]

AFL could scrap compo next year too so you'd wanna be wary of that.

 

[sregit]

Motlop would make us a genuine premiership threat.

On that basis it couldn't possibly happen as god doesn't love Richmond supporters

if you're a long time richmond supporter you gave up any belief in a God.

 

[Stylo]

I think the reasoning behind it is two fold:
If Danger goes it's to one club. Geelong.

How do you know this? I've heard from a few different sources that the Pies are right into him, and while he wants to be closer to home his primary consideration is going to a team that will contend fairly soon.

 

[manboob]

Just going by an interview where his manager said "it's Adelaide or Geelong". Also I think the Pies have vastly overrated their list but that's me (physically they are a very small team).
http://www.9jumpin.com.au/show/aflsundayfootyshow/videos/4295248914001/

 

[tigs2010]

Just going by an interview where his manager said "it's Adelaide or Geelong". Also I think the Pies have vastly overrated their list but that's me (physically they are a very small team).
http://www.9jumpin.com.au/show/aflsundayfootyshow/videos/4295248914001/

Been saying for years the Pies have way too many short people. They're also a pretty poorly skilled team.

 

[THE_GUN]

bennell - fmd

no chance we can get him , we are dreaming

 

[telsor]

Consider Yarran's lack of effort recently, I don't want him.

If you don't put in when your team is struggling, you don't deserve to make it to a better team.

 

[captain blood 17]

Its actually a treloar thread

Whatev's. Point still remains captain correction.


Sent from my iPad using righteous man power.

 

[_RT_]

Motlop first round pick no more. Geelong will take that so they can the on trade it for Henderson. Yarran second round pick no more no less. Obviously not happy at Carlton and not worth a first on current output. Blair & Dan need to get it done.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Motlop first round pick no more. Geelong will take that so they can the on trade it for Henderson. Yarran second round pick no more no less. Obviously not happy at Carlton and not worth a first on current output. Blair & Dan need to get it done.

NFW , one or the other or neither, can't afford to have two blokes who choose when they play and when they don't in the same side, bad enough having one. Nor should the club use the first two picks of the one draft to get them , it would be a move that destroys the list .
Blokes already on the list are playing VFL for the same reason .

 

[wart101]

As good as done, will be a Tiger.

sauce?

 

[Rich o man]

How do you know this? I've heard from a few different sources that the Pies are right into him, and while he wants to be closer to home his primary consideration is going to a team that will contend fairly soon.

So this weekend is our Danger Cup.

 

[no orange peeler]

We are getting treloar , Motlop and Kruezer .
Won't have our first pick , astbury , McDonough and possibly our 2nd.
Oliver will be taken with 3rd pick .

would be paying 3.50 for the flag if this happens

 

[Toadvine]

People should remember how poor Higgins was last year for the dogs off half back. He was banished to the VFL because he was so unaccountable.
Yes Higgins might have been dropped because they knew he would leave but Carlton don't have the talent on their list to take that option IMO.

I think Yarran could turn it around in a similar way....

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Carlton entering the fray they want a KPP if the loose Henderson to Geelong , Geelong interested in Yarran if they loose Motlop . None of geelong's tradeable talls appeal to Carlton but astbury, Elton and Griffiths do .

 

[a_fighting_fury]

....we are setting up for long term success, no shortcuts & have been doing so since 2010. no need to ruin it now, we are slowly getting there & once there should be able to stay there a while

quoted for truth -


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[SumTingWong]

We are getting treloar , Motlop and Kruezer .
Won't have our first pick , astbury , McDonough and possibly our 2nd.
Oliver will be taken with 3rd pick .

Could you be more specific?

 

[TimmytheTiger]

Is it three players that we have to drop from the senior list at the end of the year for the Draft? If so, who do we think is on the way out? Axel would be one, Newman potentially another - McDonough?, Arnott?, Petterd?

 

[Ancient Tiger]

This is a Motlop thread, but, i would offer both nuts, my big toe and some back hair to land Bennell. He is the one. A superstar.


Sent from my iPad using righteous man power.

I'd offer him some pepsi but from what I hear he is not a pepsi man!

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

someone said newy will get another year. he is cooked. me personally id retire newman and foley delist arnot and Gordon. don't think dea will be here next year. upgrade 1 or 2 rookies

 

[TimmytheTiger]

You will love his finger twirl in a Tigers jumper. Don't kid yourself.

I would love it. I would start that sh** around my lounge room in front of the telly.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Yarran,Motlop,Edwards lighting up the 'G on Grand Final day would be a sight for sore Tiger Eyes

Going back to back aswell.

 

[Morro]

People should remember how poor Higgins was last year for the dogs off half back. He was banished to the VFL because he was so unaccountable.
Yes Higgins might have been dropped because they knew he would leave but Carlton don't have the talent on their list to take that option IMO.

I think Yarran could turn it around in a similar way....

That is a really good comparison. Both outside skillful players being played out of position in poor teams.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Danger to the cats
Cats 1st pick to the crows
Motlop to the Tigers
Tigers 1st pick to the Crows.

Crows loose Dangfield. Gain 2 1st round picks.
Cats loose Motlop and 1st pick. Gain Danger
Tigers loose 1st pick. Gain Motlop.

Win win IMO

Thats very workable.