Mega Thread Trade/Free Agency Open Discussion - RFC Forum

[Drofder]

Hmmm. North and Jeremy on our forward line. At last, a genuine dual pronged attack.

 

[Tenilius]

All noise. He needs to consent & surely that ship has sailed.

Yeah just GWS trying to force the Pies into a better deal.

 

[UpTheGuts]

Stanton v Treloar

Treloar is better, but it's not a thrashing.
One costs 2 first rounders. The other is free.

 

[johnno77]

So another day and another big bag of * all. Not sure what's worse, not stitching up a deal early in trade week, or stitching up a deal like the Hampson one too early in trade week.

A bag of s**t or a bag of * all? Take your pick. Option C is obviously a bag of dicks.

 

[UpTheGuts]

Yeah just GWS trying to force the Pies into a better deal.

There was a lot of brinkmanship in the Adams/ Shaw deal as I recall

 

[Richo is God]

View attachment 183657

Stanton v Treloar

Treloar is better, but it's not a thrashing.
One costs 2 first rounders. The other is free.

Maybe we should trade Vlastuin for Stanton then, seeing how much better Stantons stats are

 

[_Wang_]

So another day and another big bag of **** all. Not sure what's worse, not stitching up a deal early in trade week, or stitching up a deal like the Hampson one too early in trade week.

A bag of s**t or a bag of **** all? Take your pick. Option C is obviously a bag of dicks.

Now now lets not be testy we will get Yarran for pick 12 and Townsend for our third rounder..

Its a great result!!

Its all at Tiger land

 

[Groupie_]

View attachment 183657

Stanton v Treloar

Treloar is better, but it's not a thrashing.
One costs 2 first rounders. The other is free.

again ?

 

[SnakeMan86]

Now now lets not be testy we will get Yarran for pick 12 and Townsend for our third rounder..

Its a great result!!

Its all at Tiger land

Id hate Yarran for pick 12, second rounder at best.

 

[Kyusss]

Gubby Allen is making a bit of a goose of himself IMO, if Treloar is open to the highest bidder well Richmond are the highest bigger, either trade him to Richmond (or if there is a higher bidder) or stop talking about how it isn't a cert he is going to the pies.

 

[UpTheGuts]

Maybe we should trade Vlastuin for Stanton then, seeing how much better Stantons stats are

Vlastuin is not a midfielder. Keep up

 

[UpTheGuts]

Gubby Allen is making a bit of a goose of himself IMO, if Treloar is open to the highest bidder well Richmond are the highest bigger, either trade him to Richmond (or if there is a higher bidder) or stop talking about how it isn't a cert he is going to the pies.

Yeah I suspect we are not involved.
If the player doesn't want us, hard to force the issue

Players should be able to be traded by their club up to 5 years. Payoff of reducing FA to 6 years

 

[Groupie_]

Gubby Allen is making a bit of a goose of himself IMO, if Treloar is open to the highest bidder well Richmond are the highest bigger, either trade him to Richmond (or if there is a higher bidder) or stop talking about how it isn't a cert he is going to the pies.

the guy is just trying to cover up the fact that hes helping out his old club

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Surely Treloar's girlfriend would still get the job if she decided to come to Richmond right? After all, it is completely legit and she was selected on merit right?

 

[fightingfury]

Brett Anderson just said that treloar deal to Collingwood to deal is wrapped up and will be concluded by Thursday. Can we put this one to bed now?

 

[Drofder]

If we're gonna compare Stanton and Treloar, then we might as well compare Yarran and Garlett.

What did Melbourne pay for Garlett ? 61 and 79 for Garlett plus 83 back from Carlton ? And now they want what.....pick 12 for Yarran ? Hah hah hah.....they're funny those guys.

It shouldnt even be a mid second round for Yarran. It should be a LATE second round.

Thanks to Final Siren for the comparison.

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

View attachment 183657

Stanton v Treloar

Treloar is better, but it's not a thrashing.
One costs 2 first rounders. The other is free.

6.6 contested possessions. He would be dead last among our mids for CP, and that includes Ellis and Lambert. The club has said they want inside grunt.

A 30 year old seagull with a WADA ban hanging over his head is not the answer.

 

[Wacky Tiger]

Brett Anderson just said that treloar deal to Collingwood to deal is wrapped up and will be concluded by Thursday. Can we put this one to bed now?

On thursday when it gets confirmed yeah sure. But not yet. We have Rich booked in to talk about tomorrow so id rather keep this Treloar talk going till thursday

 

[RobsJourney]

View attachment 183669

If we're gonna compare Stanton and Treloar, then we might as well compare Yarran and Garlett.

What did Melbourne pay for Garlett ? 61 and 79 for Garlett plus 83 back from Carlton ? And now they want what.....pick 12 for Yarran ? Hah hah hah.....they're funny those guys.

It shouldnt even be a mid second round for Yarran. It should be a LATE second round.

Thanks to Final Siren for the comparison.

Ouch.. look how many more goals Garlett has. That said Yarran has mainly been played as a backman..

 

[UpTheGuts]

6.6 contested possessions. He would be dead last among our mids for CP, and that includes Ellis and Lambert. The club has said they want inside grunt.

A 30 year old seagull with a WADA ban hanging over his head is not the answer.

6.8 CP for Ellis. Less for Kamdyn.
4.1 for Hunt.

25% more tackles than our captain, though...

 

[_Wang_]

Id hate Yarran for pick 12, second rounder at best.

Sorry dude I really need a sarcasm emoji

 

[TiggerMan22]

Unfortunately, his 3 finals have got progressively worse. As our Captain, and supposed best player, he has to stand up in finals. If he doesn't he should take more heat than others.
In saying that, I have faith that by the end of his career, this will not be his legacy.

Bullshit.
He played well in a close game, bad in a bad game, then bad in a close game.
Only 1 of those was a unexpected bad performance.
He couldnt do anything against Port when the whole team is so tired just from making finals.

 

[Roachy8]

Sorry dude I really need a sarcasm emoji

Isn't that your avatar - sort of?

 

[Drofder]

The most interesting part of Non-Trade Week every year (and to a certain extent the National Draft as well), is how much of a fool that Adrian Dildo-ro can make of himself.

I pray every year that Arsendon keep him in a job. He's well suited to them.

 

[David3030]

View attachment 183669

If we're gonna compare Stanton and Treloar, then we might as well compare Yarran and Garlett.

What did Melbourne pay for Garlett ? 61 and 79 for Garlett plus 83 back from Carlton ? And now they want what.....pick 12 for Yarran ? Hah hah hah.....they're funny those guys.

It shouldnt even be a mid second round for Yarran. It should be a LATE second round.

Thanks to Final Siren for the comparison.

Based on these stats picks after 61 and 79 are sufficient using Garlett as a guide