Rank Richmond's Players from 1 to 30

[Mr Commissioner]

I am an idiot but the mods think the thread idea is fun.

Rank the list from 1 to 30.


EFA: DrMike

 

[Mogwai]

seriously that insecure about that fluked GF place?

 

[Squibbs]

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

relton roberts

 

[Mr Commissioner]

I'll start.

1. Alex Rance

 

[ReaperX]

I'll start.

1. Alex Rance

Pfft what is this crap, everybody knows that Troy Chaplin is our best player.

n00b.

 

[Tiger Toffee]

Pfft what is this crap, everybody knows that Troy Chaplin is our best player.

n00b.

I thought it was Richard Lounder closely followed by Mark Pitura.

 

[ReaperX]

I thought it was Richard Lounder closely followed by Mark Pitura.

Well sure, if we're talking all past players, I guess those guys have a case... however if we're doing that, it's difficult to go past Jordan McMahon for mine.

What a true RFC legend that guy was.

 

[Nostradumbass]

Great thread, would read again.

 

[Gosha]

2. Steven Morris

 

[RememberRoyce]

3. Ben Cousins

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

4. Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls

 

[Gosha]

5. Ben Nason

 

[CoggaRules]

6. Billy Nicholls

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

At his best, Cotchin is number 1. But overall I would say:

1. Rance
2. Cotchin
3. Deledio
4. Riewoldt
5. Martin
6. Miles
7. Edwards
8. B.Ellis
9. Houli
10. Vlastuin
11. Vickery
12. Maric
13. Grimes
14. Grigg
15. Conca
16. McIntosh
17. Chaplin
18. Yarran
19. Batchelor
20. Lennon
21. Marcon's best mate
22. Hunt
23. Lloyd
24. Griffiths
25. C.Ellis
26. Astbury
27. Morris
28. Hampson
29. Menadue
30. McBean

I expect Conca, Lennon, Griffiths, C.Ellis and Menadue to rise on that list this year. Haven't seen the rest play (other than Elton and Drummond)

 

[Foley#41]

Want to know which club is closer.

Richmond is much closer:

Compared to:

It's no contest really.

 

[Bobby Sands]

Want to know which club is closer.

Rank your list 1-30.

What you got?

 

[Bobby Sands]

14. Grigg
15. Conca
16. McIntosh
17. Chaplin
18. Yarran

Damn

 

[SunshineBoy]

At his best, Cotchin is number 1. But overall I would say:

1. Rance
2. Cotchin
3. Deledio
4. Riewoldt
5. Martin
6. Miles
7. Edwards
8. B.Ellis
9. Houli
10. Vlastuin
11. Vickery
12. Maric
13. Grimes
14. Grigg
15. Conca
16. McIntosh
17. Chaplin
18. Yarran
19. Batchelor
20. Lennon
21. Marcon's best mate
22. Hunt
23. Lloyd
24. Griffiths
25. C.Ellis
26. Astbury
27. Morris
28. Hampson
29. Menadue
30. McBean

I expect Conca, Lennon, Griffiths, C.Ellis and Menadue to rise on that list this year. Haven't seen the rest play (other than Elton and Drummond)

surely you jest, Mcbean is the next big thing, the great white hope, the next jack watts

 

[tugga]

Top 30 of our list as of right now as I rate them:
1: Rance
2: Cotchin
3: Riewoldt
4: Deledio
5: Martin
6: Edwards
7: B. Ellis
8: Vickery
9: Miles
10: Maric
11: Grimes
12: Houli
13: Yarran
14: Vlastuin
15: McIntosh
16: Chaplin
17: Grigg
18: Lennon
19: Lambert
20: C. Ellis
21: Batchelor
22: Conca
23: Hunt
24: Moore
25: McBean
26: Griffiths
27: Menadue
28: Lloyd
28: Townsend
29: Astbury
30: Drummond

 

[Severe]

Has Relton Roberts been posted?

 

[SunshineBoy]

Has Relton Roberts been posted?

yep
one of the first listed

 

[RememberRoyce]

1. Josh Kennedy
2. Luke Shuey
3.Matt Priddis
4. Andrew Gaff
5. Nicknat
6. Mark Lecras
7. Jeremy Mcgovern
8. Shannon Hurn
9. Jack Darling
10. Brad Sheppard
11. Elliot Yeo
12. Wellingham
13. Mackenzie
14. Masten
15. Jack Redden (feeling he'll be top 5 by midway point of the year.)
16. Jetta
17. Schofield
18. Dom Sheed
19. Liam Duggan
20. Jaime Cripps
21. Josh Hill
22. Mitchell Brown
23. Scott Lycett
24. Xavier Ellis
25. Sam Butler
26. Mark Hutchings
27. Jamie Bennell
28. Jackson Nelson
29. Fraser Mcinnis
30. Luke Partington

Wow.
Serious lack of depth there eh!

Fingers crossed not too many injuries...

 

[Mr Commissioner]

Wow.
Serious lack of depth there eh!

Fingers crossed not too many injuries...

List starts to fall away after the first 20 - yours, around the 10 mark.

 

[Severe]

yep
one of the first listed

Ok....Sam Lonergan?