Always a fun one I get requested to do each year, so I thought I may as well go again this year and try my luck. Those wanting a go, feel free to put your attempts below and see if you can beat Collingwood's selections or possibly mine.
Hinesight (Collingwood's selections):
MSD:
3: Ashley...
Hinesight
17. Oliver Henry
19. Finlay Macrae
23. Reef McInnes
30. Caleb Poulter
31. Liam McMahon
44. Beau McCreery
Rookie draft:
13. Jack Ginnivan
28. Isaac Chugg
*Of the picks. And I have my full review and grade on ESPN. But the basics are Macrae, Reef and Ginnivan are three picks I out and...
Always a bit of fun. Pitting myself against the club and then can come back in a few years time to review how right/wrong/close or otherwise.
Hinesight:
40: Jay Rantall
45: Trent Bianco
55: Trey Ruscoe
Notes: All suitable selections. Rantall and Bianco both represent relative value without...
Hi all,
This year as per tradition I'm recruiting for Collingwood in the annual Bigfooty Official Phantom Draft.
A link for all those who wish to follow it: https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/big-footy-phantom-draft.1231744/
--
My first selections:
And here I had planned all day to...
Competition link: https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/big-footy-phantom-draft-trial-run-starts-thursday-9am.1223054/
*note: Academy bidding is not included in this draft under the rules devised by those running the competition as a way to get a feel for where each player would fit into the...
A place to post your trade suggestions.
With Boston unable to trade for Anthony Davis this year due to the Rose rule and LAL not wanting to get rid of all their young pieces and picks and Pelicans ideally not wanting to send Davis to another team in their conference. Why shouldn't the Raptors...
*Hastily put together but hopefully easy enough to follow. Busy weekend so didn't have the time to do it earlier.
Hinesight:
ND:
Isaac Quaynor – bid on earlier than I’d feel comfortable with talents I rate more highly to be available at next pick *38 on draft board
Will Kelly – same story as...
I'd happily go without Teague in such a trade, but the NBA Trade Machine has the deal working with Teague, he isn't an essential component, I'd personally prefer Rose though he at this time can't be traded.
The rule with trading picks is you can't trade back to back first round picks.
The...
I thought this might be the best place to ask as I've failed to find this anywhere.
I'm looking for Buckley's long kick season stats from 1993-2007.
Even better if there are competition long kick stats during those years, or better again all-time long kicking stats for a season and where any...
Phantom Drafts:
5/10/2018: Pre trade period AFL Draft first round phantom draft: http://www.espn.com.au/afl/story/_/id/24885902/afl-draft-first-round-phantom-goes-where
25/10/2018 2 round post trade period phantom draft...
2016
Knightsight:
30. Willem Drew (9 in my power rankings)
45. *Brad Scheer (16 on draft board - bid) likely matched. Given that Dylan Clarke (20 in power rankings)
50. *Lachlan Tiziani (21 in power rankings - bid) likely matched. Given that Ben Ronke (25 power rankings - actual position 17 in...
Phantom Draft:
October Phantom Draft (first two rounds) 25/10/2017: http://www.espn.com.au/afl/story/_/id/21134708/knightmare-october-phantom-draft-first-two-rounds
November Phantom Draft (first three rounds) 13/11/2017...
As I've been receiving questions in my 2015 thread I thought it time to create a 2016 thread.
This for now will be a Q+A thread and feature my weekly articles.
Once my first draft profiles and power rankings have been posted onto ESPN (will let you all know when they have been) and have been...
Collingwood Almanac 2016:
Player value rankings:
--Untouchable--
1. Brodie Grundy: A best five ruckman in the competition today and the best ruckman in the game under the age of 24.
2. Darcy Moore: Still a developing key forward, but a rapidly improving player and has the mix of attributes...
The idea came from NBA inspiration, viewing a video about the 50 greatest NBA basketball players.
Then the question came up in my mind. Who are the 50 greatest Pies of all time?
As brownlow medalists: Syd Coventry, Albert Collier, Harry Collier, Marcus Whelan, Des Fothergill, Len Thompson...
Will this be the year I outperform our superstar recruiting team including Derek Hine, Matt Rendell and Dom Milesi and company?
Hinesight (Collingwood selections):
32: Brayden Sier: Tall, strong bodied midfielder. Have not sighted and this is very early for a midfielder who only managed 16 and...
Collingwood Almanac 2015:
2015 Best 22 (my interpretation - fully healthy end of season preferred team):
B: Brayden Maynard Nathan Brown Marley Williams
HB: Tom Langdon Jonathon Marsh Matthew Scharenberg
CEN: Steele Sidebottom Scott Pendlebury Travis Varcoe
HF: Alex Fasolo Travis Cloke...
2015 power rankings:
-- Top five on list quality --
1. Jacob Hopper (NSW - GWS ACADEMY - MID)
2. Clayton Oliver (VIC – MID)
3. Jacob Weitering (VIC – KPD)
4. Callum Mills (NSW - SYDNEY ACADEMY – MID)
-- Top ten on list quality --
5. Ben Keays (QLD – BRISBANE ACADEMY – MID/FWD)
6. Matthew...
It will seem like a big call for those not aware or with little knowledge of Wilt and naturally there will be debate as the range of sports people over such a long period of time in such a wide range of sports is so wide and diverse but Wilt is the only guy I'd make that statement of and I don't...
Hinesight - who Collingwood went with..
5. De Goey (14 in my power rankings - though with Heeney, Moore and Steele higher on my draft board that would essentially make him 11 of those live available selections on my draft board)
9. Moore (4 in my power rankings)
30. Maynard (32 in my power...
Who Collingwood seem to want based on a combination of media rumours and common sense:
Pick 5: Presumably De Goey is is the pick and the guy Collingwood want. Perhaps they also have Laverde or Langford on the shortlist for that selection. Perhaps they like Pickett though it looks like he will be...
Interview with Derek Hine - http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/exclusive-the-derek-hine-interview-the-bigfooty-collingwood-podcast-2014.1062679/
For summarised notes on Derek Hine interview see page 5, post 106 of Collingwood Almanac.
My interpretation of the 2014 Best 22 (Fully...
Gaining knowledge in your own game often grows from knowledge in the games of others.
With the NBA my no.2 sport and as the keen researcher I am, I've been doing some research into the great coaches and how they found success beyond simply the playing personnel they had at their disposal.
The...
A yearly favourite of mine is putting myself up against master recruiter Derek Hine and seeing what I can do.
I've added some insight into my thoughts on the eventual Collingwood selections and who I personally would have selected.
Hinesight (who Derek Hine selected):
Pick 6: Matthew...
My prediction of what Derek Hine's draft board looks like going off media rumours and the chances of them being available at our selections:
1. Boyd (unavailable - will go pick 1)
2. Aish (50% chance of availability at pick 6)
3. Scharenberg (90% chance of availability at pick 6. 50% chance of...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.