Martin Clarke v Bryce Gibbs

[The Royal Sampler]

Originally Posted by parrot

Rusling! Sorry, that is funny. The guy that runs fast in straight line, but is incapable of taking a contested mark. Yeah I'm sure the Weagles would take him for Judd. lol. Think you've been reading too much HUN-Collingwood-Newsletter. Judd rates our list as being more talented and having a much better future than yours. More important than a BF poll I'd suggest.

Sure he does. Which explains why our young list just missed out on a GF, and yours just missed out on a spoon.

Incidentally, Rusling > Kennedy.

[mdc]

Originally Posted by The Royal Sampler

Sure he does. Which explains why our young list just missed out on a GF, and yours just missed out on a spoon.

Incidentally, Rusling > Kennedy.

Wait for the Kennedy -> WC trade to become official, and then parrot will wholeheartedly agree with you.
"We conned WC into taking a dud..." and so forth and so on.

Right sir?

[parrot]

[one_twelve112]

Originally Posted by parrot

Well said.....

[Modra93]

ha judd prefers gibbs of marty clarke haha

[The Royal Sampler]

Originally Posted by Modra93

ha judd prefers gibbs of marty clarke haha

Who is this "gibbs of marty clarke" of whom you speak? You make marty clarke sound like a town.

Anyway, we just signed Marty Clarke v. 2.0, otherwise referred to as Kevin Dyas. You keep selling your team for gun players, we'll keep picking them up with our last pick in the rookie draft.

[Magpie Mick]

Quite a big lead considering Clarke was a Rookie who never played the game before and cost the pies nothing whilst Gibbs was a numbner one pick in the National draft!

Well done to the pies recruiters. Lets hope that our next Irish kid, Dyas, is half as good as Marty. It is said that Dyas is more advanced than Clarke at the same time, scary isn't it!!!

[Jason_K]

Originally Posted by Magpie Mick

Quite a big lead considering Clarke was a Rookie who never played the game before and cost the pies nothing whilst Gibbs was a numbner one pick in the National draft!

Well done to the pies recruiters. Lets hope that our next Irish kid, Dyas, is half as good as Marty. It is said that Dyas is more advanced than Clarke at the same time, scary isn't it!!!

Whoops. Forgot to bump this thread after the Filth game in my post-game celebrations

I think the answer was fairly clear during last week's game

[Jason_K]

Just for referencing, the results when I bumped this thread:

Clarke - 131
Gibbs - 96

[hellfire]

Originally Posted by Jason_K

Whoops. Forgot to bump this thread after the Filth game in my post-game celebrations

I think the answer was fairly clear during last week's game

I don't think one game can say anything. Stupid comment.

In saying that I'd take Gibbs, have always been a fan.

[HBK619]

I have a personal feeling Clarke might end up just a flash in the pan fantastic player(Just personal opinion remember), might turn out a good average player, but I don't think we will see what we saw from him last year.

Gibbs should be a good player, but is often up and down like a yo-yo, no better proof than last week against Collingwood, would do something awful, but follow it up with something good.

Gibbs will be better, but by how much is unknown.

[parrot]

Clarke kicks round-ball like floaters, and has developed the habit of letting his opponent kick match winning goals. I guess we won't see any more of those Marty-Clarke-HUN-Collignwood-Newsletter-liftouts for a while. Too bad.

[dylan_mike]

Put them both on the trade table and I guarrantee that 16 teams will pick Gibbs before Clarke.

[hellfire]

Originally Posted by dylan_mike

Put them both on the trade table and I guarrantee that 16 teams will pick Gibbs before Clarke.

...Number 1 pick vs. a rookie.

[Jason_K]

Originally Posted by hellfire

...Number 1 pick vs. a rookie.

Didn't stop some of your supporters genuinely believing and arguing that Clarke was better