How do Hawthorn, Saints and Freo fans feel...

Major Colvin · Sep 13, 2006

about how their clubs missed out on the greatest player ever in Chris Judd?

Ball and Hodge aren't near him - and Freo missed out on all of them.

Weagles wouldn't win a premiership without him.

blues76 · Sep 13, 2006

Keithy George said:
about how their clubs missed out on the greatest player ever in Chris Judd?

Ball and Hodge aren't near him - and Freo missed out on all of them. Weagles wouldn't win a premiership without him.

hahaha...this will get nasty...but judd is the best by a country mile...

melbournemartin · Sep 13, 2006

I remember Hodge made a surge last year and had people saying he was better than Judd. I believe Hodge has a better kick but that is about all. Ball is behind both imo but the injuries probably have a fair bit to do with it.

mighty_sainters · Sep 13, 2006

Judd wont be at eagles much longer. After his contract he will be back and playing in victoria. (either with bulldogs, stkilda, carlton, collingwood or melbourne)

Major Colvin · Sep 13, 2006

mighty_sainters said:
Judd wont be at eagles much longer. After his contract he will be back and playing in victoria. (either with bulldogs, stkilda, carlton, collingwood or melbourne)

He was a Demon fan you know. Come home Juddy.

Won't happen, he'll be at the Weagles for his entire career

Gary Shadforth · Sep 13, 2006

Judd is great. But I'm more than happy with Hodgey ..... actually excited!

zero · Sep 13, 2006

mighty_sainters said:
Judd wont be at eagles much longer. After his contract he will be back and playing in victoria. (either with bulldogs, stkilda, carlton, collingwood or melbourne)

reiwoltd is far more likely to leave the saints than judd the eagles.

decent chance of winning a premiership playing in the west

TigerGlory · Sep 13, 2006

Its not really all that bad though.

Hodge and Ball, been fantastic players for their respective clubs.

Would take any of the three to be honest, probably the cheapest.

Hap Hapablap · Sep 13, 2006

mighty_sainters said:
Judd wont be at eagles much longer. After his contract he will be back and playing in victoria. (either with bulldogs, stkilda, carlton, collingwood or melbourne)

are you god? ffs

Major Colvin · Sep 13, 2006

TigerGlory said:
Its not really all that bad though.

Hodge and Ball, been fantastic players for their respective clubs.

Would take any of the three to be honest, probably the cheapest.

Yes BUT..

If Judd was at St.K they would have won a premiership already. He is simply a class above

Philhawk · Sep 13, 2006

What a stupid thread.

How do Melbourne fans feel knowing that they drafting Luke Molan in front of players like McGuire, Dal Santo, Mitchell, Seaby, Hansen and Waite?

Hindsight is a beautiful thing. Sure, perhaps if we had had it again, we might have drafted Judd, but i'm more than happy with Hodge. He's proven himself to be one of the elite midfielders in the comp (Judd is ofcourse at a different leve), but Hodgey himself is still a midfielder any other team would kill for.

Roughie · Sep 13, 2006

Judd is a superstar, Of course I wish we had him.... But im still very happy with Hodge and to be honest with you I dont even think about the whole what if we had Judd.

Major Colvin · Sep 13, 2006

philhawk said:
What a stupid thread.

How do Melbourne fans feel knowing that they drafting Luke Molan in front of players like McGuire, Dal Santo, Mitchell, Seaby, Hansen and Waite?

Bad - every club has their clangers

But we're talking about JUDD. How does it feel?

Philhawk · Sep 13, 2006

Keithy George said:
Bad - every club has their clangers

Thanks, you just answered how the abovementioned fans feel.

Smell The Glove · Sep 13, 2006

Judd is indeed well above just about every other player in the league, but neither Hodge nor Ball had had two shoulder recos before they got drafted, had they? So only a complete nuff nuff would say that Hawthorn and St Kilda should have taken Judd, because for all they knew he could have re-injured a shoulder and never played a game. The rest is history, as they say. Fremantle on the other hand.........WTF WERE THEY THINKING!!!!!!!!!

Major Colvin · Sep 13, 2006

philhawk said:
Thanks, you just answered how the abovementioned fans feel.

You missed the rest of my post, champ.

It's hurting isnt it?

Major Colvin · Sep 13, 2006

whippersnipper said:
Judd is indeed well above just about every other player in the league, but neither Hodge nor Ball had had two shoulder recos before they got drafted, had they? So only a complete nuff nuff would say that Hawthorn and St Kilda should have taken Judd, because for all they knew he could have re-injured a shoulder and never played a game. The rest is history, as they say. Fremantle on the other hand.........WTF WERE THEY THINKING!!!!!!!!!

The thread has nothing to do with who they should have taken. I'm simply asking how it feels in hindsight knowing that the greatest player possibly ever could've been playing for their club

Doggy · Sep 13, 2006

Keithy George said:
Bad - every club has their clangers

But we're talking about JUDD. How does it feel?

Keiran MacGuinness - Oh dear
Brad Murphy

Upgrayedd · Sep 13, 2006

mighty_sainters said:
Judd wont be at eagles much longer. After his contract he will be back and playing in victoria. (either with bulldogs, stkilda, carlton, collingwood or melbourne)

he extended it, and has said he wants to remain an eagle
he got picked third because hodge was playing better then him, and judd already had a shoulder re-construction* which probably influenced judd and ball being picked before him
im not 100% sure he had a re-construction, i just know he had injury problems with his shoulder

haze.13 · Sep 13, 2006

No argument that Judd is a star, but...

There are a lot of great players that have won personal accolades and not managed to grab that premiership they so long desired. I hope Judd gets one (won't be this year) but well you never know do you? His age and the eagles don't quite fit of you know what I mean. They'll be rebuilding in two seasons and then where will he be?

Personally I am happy with Hodgey, he is a natural leader which is what we needed at the time. Judd has had leadership forced on him this season and in my opinion I don't think he's seems all that comfortable with it. Ball will win a premiership - and will hold up the cup, Hodge will do the same at least once. But will Judd

Philhawk · Sep 13, 2006

Keithy George said:
You missed the rest of my post, champ.

It's hurting isnt it?

Not really. We got a gun 3 gun players in Hodge, Mitchell and Brown out of it. What did Melbourne get out of the draft?

Smell The Glove · Sep 13, 2006

Keithy George said:
The thread has nothing to do with who they should have taken. I'm simply asking how it feels in hindsight knowing that the greatest player possibly ever could've been playing for their club

Then its just a pointless thread, designed just to stir shyt with Hawthorn and St Kilda supporters.

Upgrayedd · Sep 13, 2006

philhawk said:
Not really. We got a gun 3 gun players in Hodge, Mitchell and Brown out of it. What did Melbourne get out of the draft?

Brad Miller, and two other hacks i think are de-listed

Major Colvin · Sep 13, 2006

whippersnipper said:
Then its just a pointless thread, designed just to stir shyt with Hawthorn and St Kilda supporters.

Well, yes.

Smell The Glove · Sep 13, 2006

Keithy George said:
Well, yes.

Point taken. Proceed

Log In or Create New Account

How do Hawthorn, Saints and Freo fans feel...

Norm Smith Medallist

Team Captain

Brownlow Medallist

Premium Platinum

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

I'm off to Nepal to become a mountain goat.

Norm Smith Medallist

Delicious

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Delicious

Cancelled

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

A Vote for Clive is a Vote for Justice

Senior List

Delicious

Cancelled

A Vote for Clive is a Vote for Justice

Norm Smith Medallist

Cancelled

How do Hawthorn, Saints and Freo fans feel...

Similar threads