OFFICIAL - Judd deal is off

Mr.X · Oct 10, 2007

Just got back from a meeting in the CBD and the blues are now resigned to the fact the they'll struggle to make the deal directly with WCE.

There isn't enough time left in trade week to come up with a complicated 3 or 4 way club deal that will keep everyone happy, so the pick 3+20+Kennedy deal is off the table. The deal should have been done by now, and time is a real factor

Judd is aware of this, and is extremly disappointed. Looks like he will nominate for the PSD with a huge price attached.

Tigers are very much in the mix, and there may soon be a higher profile player at RFC traded away to make room in their cap. They intend to speak to Judd and get him keen on the idea of coming to Tigerland.

Disappointing for all parties concerned.. just proves that draft week rarely gets any real results

Thrawn · Oct 10, 2007

A meeting in the CBD

Rofl.

bluesforever · Oct 10, 2007

The source is? You being at the meeting??

hellfire · Oct 10, 2007

ok. .

bluejoker · Oct 10, 2007

Yeah whatever, thats why they just said on SEN its a certainty and that Kennedy just has to say yes and its done.

If all else fails then we give 3, 20 and Bower or 3 and Walker

Carn the Coasters · Oct 10, 2007

As if they wouldn't give up pick 1 if necessary. Load of crap.

_RT_ · Oct 10, 2007

I was interested in one of the news casts tonight they had an interview with Judd at Perth airport and one of the reporters asked about Richmond to which Judd replied, something along the lines of when something is worked out you guys will be the first to know at a press conference the day after.

Messenger · Oct 10, 2007

Carlton still have something West Coast want.......

Dogs Rule · Oct 10, 2007

I don't care where he ends up to be honest....just get it done!!!

Banga19 · Oct 10, 2007

Mr.X said:
Just got back from a meeting in the CBD and the blues are now resigned to the fact the they'll struggle to make the deal directly with WCE.

There isn't enough time left in trade week to come up with a complicated 3 or 4 way club deal that will keep everyone happy, so the pick 3+20+Kennedy deal is off the table. The deal should have been done by now, and time is a real factor

Judd is aware of this, and is extremly disappointed. Looks like he will nominate for the PSD with a huge price attached.

Tigers are very much in the mix, and there may soon be a higher profile player at RFC traded away to make room in their cap. They intend to speak to Judd and get him keen on the idea of coming to Tigerland.

Disappointing for all parties concerned.. just proves that draft week rarely gets any real results

Just proves???? Just proves jack sh1t

DynamoUltra · Oct 10, 2007

If Kennedy is unsure if he wants to play for West Coast, why would they want him?

Mr.X · Oct 10, 2007

Scoff all you want, but I'm only giving you guys a heads up.

As much as I'd like to see Judd at Carlton, it's over... ain't gonna happen during this trade week.

Accept it

mjonc · Oct 10, 2007

Messenger said:
Carlton still have something West Coast want.......

Hmmmm, the 2005 Wizard Cup? :thumbsu:

Beloved · Oct 10, 2007

Funny thread...

Smash`N`Grab · Oct 10, 2007

The fact a Carlton supporter posted this makes me less sceptical

No motive to make up BS of this nature

Bombers_Forever · Oct 10, 2007

I wouldn't believe it is over........or a deal is done fr that matter

Messenger · Oct 10, 2007

mjonc said:
Hmmmm, the 2005 Wizard Cup?

That's it!

Mr.X · Oct 10, 2007

Smash`N`Grab said:
The fact a Carlton supporter posted this makes me less sceptical

No motive to make up BS of this nature

Thanks - I'd be much more pleased if the deal was done, and Judd was coming to Carlton.

I don't like giving this news, considering the positive vibes Judd arrriving at Carlton would have given, but its fact

Some Blues fans need to accept it and move on

tigers71 · Oct 10, 2007

Mr.X said:
Just got back from a meeting in the CBD and the blues are now resigned to the fact the they'll struggle to make the deal directly with WCE.

There isn't enough time left in trade week to come up with a complicated 3 or 4 way club deal that will keep everyone happy, so the pick 3+20+Kennedy deal is off the table. The deal should have been done by now, and time is a real factor

Judd is aware of this, and is extremly disappointed. Looks like he will nominate for the PSD with a huge price attached.

Tigers are very much in the mix, and there may soon be a higher profile player at RFC traded away to make room in their cap. They intend to speak to Judd and get him keen on the idea of coming to Tigerland.

Disappointing for all parties concerned.. just proves that draft week rarely gets any real results

Its not over until 2pm Friday and alot can happen until than. Just have to find another player instead of Kennedy. What about Waite !! He should go to West Coast!!

MBIB · Oct 10, 2007

DynamoUltra said:
If Kennedy is unsure if he wants to play for West Coast, why would they want him?

Unless he desperately wants to return to Melb in the future he'll play and play well for WC. Stevens nominated Collingwood and may be our captain next year.
Just like if Judd ends up at Richmond (god forbid) he'll play his guts out.

rfctigerarmy · Oct 10, 2007

Mr.X said:
Thanks - I'd be much more pleased if the deal was done, and Judd was coming to Carlton.

I don't like giving this news, considering the positive vibes Judd arrriving at Carlton would have given, but its fact

Some Blues fans need to accept it and move on

You posted this 5 minutes ago. You want the Carlton supporters who have been waiting for this for months to give up all they have hoped for and change like that?

Wrong.

walkers a legend · Oct 10, 2007

tigers71 said:
Its not over until 2pm Friday and alot can happen until than. Just have to find another player instead of Kennedy. What about Waite !! He should go to West Coast!!

nope waite is ours

Thrawn · Oct 10, 2007

Smash`N`Grab said:
No motive to make up BS of this nature

Apart from stirring the pot even further.

Smash`N`Grab · Oct 10, 2007

Thrawn said:
Apart from stirring the pot even further.

But why would he want to??

Does he have a history of trolling??

Still makes no sense to me that a Carlton supporter would make up negative BS about their own club

jack_riewoldt_rulz · Oct 10, 2007

West Coast Just Take 2# and 18#

Log In or Create New Account

Ashes: 5th Test: Jan 4-8, SCGDay 2

OFFICIAL - Judd deal is off

Premiership Player

Premium Platinum

Club Legend

Norm Smith Medallist

Senior List

Club Legend

Not A Minion

No, I’m just disappointed

Brownlow Medallist

Club Legend

Premiership Player

Premiership Player

Team Captain

Brownlow Medallist

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

No, I’m just disappointed

Premiership Player

Club Legend

Norm Smith Medallist

🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆

Norm Smith Medallist

Premium Platinum

Club Legend

Club Legend

OFFICIAL - Judd deal is off

Similar threads

Ashes: 5th Test: Jan 4-8, SCG
Day 2