BigFooty AFL Top 50: Trent Cotchin v Max Hudghton

R

Russian

Brownlow Medallist

Veteran 10k Posts Ex-Moderator

Oct 3, 2003

17,265

514

Adelaide

AFL Club

Port Adelaide

Other Teams

Centrals

• Oct 26, 2008

• #1

Trent Cotchin
(Richmond)
- or -
Max Hudghton
(St Kilda)

Who will be the better player in season 2009?
​

NB: This is a best player vote. If Sandilands beats Roughead and Roughead beats Judd, then Sandilands beats Judd​

 

Pie 4 Life

Hall of Famer

Werewolf Player Werewolf Host Draft Expert Dragons FFC - Sweet F.A. Sweet F.A. 300+ Games Played in the SFA SFA Hall of Fame

Oct 5, 2003

39,122

44,755

Dragon Island

AFL Club

Collingwood

Other Teams

Dragons FFC

• Oct 27, 2008

• #2

As much as I admire Max, Cotchin is a gun, he will come in leaps and bounds next year.

 

Armitage2Riewoldt

Brownlow Medallist

Ex-Moderator

May 23, 2008

17,001

20,676

Melbourne

AFL Club

St Kilda

• Oct 30, 2008

• #3

This is a pretty stupid vote, no?

Max is a champion in the twilight of his career...While Cotchin is a superstar in the making.

Cotchin will be deemed to have a better year, but let me say this: Hudghton will be far more valuable to us, then Cotchin would be next year.

Sure I'd do a direct swap right now, only cos Cotchin has 12 years of footy left in him. But Hudghton will be way more important than a 19 year old kid next year...I mean c'mon.

 

DoubleO7

Norm Smith Medallist

Veteran

Oct 15, 2008

7,887

50

Abroad

AFL Club

Collingwood

Other Teams

Arsenal Football Club

• Oct 30, 2008

• #4

Cotchin

 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

wheels4

All Australian

May 21, 2008

975

0

Melbourne

AFL Club

St Kilda

• Oct 30, 2008

• #5

Um Hudghton, plays FB and is the only player to beat Buddy twice in a year. it won't change next year

 

V

Virgil

Premiership Player

Veteran

Aug 16, 2007

4,978

7

Melbourne

AFL Club

North Melbourne

• Oct 30, 2008

• #6

Armitage2Riewoldt said:

This is a pretty stupid vote, no?

Max is a champion in the twilight of his career...While Cotchin is a superstar in the making.

Cotchin will be deemed to have a better year, but let me say this: Hudghton will be far more valuable to us, then Cotchin would be next year.

Sure I'd do a direct swap right now, only cos Cotchin has 12 years of footy left in him. But Hudghton will be way more important than a 19 year old kid next year...I mean c'mon.

Click to expand...

Agree with all of this. Structurally, Hudghton is irreplaceable for the Saints, but I honestly think Cotchin will out do him next season, all things considered.

 

Big Nasty

Norm Smith Medallist

Veteran

Jul 26, 2006

5,334

122

Gippsland

AFL Club

Geelong

Other Teams

Cats VFL

• Nov 5, 2008

• #7

And people are always b!tching about the umpires not respecting defenders.