Remove this Banner Ad

Jamie Charman is Comin to Richmond

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Source???
But that sounds like a reasonably fair deal taking into account that there is quite a big difference between the tiger's second round and the lions first Round
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

well ive been reading about previous connections and he was going to come to richmond but couldnt agree on terms because he was a required player, now that he isn't, he wants to move to melbourne club
but melbourne and saints r showing a bit of intrest, but tigers the most
 
im not 100 percent sure
ill try and find the article, it might be a while...sorry
but does anyone think we can organise a trade we're we both get macdonald and charman
how about

rich get mcdonald and charman
bl get 2nd round and raines
 
The BRICKSTER said:
if we trade pick 19 I will be pissed

look what happened last time we did that.

I would like Charman but not for 19.

Charman for Raines a straight swap
Click to expand...
Mate, were doing you a huge huge favour by even offering a pick for Raines. Vossy feels sorry for you guys and wants to help out. We could easily get Raines in the PSD as no one else is remotely interested.
 
so in effect pick 19 for charman

NO DEAL
tuck for charman is a more realistic trade i feel, both similar ages and need fresh starts at new clubs but to give up pick 19 for a player who gets injured and is undersized is MCMAHONESQU
 
Realistic trade.

Richmond need someone to help Vickery get into the game and mentor him now Simmonds is gone and...Graham and Patto wont do that.

Seems fair. Good luck to both players being moved on if true.
 
ohhhBigMalcho said:
so in effect pick 19 for charman

NO DEAL
tuck for charman is a more realistic trade i feel, both similar ages and need fresh starts at new clubs but to give up pick 19 for a player who gets injured and is undersized is MCMAHONESQU
Click to expand...
but at his best, he is a great tough versatile ruckman
how about

shane tuck and andrew raines
for joel macdonald and jamie charman
 

Remove this Banner Ad

would prefer
charman/ 3rd round
for
Tuck and raines
or 3rd round/raines
Don't won't to give up 19
how old is charman
 
I would have thought that deal was good for the Tiges, as charman is a quality ruckman when right. Granted he has been average for a couple of years, but a change of scenery might get him back to his best and quality ruckman are hard to get.

Yet i read this thread and the Tiges are unhappy. I dunno when you have spuds like Simmonds and Graham as your ruckmen giving us something like pick 19 for Charman seems a good deal.
 
Foley Tigers said:
Jamie Charman is reportedly signing with richmond
BL: Get Raines, 2nd round
Rich: 3rd round, Charman
Click to expand...
______________________________________________

Not a snowflakes chance in hell.

Hardwick is rebuilding and your saying that we are going to trade away our 2nd round pick.
Hardwick has said over and over... that we are going to the draft.

It will not happen. Complete BS. Bored were you? Troll are you? Yep.
 
Foley Tigers said:
27 basically the same as tuck
give him 3 yrs
give vickery a chance to develop
or graham
and we have a preimership duo
in my opinion
thoughts??????????????
Click to expand...

Graham wont be a premiership ruckman, i have a good feeling about that;)

tuck straight swap for charman
they need inside midfielders as they only have black and power really so i think they would agree to a straight swap
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Seems pretty fair. Maybe Brisbane getting the better end of the deal as there's no knowing how Charmo will go at a new club.
 
Foley Tigers said:
27 basically the same as tuck
give him 3 yrs
give vickery a chance to develop
or graham
and we have a preimership duo
in my opinion
thoughts??????????????
Click to expand...

Yeah i reckon tuck for charman
let graham play second ruckman to charman
let vickery develop in the forward line and do some ruck work here and there
i've always been a fan of charman so i would be happy for this deal to happen but only if it was for tuck not pick 19
19 is very important
 
Brisbane massive winners out of that trade.

Charman is an over-rated ruckman who built a reputation after 1 solid season.

He doesn't do enough around the ground and doesn't win enough hitouts.

Handy backup ruckman at best.

Pick #19 is way over the odds.

Jolly looks like going for #14 lmao.

richmond screwed again? :confused:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Suma Magic
  • Poll
Opinion Which club would you least like a player to nominate?
Replies
10
Views
610
RonnieRaven
RonnieRaven

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top