-
LIVE: Richmond v Melbourne - 7:25PM Wed
Squiggle tips Demons at 77% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Preview Rd 5 - Carlton v Fremantle 6:45PM Friday 27th April @ Subiaco - Team post #423
- Thread starter zeeCFC
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Poseidon
Kreuzer Sonata
10k Posts
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer Sponsor 2013
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer 2011 Player Sponsor
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco - Preview Thread
Smashed in the ruck, if Warnock is healthy he's an automatic inclusion.
Smashed in the ruck, if Warnock is healthy he's an automatic inclusion.
- Thread starter
- #3
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco - Preview Thread
In the mix: Joseph, Collins, Thornton, Ellard, Armfield
Definite out: Carrazzo.
In the mix to go out: Duigan, Robinson, Curnow, Bower, Yarran (inj)
Scotland and Simpson despite getting high possessions have been butchering the ball of late, especially Scotland. McLean had a dirty day, as did Curnow.
In the mix: Joseph, Collins, Thornton, Ellard, Armfield
Definite out: Carrazzo.
In the mix to go out: Duigan, Robinson, Curnow, Bower, Yarran (inj)
Scotland and Simpson despite getting high possessions have been butchering the ball of late, especially Scotland. McLean had a dirty day, as did Curnow.
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
We get to see how we respond now, if we are a top side.
All about responses.
We get to see how we respond now, if we are a top side.
All about responses.
- Thread starter
- #5
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Sandilands tapping to Mundy and Barlow in the middle for the first time in a while except yesterday. Our extractors need a kick up the arse after their poor showing in the clearances today. Robinson is offering very little at the moment, needs to find his way back into getting 30 or so possies and disposing well from the midfield. Giving us very little on the HFF.
Sandilands tapping to Mundy and Barlow in the middle for the first time in a while except yesterday. Our extractors need a kick up the arse after their poor showing in the clearances today. Robinson is offering very little at the moment, needs to find his way back into getting 30 or so possies and disposing well from the midfield. Giving us very little on the HFF.
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Out - Carrazzo(inj), McLean, Bower, Lucas
In - Ellard, Armfield, Thornton, Collins/Russell
Out - Carrazzo(inj), McLean, Bower, Lucas
In - Ellard, Armfield, Thornton, Collins/Russell
pepalenko
rolling with my cronies
- May 4, 2011
- 3,564
- 3,217
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, SanFransisco 49s, Yankees
This for me. Collins over Russell.
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
JR definitely in over collins, we need experience back there, something we lacked today
JR definitely in over collins, we need experience back there, something we lacked today
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Carrazzo injury happened right in front of me. (RIGHT IN FRONT OF ME!!!!) and I have no doubt that was Lonergan's intention as well.
How bad is the injury? (Although the clique on this board will be happy to see him out)
IN: Thornton
Armi Warnock.
OUT: Carrots maybe Bower maybe Mclean
Collins deserves a chance as well if there is a spot.
Carrazzo injury happened right in front of me. (RIGHT IN FRONT OF ME!!!!) and I have no doubt that was Lonergan's intention as well.
How bad is the injury? (Although the clique on this board will be happy to see him out)
IN: Thornton
Armi Warnock.OUT: Carrots maybe Bower maybe Mclean
Collins deserves a chance as well if there is a spot.
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Really need to respond well after today.
We seem to play patterson stadium pretty well but more than anything just need to get the intensity back.
The team owes us that
Really need to respond well after today.
We seem to play patterson stadium pretty well but more than anything just need to get the intensity back.
The team owes us that
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Out- Bower, McLean, Carrots
In- Ellard, Russel, Armfield
Hampson has been great up until this week and we can't drop him after 1 poor perforamnce, although he may stuggle against Warnock.
Curnow could've gone instead of McLEan but TBH I see curnow as future best 22 and not McLean, so I htink we should persist with Curnow.
Lucas should stay. He hasn't been great but I think we also have to persist with him and his speed should be helpful in Pattersons.
We need some hardness from Ellard and he will always put in 100% (especially in his home town).
Armfield back is an obvious one provided he is fit.
Out- Bower, McLean, Carrots
In- Ellard, Russel, Armfield
Hampson has been great up until this week and we can't drop him after 1 poor perforamnce, although he may stuggle against Warnock.
Curnow could've gone instead of McLEan but TBH I see curnow as future best 22 and not McLean, so I htink we should persist with Curnow.
Lucas should stay. He hasn't been great but I think we also have to persist with him and his speed should be helpful in Pattersons.
We need some hardness from Ellard and he will always put in 100% (especially in his home town).
Armfield back is an obvious one provided he is fit.
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Bad luck about carazzo.He would've got the job on hilly,who do you guys think will get that job now?
Hopefully it's a cracking contest,should be ,you guys will be dirty about losing today.
Fyfe will probably come back in which sets up a great midfield battle of Barlow,mundy,fyfe,broughton,hill,sandi and Clarke v's Judd,Murphy,Simpson,Scotland,????,krueser and hampson.
Bad luck about carazzo.He would've got the job on hilly,who do you guys think will get that job now?
Hopefully it's a cracking contest,should be ,you guys will be dirty about losing today.
Fyfe will probably come back in which sets up a great midfield battle of Barlow,mundy,fyfe,broughton,hill,sandi and Clarke v's Judd,Murphy,Simpson,Scotland,????,krueser and hampson.
Tanks_Alot
Club Legend
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Probably Robinson will get the job on Hill.
If I was Ratts, I'd be making a statement and drop Jeffy, Hammer, Yazz, Lucas, McLean & Bower
Bring Warnock in, bring Watson in, Armfield, Walker, Ellard, Thornton and give Joseph his first game too.
7 changes is a lot and we'll most likely lose to Freo if we do this, but it is short term pain for long term gain. The dropped players will learn a lesson and the rest of the side will be sent a clear message that we aren't tolerating crap anymore, no passengers!
Probably Robinson will get the job on Hill.
If I was Ratts, I'd be making a statement and drop Jeffy, Hammer, Yazz, Lucas, McLean & Bower
Bring Warnock in, bring Watson in, Armfield, Walker, Ellard, Thornton and give Joseph his first game too.
7 changes is a lot and we'll most likely lose to Freo if we do this, but it is short term pain for long term gain. The dropped players will learn a lesson and the rest of the side will be sent a clear message that we aren't tolerating crap anymore, no passengers!
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Haven't got where we are by making wholesale changes every time we lose. In fact, top teams don't operate that way.
Should be fielding the team that we think will win us a premiership. That includes Jeffrey & Robbo. Would give MacLean another crack or two, but if he doesn't succeed then that's it, for good.
Bombers have flown under the radar a bit, they're undefeated. So, wouldn't make wholesale changes for Freo. But if we turn out the same performance next Friday ...
Haven't got where we are by making wholesale changes every time we lose. In fact, top teams don't operate that way.
Should be fielding the team that we think will win us a premiership. That includes Jeffrey & Robbo. Would give MacLean another crack or two, but if he doesn't succeed then that's it, for good.
Bombers have flown under the radar a bit, they're undefeated. So, wouldn't make wholesale changes for Freo. But if we turn out the same performance next Friday ...
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
That's only one third of the team. I'd be looking to squeeze another 6-8 outs.
That's only one third of the team. I'd be looking to squeeze another 6-8 outs.
Tanks_Alot
Club Legend
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Haha true, but their intensity was crap today, I still stand by what I said. I wouldn't want them thinking they can turn up and put in that sort of performance and get away with it.
Haha true, but their intensity was crap today, I still stand by what I said. I wouldn't want them thinking they can turn up and put in that sort of performance and get away with it.
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
I understand you're pissed after today but seriously, making wholesale changes to "prove a point" is schoolboy footy stuff. I'd like to think we're a bit more professional than that. I'd be livid with the club if it made that many changes unless injuries were a factor.
I reckon Carrots and McLean out and maybe Lucas. In Armfield, Ellard and maybe Thornton.
Walker available?
I understand you're pissed after today but seriously, making wholesale changes to "prove a point" is schoolboy footy stuff. I'd like to think we're a bit more professional than that. I'd be livid with the club if it made that many changes unless injuries were a factor.
I reckon Carrots and McLean out and maybe Lucas. In Armfield, Ellard and maybe Thornton.
Walker available?
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Assuming Yarran is okay...
In: Armfield, Thornton, Collins
Out: Bower / Duigan, Carrazzo, Lucas
Assuming Yarran is okay...
In: Armfield, Thornton, Collins
Out: Bower / Duigan, Carrazzo, Lucas
ESKIE
Keeping it Cool.
- Feb 28, 2009
- 31,790
- 53,397
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Not sure what the hell the MC will do, Armfield and Thornton, Bower and Carrazzo out
Ask me last night after watching Freo I felt we had em covered, today...dunno
Not sure what the hell the MC will do, Armfield and Thornton, Bower and Carrazzo out
Ask me last night after watching Freo I felt we had em covered, today...dunno
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Laidler is literally on one leg as well.
If we can somehow get through Friday night he will need to be "rested" the following week
Laidler is literally on one leg as well.
If we can somehow get through Friday night he will need to be "rested" the following week
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
We obviously went into the game expecting to win and struggled. I thought last week after we beat Collingwood (which we really got up for) that Essendon were a sneaky chance to beat us.
Quietly confident about next week. Would only be making forced changes.. 3 weeks of good form and 1 week of bad doesn't justify a dropping and most players were in good form.
We obviously went into the game expecting to win and struggled. I thought last week after we beat Collingwood (which we really got up for) that Essendon were a sneaky chance to beat us.
Quietly confident about next week. Would only be making forced changes.. 3 weeks of good form and 1 week of bad doesn't justify a dropping and most players were in good form.
Re: Rd 5 - Carlton vs. Fremantle, 6:45PM, Friday 27th April @ Subiaco
Goes without saying, but we need Walks back desp. Not only can he take marks but he is the only one you can be comfortable with having the ball in his shooting for goal.
We def need Armfield back, his pace is important and he can play a tagging role too.
Bower needs to go too.
So
Out - Bower McLean Lucas
In - Thornton Armfield Walker
Goes without saying, but we need Walks back desp. Not only can he take marks but he is the only one you can be comfortable with having the ball in his shooting for goal.
We def need Armfield back, his pace is important and he can play a tagging role too.
Bower needs to go too.
So
Out - Bower McLean Lucas
In - Thornton Armfield Walker
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
