12 team competition. 6 teams have to go, who would you boot?

[smasha]

So you stole Richmonds idea and tried to make it your own?Lol.

And Collingwood gave us the sherrin

 

[LukeH10]

It would be wrong to boot collingwood now when they are down haha.

Hardly down. May struggle to make finals from here but win/loss this year won't be a true reflection on where we are at.
We'll close on top 4 next year.

 

[smasha]

Sherrins dont go through the goals.Shoddy design.

 

[Percel]

Richmond won't be going anywhere. Nth would be one of the first to go.

I or II?

 

[Power Raid]

Cats and Dogs merge with Roos
Saints and Blues merge with the Dees
Relocate the Dons and merge with the Suns
Relocate and merge the pies with the Giants

relocate the hawks to tassie and richmond to nz

 

[brizrider]

GWS, Gold Coast, Western Bulldogs, St Kilda, Melbourne and North Melbourne.

Yup, probably if hard nosed about it.

 

[DarwinRoo]

Brisbane, GC, GWS, Sydney, WB, North

Footy is not working north of the border so get rid of it and WB and North are two of the weaker Vic teams.

We s**t all over St Kilda financially

 

[Slax]

There isn't the talent for 18 teams and that is pretty clear now and we will be propping up a number of clubs pretty forever now. So who needs to go?

Kill off
GWS
North Melbourne -send them to the VFL and bring Fitzroy back into the VFL

Merge
Gold Coast and Brisbane - SE Qld will only ever be able to financially support one club.
Melbourne and St Kilda.

 

[bugalugs213]

Melbourne
carlton
Essendon
Gws
Gc
Fremantle

 

[Sultan]

North, St Kilda, Carlton, Melbourne, Essendon

 

[deedog2]

Shittest thread of the year.

 

[Sultan]

Can't think of a 6th

 

[womble54]

Dogs, North, Hawks, GWS, Port and The Suns. If Vic teams need to be killed it should not be 6 of the remaining foundation clubs in Collingwood, Carlton, Essendon, Melbourne St Kilda and Geelong. That leaves the door open to getting rid of Richmond, Hawthorn, North and the Dogs that are all expansion clubs of there time

I'd be happy to take the Dogs back to the VFL. AFL house has totally ****ed the national league so might as well go see a league that is actually watchable.

Enjoyed beating your s**t truck of a team yesterday though. Cheers

 

[telsor]

This thread again?

6 clubs..
Easy! Get rid of WCE, Freo, Ade, Port, GWC & GC.
Have Brisbane taken over by Fitzroy and relocate Sydney to South Melbourne.

 

[EagleShore]

Will never happen. The AFL has spent millions of dollars to expand the competition.

It is far more likely in the next 20 years or so that the competition will become split into conferences ala NBA. Or even more likely, mid season there will be a point where the competition is split into three (6 teams in each bracket) to decide finals positions and in the case of the bottom 6, draft selection.

Cannot recall who it was, but a pundit in the past year has suggested this (may've been a Gerard - Healy or Whateley).

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Merge Sydney and GWS
Fold gcs

Merge Stk, Melb, Carlton, Essendon


14 team comp please

 

[deedog2]

Merge Sydney and GWS


Merge Stk, Melb, Carlton, Essendon

Yeah...coz we'll all go for these merged teams lol

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Yeah...coz we'll all go for these merged teams lol

Not about the fans moving, it's about creating an attractive product

 

[Papa G]

8,2,2,1,1,1 is what the league should be.

 

[Papa G]

This thread again?

6 clubs..
Easy! Get rid of WCE, Freo, Ade, Port, GWC & GC.
Have Brisbane taken over by Fitzroy and relocate Sydney to South Melbourne.

And ABBA back to number 1 on the hit parade.

 

[EagleShore]

12 teams playing each other twice is 24 rounds

oops.

 

[Tyler Hodges]

Gws, suns, lions, Melbourne st Kilda merge to be the St Kilda fallen angels, bulldogs and north merge to become the north western kangaroos. Boom!

 

[MotleyLemon]

Gws, suns, lions, Melbourne st Kilda merge to be the St Kilda fallen angels, bulldogs and north merge to become the north western kangaroos. Boom!

Geez you'd be filthy going from the cracking Dogs playing strip to the awful North ones.

 

[womble54]

Will never happen. The AFL has spent millions of dollars to expand the competition.

It is far more likely in the next 20 years or so that the competition will become split into conferences ala NBA. Or even more likely, mid season there will be a point where the competition is split into three (6 teams in each bracket) to decide finals positions and in the case of the bottom 6, draft selection.

Cannot recall who it was, but a pundit in the past year has suggested this (may've been a Gerard - Healy or Whateley).

Far more likely soccer has killed the league inside 30 years. The hundreds of millions wasted in expansion programs to a disinterested audience in GWS and GC has achieved bugger all compared to disenfranchising the heartcore audiences in the southern states. Afl should have built up the baracades and circled the wagons with that money and instead spent millions charging over the top into a futile western front that could see them lose the war. They are also fighting the wrong enemy. Like declaring war on Turkey (Rugby) without noticing the entire continent of Europe (soccer) is about to charge the eastern front. Stupid rich *heads in AFL house

 

[South of the Yarra]

Admit it.

You'd miss us.

Would miss the Saints. I admit. No one else though. Ok Saints in. Gold Coast out. JD has twisted my arm.