#12 - Who do you want

[THE_GUN]

Ok simple question vote for who you would like with the tigers 1st selection #12

 

[THE_GUN]

Sorry Mods, wanted to add a poll but not happening, if 1 of you could possibly add possibly the 10 most likely players
Ahern,De Goey,Duggan,Durdin,Cockatoo,Goddard,Lamb,Langford,Weller,Menadue

Thanks

 

[Mr Magic]

Sorry Mods, wanted to add a poll but not happening, if 1 of you could possibly add possibly the 10 most likely players
Ahern,De Goey,Duggan,Durdin,Cockatoo,Goddard,Lamb,Langford,Weller,Menadue

Thanks

In order of that list probably, Durdin, Goddard, Cockatoo then Duggan.

Seen some posters talking about West Coast picking Cockatoo at 11 if Pickett gone. Some say Eagles have talked to him

 

[juss]

Pickett/Ahern/De Goey

 

[JR#8]

Petracca

 

[Tigerbob]

I want Cockatoo just for the lols.

 

[Wacky Tiger]

Duggan

 

[Cevap_Roll]

A utensil or too

 

[_RT_]

Mitch Robinson

 

[tigs2010]

I want Cockatoo just for the lols.

The meltdowns in a few years when he's not a star would be epic. "Why did we reach" lol

 

[_RT_]

The meltdowns in a few years when he's not a star would be epic. "Why did we reach" lol

Menadue could have the same sort of reaction except in reverse as posters would be screaming why isn't he starting in his first season.

 

[Tigerbob]

The meltdowns in a few years when he's not a star would be epic. "Why did we reach" lol

Sack FJ.

 

[DustinsGuns]

Duggan.

Go vanilla.

 

[Stylo]

I want Cockatoo just for the lols.

Would be amazing if WCE took him

 

[Frustrated Tiger]

This is the only #12 i want. .....

 

[Mr Magic]

Would be amazing if WCE took him

Why?

 

[Stylo]

Why?

Because it's an astounding reach, and it'd strike out any future debate about us picking him if he turns out a better player than whoever we get at 12.

 

[sante]

Another thread?

 

[Mr Magic]

Because it's an astounding reach, and it'd strike out any future debate about us picking him if he turns out a better player than whoever we get at 12.

Less of a reach than Conca who was more vanilla than Heppell.

Why would it strike out any future debate??

If Cockatoo turns out a gun, then what??? Recruiting department sacked???

 

[Stylo]

Less of a reach than Conca who was more vanilla than Heppell.

Why would it strike out any future debate??

If Cockatoo turns out a gun, then what??? Recruiting department sacked???

It would strike out future debate because taking him was never an option if he were already off the table.

 

[Cevap_Roll]

Less of a reach than Conca who was more vanilla than Heppell.

Why would it strike out any future debate??

If Cockatoo turns out a gun, then what??? Recruiting department sacked???

Highly dependant on if the player we chose at 12 turns out to be a gun.
If both players end up being guns then who cares. If the player we chose flops and Cockatoo goes at 14-18 and turns out to be a gun who knows what could happen.

 

[Mr Magic]

Highly dependant on if the player we chose at 12 turns out to be a gun.
If both players end up being guns then who cares. If the player we chose flops and Cockatoo goes at 14-18 and turns out to be a gun who knows what could happen.

We should care because a line breaker who can assist in the middle and elsewhere is more valuable!! So is a KPP. Do you want another Fiora v Pavlich or Tambling v Franklin debate again?

You realise Duggan is no guarantee he will build up his body to cope with the rigours and pressure of AFL on field. In that sense Drummond is far more secure with a later pick!

 

[Final Siren]

Pick #12:

2000: Shaun Burgoyne (Port)
2001: Brent Reilly (Ade)... one ahead of Nick Dal Santo
2002: Jay Schulz (Richmond)
2003: Ryan Murphy (Freo)
2004: Danny Meyer (Richmond)
2005: Nathan Jones (Melb)
2006: James Frawley (Melb)... one ahead of J. Riewoldt
2007: Cyril Rioli (Haw)
2008: Lewis Johnston (Syd)
2009: Kane Lucas (Carl)... one ahead of Talia
2010: Lucas Cook (Melb)
2011: Sam Docherty (Bris)
2012: Kristian Jaksch (GWS)
2013: Ben Lennon (Richmond)

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Would be amazing if WCE took him

"Why didn't we trade Cotch,Jack,Lids & Dusty for pick 1 to get utensil"

 

[Mr Magic]

Pick #12:

2000: Shaun Burgoyne (Port)
2001: Brent Reilly (Ade)... one ahead of Nick Dal Santo
2002: Jay Schulz (Richmond)
2003: Ryan Murphy (Freo)
2004: Danny Meyer (Richmond)
2005: Nathan Jones (Melb)
2006: James Frawley (Melb)... one ahead of J. Riewoldt
2007: Cyril Rioli (Haw)
2008: Lewis Johnston (Syd)
2009: Kane Lucas (Carl)... one ahead of Talia
2010: Lucas Cook (Melb)
2011: Sam Docherty (Bris)
2012: Kristian Jaksch (GWS)
2013: Ben Lennon (Richmond)

Interesting the KPP's at this at have not been too bad and held their value reasonably.

Frawley, JR later, Schultz has been okay even though we passed him for peanuts, Jaksch has been of value trading to Carlton.

Weakest link is probably Meyer.