year of the cat , what do you like about Miller over other players at that pick?
Actually..are you talking Isaiah 187cm or Josh the ruckman 204cm?
Isaiah - first of all I should declare my assessment is based only on the vision provided by afl.com.au so it's hardly a learned one!
Firstly, I like that he seems to read the play exceptionally well in the highlights. His disposal is first rate and he displays both a great turn of foot as well as terrific agility. I think that he'd make a very good attacking half back. Plonk him on one flank and Thurlow on the other with a couple of more defensively minded smaller types down there, then we have the makings of a good back six.
I have a feeling we will end up with Gardiner the closer this draft gets. So my option C) might be the most realistic. I do like the look of Gardiner. I don't think he is big enough to be that tall to take the gorillas but I do think he will end up being the general in the back half like Scarlett was for much of his career. The guy just looks to me like a very organised player. I love his competitiveness and drive to succeed. I just can't agree with the assessment provided a couple of pages back. I think it is very wrong.