2014 Brownlow Medal

[PureFooty]

What do we reckon about the Dees most votes? Tyson or Jones?

Jones deserves favoritism, is the proven vote getter of the two. Tyson has played some really good games and his clearance work has been excellent but he does turnover the ball. Jones rarely makes mistakes, I think they'll both poll well and wouldn't be surprised if Tyson gets more, but the element of him not really polling before as opposed to Jones who does, makes it a non-betting market for me.

 

[Catz]

Jones deserves favoritism, is the proven vote getter of the two. Tyson has played some really good games and his clearance work has been excellent but he does turnover the ball. Jones rarely makes mistakes, I think they'll both poll well and wouldn't be surprised if Tyson gets more, but the element of him not really polling before as opposed to Jones who does, makes it a non-betting market for me.

Jones is too short to be worth it

 

[Tonche]

Feel like the bookies have got it pretty right (albeit with their usual ridiculously framed markets) with the team vote markets this year. I've got a couple that present value but they're far from the Brad Ebert's and Jonathan Giles' of years gone past.

 

[TheJanuaryMan]

Jones is too short to be worth it

have largely left melbourne out of the team votes markets, a few too many intangibles thee.

 

[TheJanuaryMan]

Feel like the bookies have got it pretty right (albeit with their usual ridiculously framed markets) with the team vote markets this year. I've got a couple that present value but they're far from the Brad Ebert's and Jonathan Giles' of years gone past.

agreed overall. main ones that offer some value is marc murphy, dayne beams, shane mumford, david swallow (in the ablett-out market), jackson macrae.
the other one that is hard to really line up is jordan lewis. a lot of touches, but hasnt polled well in the past in a strong, winning team (can say that gray also hasnt polled, but has been in some heavy losing teams, plus largely up forward in those years)

 

[banana_bus]

Feel like the bookies have got it pretty right (albeit with their usual ridiculously framed markets) with the team vote markets this year. I've got a couple that present value but they're far from the Brad Ebert's and Jonathan Giles' of years gone past.

Dont forget Lenny

 

[Murphinator]

marc murphy

Marc Murphy is great value if you consider throwing money down the drain as "value"

 

[TheJanuaryMan]

Marc Murphy is great value if you consider throwing money down the drain as "value"

as a carlton man,you see their top 3 as gibbs, simpson, judd?

 

[Keystone agony]

as a carlton man,you see their top 3 as gibbs, simpson, judd?

He does. I have murphy right in the mix depending mainly on round 2 or 3 (vs tigers) to see how many he gets from that game.

 

[Keystone agony]

FWIW guys like Macrae and Sloane have now got out to some really good value IMO.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Marc Murphy is great value if you consider throwing money down the drain as "value"

If he doesn't end up within 5 of the leader I'll give your Dad a reach around.

 

[KardiniaPark]

I can pay in advance...

 

[TheJanuaryMan]

out of interest, where do others have hannebery in the sydney votes? i had him finishing on 16, but when looking back on some games, there could be a case for him polling in a couple of matches i didnt award votes. he hada big purple patch from round 5-11 or so, and then finished okay when he came back.

if kennedy didnt poll as expected, then the $34 on hannebery to top Sydney may get intersting (there are a lot of potential pollers there - kennedy, buddy, parker, hannebery, so just wonder how many there are to go around)

 

[Jugada]

Hannebery 9

 

[Keystone agony]

Hannebery 14.5

 

[Murphinator]

as a carlton man,you see their top 3 as gibbs, simpson, judd?

Gibbs will stroll to victory. Simmo 2nd, Murph 3rd, Judd 4th. I think Judd has the potential to snag 2nd though.. we all know how well he polls.

 

[Keystone agony]

Gibbs will stroll to victory. Simmo 2nd, Murph 3rd, Judd 4th. I think Judd has the potential to snag 2nd though.. we all know how well he polls.

You changed quick. Im sure it wasnt long ago you said murph wouldn't be top 3 for the blues. All of a sudden hes 3rd

 

[KardiniaPark]

You changed quick. Im sure it wasnt long ago you said murph wouldn't be top 3 for the blues. All of a sudden hes 3rd

He obviously has Squibbs high teens and the rest 9-11. So basically 2nd would be the same as 4th.

 

[EightySix]

CARLTON
min max exp
10 14 11 Murphy
9 15 11 Gibbs

R2 key game Murphy
R18 key game Gibbs

 

[KardiniaPark]

CARLTON
min max exp
10 14 11 Murphy
9 15 11 Gibbs

R2 key game Murphy
R18 key game Gibbs

So in your opinion Murphinator is a Murphy hater? Does he even go for Carlton? Could he be a plant from Brownlow Genius to get a better price Murphy? Does my hat need more tin foil? So many questions...

 

[EightySix]

So in your opinion Murphinator is a Murphy hater? Does he even go for Carlton? Could he be a plant from Brownlow Genius to get a better price Murphy? Does my hat need more tin foil? So many questions...

Disgrace. Should change his username

Gibbs had a terrific year. Will most likely win B&F. At $1.33 for Team Votes, I'm not anchoring.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Disgrace. Should change his username

Gibbs had a terrific year. Will most likely win B&F. At $1.33 for Team Votes, I'm not anchoring.

I think you should stick the Carlton board into him

 

[Murphinator]

You changed quick. Im sure it wasnt long ago you said murph wouldn't be top 3 for the blues. All of a sudden hes 3rd

I only said he had no chance of taking our most votes

Disgrace. Should change his username

Gibbs had a terrific year. Will most likely win B&F. At $1.33 for Team Votes, I'm not anchoring.

I love Murph. Gibbs had a stunning year though - he has been crunched after opening ~1.66 for Carlton most votes. Gibbs mid-teens.

 

[CamTinley]

Randomish question ... Does anyone give Nathan Jones any votes in the Round 1, St Kilda V Melbourne game and if so how many? Thanks

 

[NMxrkxdxs]

hey fellas, i've got a large multi riding on the last leg which is 'Stevie Johnson leader after round 4 (Selwood excluded)'..i got him at $4.50 and he is into $1.95 now.

do you guys have him leading after round 4? or should i hedge on a few other players? etc. Ablett, riewoldt