With 1 match to go, no doubt this type of list analysis will occur as early as Monday. I just wanted to get a jump start, with our season essentially over and the papers stamped of many already. Here’s my summation of our list for the year (almost passed).
#1 - Andrew Walker
2014 Games Played: 14
2014 Performance Rating: 6
Defining stats (per game avg): 22.4 disposals, 5.1 marks & 5.8 R50s
Comments: Has had an injury-affected year that saw him struggle to impact as many games in a tough year for the Blues.
Off-season Status: Safe. Despite talk of trade-bait, 1AW has put this to bed signing on until 2017 and committing his future to the Blues, and will likely retire a one-club-player for Carlton.
#2 - Troy Menzel
2014 Games Played: 18
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 9.2 disposals,3.4 marks, 1.4 tackles & 1.3 goals
Comments: In just his 2nd year, he cemented his spot in the seniors and as Carlton’s most exciting young player. A Rising Star nomination in R16 rewarded him for his emergence in the competition.
Off-season Status: In news that brought joy to many fans, Menzel recently signed on to stay at VISY Park for another 2 years. Will look to build his tank in the off-season and push further up the ground in his bid to become a long-term midfielder at AFL level.
#3 - Marc Murphy
2014 Games Played: 20
2014 Performance Rating: 8
Defining stats: 24.1 disposals, 3.7 marks, 4.9 clearances & 4.9 tackles
Comments: Murph stepped up both on and off the field in 2014 – his 2nd year as captain of the Navy Blues. He led from the front and put his body on the line every time he took the field.
Off-season Status: Another to sign a long-term deal for Carlton, keeping him at the club until 2018. Will look to lead the team up the ladder in 2015 as his relationship with Mick and his leadership group grows, and he continues to become one of the best on-ballers in the competition.
#4 - Bryce Gibbs
2014 Games Played: 21
2014 Performance Rating: 9
Defining stats: 24.9 disposals, 5.6 clearances, 5 tackles and 0.9 goals
Comments: In a year that should yield his first club best & fairest, Gibbsy has been a shining light in a bleak year for the Blues. He’s one of 2014’s success stories as he has finally started to show the promise of an A-grade midfielder on a consistent basis. One gets the feeling that 2015 will see him elevate to that top echelon of elite midfielders.
Off-season Status: Entering 2014 as one of the most sought-after Restricted Free Agents, Gibbs let his football do the talking for most of the year, before signing up as a ‘Blue for Life’ in a 5-year deal that will tie him to the club until 2019.
#5 – Chris Judd
2014 Games Played: 11
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 19.8 disposals, 5 clearances & 3.5 tackles
Comments: Fighting off injury and a mid-season swirl of scrutiny, Juddy returned to end the year in vintage form and show his fans and critics alike that the champion isn’t done yet.
Off-season Status: The great man himself admitted that he’d all but decided to retire come end of year, however a late-season resurgence and positive vibe at the club changed his mind and will see him play on for another year in 2015 as he looks to fight for one more crack at success in Navy Blue.
#6 – Kade Simpson
2014 Games Played: 21
2014 Performance Rating: 9
Defining stats: 23.7 disposals, 76.1% DE, 6.3 marks & 3.4 rebound 50s
Comments: Vying for back-to-back B&F honours, the courageous wingman has played in defence and through the middle in 2014, and has been the rock (and heart) of the side through an adversity-laden season.
Off-season Status: Simmo is contracted until 2016 so will be another key player that remains at the club until his final AFL game. The vice-captain will be an important part of Carlton’s anticipated rise up the ladder next season.
#7 – Dylan Buckley
2014 Games Played: 8
2014 Performance Rating: 6
Defining stats: 13.4 disposals, 80.4% DE, 3.6 marks & 2.7 tackles
Comments: The name Buckley has returned to the hearts of Carlton fans as a Malthouse-driven switch to defence ignited his career. His courage and run is reminiscent of a young Kade Simpson – giving Blues fans a look into the future. A Rising Star nod in Round 2 was the impetus for many fans’ excitement and optimism.
Off-season Status: Yet another promising kid to re-sign this year – Buckley is now contracted to the club until 2016, but will no doubt have desires to remain in Navy Blue for much longer. Bucks could become a big part of the future at VISY Park, if he uses 2014 as a springboard into next season.
#8 – Matthew Kreuzer
2014 Games Played: 1
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 14 disposals, 13 hitouts & 3 marks
Comments: 2014 has been a tough year for the former #1 draft pick, as he’s battled injury for the better part of the season – only managing the 1 game.
Off-season Status: Out of contract in 2015, Kreuzer will look to have a big off-season and be fit and ready for Round 1. The Blues have badly missed his second and third efforts around the stoppage, and they’ll look to do everything possible to get their #1 big-man back to his best next season.
#9 – Kane Lucas
2014 Games Played: 6
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 12.3 disposals, 3.3 marks & 2.7 tackles
Comments: The young midfielder has failed to come on in 2014, appearing to fall out of favour with the selection committee early on – only managing the six games leading into the final round. Days may be numbered at the club, unfortunately.
Off-season Status: Uncontracted with unfulfilled potential, Lucas appears on his way out this off-season as he failed to make an impact or push for regular selection in 2014. Will likely be used as trade-bait in October, which could see him be moved onto another club or (failing a successful trade) let go before the last list lodgement.
#10 – Matthew Watson
2014 Games Played: 2
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 12.5 disposals, 3 marks, 3 rebound 50s & 2 tackles
Comments: Like Lucas, Watson has failed to make an impact this season, and will be on the block come seasons end. Has been trialled up forward in the seconds to some effect, which indicates where Mick sees him going forward (should he take that step up in 2015).
Off-season Status: His saving grace is that he’s contracted for another year, although time is running out for him to find a place for himself in Carlton’s Best 22. It will no doubt be a massive off-season for an equally massive young man, if indeed he remains in Navy Blue come 2015.
#11 – Robbie Warnock
2014 Games Played: 16
2014 Performance Rating: 5
Defining stats: 34.2 hitouts, 3.4 clearances and 1.9 tackles
Comments: Carlton’s tallest timber was forced to shoulder the rucking load for much of this season, however in these circumstances; he failed to solidify his spot as the #1 ruckman in the side. Now well-known for his inability to do much around the ground, he was usurped by rookie-listed Cam Wood and will face an uphill battle moving forward.
Off-season Status: Still contracted for next season, Warnock’s future in Carlton’s 22 is clouded as the return of Kreuzer and emergence of Wood have pushed the 208cm giant to the back of the queue. Could be traded in the off-season, otherwise will need to make huge improvements to his game if he wants to remain a Carlton (and AFL) player.
#12 – Mitch Robinson
2014 Games Played: 12
2014 Performance Rating: 6
Defining stats: 19.9 disposals, 4.7 marks, 2.3 clearances & 4.1 tackles
Comments: The much-maligned midfielder has been suspended 3 times this season, spending almost as much time off the field as he has on it. Despite this, he showed considerable improvement when he was playing, yet still gives Malthouse more headaches than just about any other player he’d have ever coached.
Off-season Status: Another player out of contract, with Robbo also unavailable for the last few rounds due to an altercation that saw him left with a fractured eye-socket and a sorry conscience. Will be put up for trade, however may get a reprieve from the coach if a good offer doesn’t come up. Still has plenty to offer the team if he can stamp out ‘that side’ of his game.
#13 – Chris Yarran
2014 Games Played: 20
2014 Performance Rating: 9
Defining stats: 16.5 disposals, 4.2 marks, 1.9 rebound 50s, 3.2 bounces & 0.9 goals
Comments: Yarran is another who has had a career-best season for Carlton in 2014, with his run and carry from the back half a key to the team’s fortunes. Now identified as one of (if not the) most important players in the side, his ability to run the ball out of defence (#1 for running bounces in the AFL) into attack (19 goals for the year) is up there with the best.
Off-season Status: Signing on for another 2 years in 2014, Yaz is now set comfortably inside Carlton’s Top 5 players and will look to continue to improve as he approaches his peak as an AFL player. He remains an important cog in the machine that is the Blues’ plan for success.
#14 – Brock McLean
2014 Games Played: 15
2014 Performance Rating: 5
Defining stats: 18.5 disposals, 3.9 clearances, 2.9 tackles & 0.9 goals
Comments: Whilst still putting up decent numbers on the field, Brock’s 2014 form has been a world away from his best – earning the ire of Carlton’s fans on numerous occasions. Approaching his twilight years as a footballer, we have most likely seen the best of him in his career.
Off-season Status: The word is that he’s likely to get another year in Navy Blue, perhaps more as insurance for the young brigade then anything. McLean is on notice and may struggle to see much senior action in 2015 as he is surpassed by younger, quicker and hungrier players around him.
#15 – Sam Docherty
2014 Games Played: 15
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 18.4 disposals, 5.1 marks, 2.6 rebound 50s & 2.5 tackles
Comments: Demanding his debut in Round 7, the Brisbane export and former-Blues supporter cemented his spot in the side in his first year at the club; and offering a lot of promise to support his potential. The trade that saw him come to Carlton with Pick 33 will be known as a huge steal for years to come.
Off-season Status: Tied to the Blues for the next few years, Doc will be a fixture of the future of Carlton and is fast becoming a fan favourite. Like Menzel, he will most likely look to spend more time with the midfield group in the off-season as his skills would be well-utilised in the middle.
#16 – Patrick Cripps
2014 Games Played: 2
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 12 disposals, 2 marks, 3 rebound 50s & 2 tackles
Comments: It was always going to be an ‘ease in’ year for the young first round draft pick as his aerobic fitness needed work before making an impact at the top level. He also battled injury, but did still manage to debut. There are big things to come in the future for this kid.
Off-season Status: The young extractor will look to have a big off-season, before attacking his second season with plans to break into the 22 early on. Cripps is seen as a long-term player in the midfield for Carlton.
#17 – Sam Rowe
2014 Games Played: 20
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 11.5 disposals, 80.1% DE, 5.1 marks, 2.4 rebound 50s & 7.9 1%ers
Comments: From the chopping block to being one of the most improved players of 2014, the big man’s story continues to delight. Finding a home in the back half this season, he seems to get better with every game and has allowed Henderson to play forward predominantly throughout the year.
Off-season Status: A well-earned 2-year contract was announced recently, and Rowe couldn’t hide the smile from his face. The Carlton will hopeful look forward to his continual improvement in 2015 and beyond.
#18 – Tom Temay
2014 Games Played: 0
2014 Performance Rating: 2
Defining stats: -
Comments: Failing to so much as push for a debut in 2 years on the list, Temay could be facing a certain fate post-season. Going missing for large chunks of time, and failing to impact VFL games has seen him drop to the bottom of the queue.
Off-season Status: Uncontracted and out of time, there is little chance that he’ll be on the list come 2015. Originally brought in with plenty of promise, his time at Carlton will be met with disappointment as he failed to make the grade.
#19 – Cameron Giles
2014 Games Played: 0
2014 Performance Rating: 3
Defining stats: -
Comments: Struck down with a season-ending injury mid-year, Giles will be delayed in his development at Carlton. Well-beaten on several occasions in defence for the Northern Blues, it became apparent that he still has a lot to learn before making an impact in the AFL.
Off-season Status: Giles has a big off-season ahead to make up for lost time and show the club that he has what it takes to make the grade. With the club’s low key position stocks, they’d be hoping he stays fit and makes big improvements next season and pushes for a debut.
#20 – Nick Holman
2014 Games Played: 1
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 8 disposals, 2 marks & 4 tackles
Comments: The young midfielder had a solid year in the VFL, and received a well-earned debut in Round 22. He still has a lot of development to go before making a meaningful impact, but he’s well on his way.
Off-season Status: Like Cripps, Holman will be looking to build on a positive first year as an AFL player, and push for more senior games in a bid to show his wares as one of the new breed at Carlton.
#23 – Lachie Henderson
2014 Games Played: 17
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 11.3 disposals, 5.2 marks & 1.6 goals
Comments: In a year inhibited by injury, Hendo spent most of the year up forward for the first time. Leading the goal-kicking with an equal season-high 28 (as at R22), Henderson hasn’t had the best year statistically – but his leadership skills alone make him an important part of Carlton’s future.
Off-season Status: With one year remaining on his current contract, Henderson will be looking to get back to 100% and break out as a key forward in 2015 – leading to (what he will hope is) a big payday and some promise of success in Navy Blue.
#26 – Andrew McInness
2014 Games Played: 1
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 11 disposals, 1 mark & 2 tackles
Comments: In a year where other, less-skilled players surpassed him in the pecking order, Andy Mac may struggle to find a place in the team going forward. Only managing the one game in 2014 (playing on AFLCA Winner Robbie Gray, mind you), he is one that may have his papers stamped.
Off-season Status: His disappointing year may come at a cost, as his struggles with form in a contract year would be unlikely to convince the coaching panel to sign him for another year.
#27 – Dennis Armfield
2014 Games Played: 7
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 7.9 disposals, 76.4% DE & 2.6 tackles
Comments: A really disappointing year for a guy who had played every game last year, with only really one good game to show for it. Has dropped down the order now and may have lost the confidence of the coaching team.
Off-season Status: Out of contract in 2015, Army will have another season to show his worth to the team. With some talented kids starting to make a splash, he will have to work extremely hard if he’s to avoid the chop next season.
#28 – Tom Bell
2014 Games Played: 12
2014 Performance Rating: 6
Defining stats: 14.1 disposals, 3.8 marks, 3.4 tackles & 0.8 goals
Comments: Despite missing a large part of the season with a finger injury, Bell made real inroads in his development as an AFL player. A few good performances late in the year will have supporters looking forward to what he can produce in the future.
Off-season Status: Signing on for another 2 years this season, Bell looks set to push towards the 50-game at Carlton as he aims to cement a place in the midfield. With Judd as a mentor for another season, here’s hoping Bell can have a breakout year in 2015.
#29 – Heath Scotland
2014 Games Played: 4
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 18.7 disposals, 4.2 marks & 3 tackles
Comments: Retiring in the middle of the season, the 268-game veteran called it a day after showing clear signs that the game had begun to go past him. Scotto has been a core part of the side for the last decade.
Off-season Status: Enjoy retirement Scotto, you’ve earned it.
#30 – Jarrad Waite
2014 Games Played: 15
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 14.3 disposals, 5.9 marks (inc. 2.1 contested), 3 tackles & 1.9 goals
Comments: Waite will finish season 2014 having played the equal-most season games since 2008. After indifferent form, injury and more suspensions, he will likely finish the season as Carlton’s leading goal scorer and remains one of the most talented and important players when on the field.
Off-season Status: An unrestricted Free Agent, Waite has received interest from rival club North Melbourne, whilst recent news says that Carlton are keen to improve their one-year offer to include the option for a second year – taking him through to 2016 and his likely retirement.
#31 – Luke Reynolds
2014 Games Played: 0
2014 Performance Rating: 2
Defining stats: -
Comments: Chosen in the rookie draft, expectations were low heading into the season. He struggled to make an impact in the seconds or push for elevation to the seniors despite playing most of the year. It must be noted that it was tough for all forwards in at the Northern Blues in 2014 due to limited opportunity/delivery.
Off-season Status: With rookie contracts a year-to-year proposition, it’s unlikely Reynolds will be retained for season 2015. However, whether or not the coaching staff have seen enough to give the 19 year old another chance, is the real question.
#32 – Nick Graham
2014 Games Played: 8
2014 Performance Rating: 5
Defining stats: 10.7 disposals, 3.6 marks & 2.5 tackles
Comments: 2014 was a year of improvement for the young blonde-haired midfielder, as he moved between the seconds and seniors on a regular basis. Playing 6 games (as at R22) together at the end of the season has given him some consistency and belief that he belongs in the team – something that should see him propel into 2015 on a good note.
Off-season Status: Likely to get another 1-2 year contract upon completion of the season, Graham will be looking to build on his moderate game tally from 2014 and cement a spot in the seniors next season.
#33 – Andrejs Everitt
2014 Games Played: 17
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 16.8 disposals, 5.2 marks, 2.2 tackles & 0.8 goals
Comments: Coming over from Sydney in the off-season, few could have predicted the underrated impact ‘Dre’ would have on the team in 2014. Played a variety of roles for the team and provided much needed flexibility in the side during testing times. Unfortunate knee injury kept him away for a handful of games at the end of the year.
Off-season Status: With the Blues for another year or two yet, Everitt is one of the trade successes of season 2014 and will be a part of Carlton’s Best 22 for years to come.
#35 – Ed Curnow
2014 Games Played: 14
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 21.3 disposals, 4.1 marks, 2.4 clearances & 5.2 tackles
Comments: Curnow should poll well again in this year’s B&F count despite only playing 14 games (as at R22), as he excelled as Carlton’s #1 stopper once again. Spent 8 weeks on the sidelines with a leg injury, but came back to have a positive impact in the run home – remains a key part of the team’s best side.
Off-season Status: Contracted to the club until 2016, Curnow has ran with the title of club tagger since taking over the role from Carrazzo in 2012/2013. Will be looking for another strong pre-season to hit the ground running next season.
#36 – Cameron Wood
2014 Games Played: 5
2014 Performance Rating: 6
Defining stats: 11.6 disposals, 23.4 hitouts, 4.6 marks & 3.2 clearances
Comments: Another to be given little hope at the beginning of the season, Wood played a lot of good footy in the VFL before finally getting his AFL chance in Round 18. He’s been serviceable around the ruck in Kreuzer’s absence, showing the value of having a ruckman that can compete around the ground – not just in ruck contests.
Off-season Status: A sure thing to be retained for 2015 – it’s just a matter of whether he remains on the rookie list or gains elevation to the seniors. With Kreuzer likely to be fit for Round 1, 2015, its more than likely Wood will get another rookie contract for next season.
#37 – Jarryd Cachia
2014 Games Played: 0
2014 Performance Rating: 3
Defining stats: -
Comments: Determined in his games at VFL level, he was senior emergency a few times, but couldn’t break through for a game at the top level. Disappointing year for the 23 year old midfielder ended with a shoulder injury.
Off-season Status: Can’t see him gaining elevation to the senior list, and hasn’t done enough to break through and show his worth in the seniors. Sadly, I think the Cachia rookie experiment will end this season and see him delisted.
#38 – Jeff Garlett
2014 Games Played: 9
2014 Performance Rating: 5
Defining stats: 8 disposals, 2.3 marks, 2.6 tackles & 1.3 goals
Comments: Garlett has struggled with off-field issues and personal demons in 2014 as he dropped away gradually to play his last game in Round 12. Played his best game in R6 v West Coach, then did nothing else (at either level) for the year. Huge drop from the heights we’ve seen from him since his debut.
Off-season Status: Like Robinson, he will face the trading block in the coming months to see if another team shows interest in the speedy small forward. Failing a good deal, Garlett may be retained for another year as a lifeline – that is, if he wants to stay.
#39 – Dale Thomas
2014 Games Played: 20
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 17.3 disposals, 5.6 marks, 1.9 rebound 50s & 2.8 tackles
Comments: Much-criticised on his switch from arch-rivals Collingwood, Daisy has slowly worked to regain the touch that made him one of the best players in the AFL just a few short years ago. Some encouraging signs late in the year give promise that he could yet return to his best in 2015.
Off-season Status: One year into a 4 year contract, Thomas has exceeded expectations by playing 20 games (as at R22) and slowly built up his fitness and running capacity. Look for a better, quicker Daisy in 2015.
#40 – Michael Jamison
2014 Games Played: 19
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 85% DE, 5.5 marks, 2.4 rebound 50s & 6.3 1%ers
Comments: Another big year for the battle-hardened fullback, Jamison has formed a formidable defensive combination with Sam Rowe, providing a good defensive matchup and drive from the back half.
Off-season Status: Recently re-signing until 2017, Jamison is one of the most important players in Carlton’s side, regularly taking the opposition’s best key forward despite giving away height almost every time. Supremely underrated amongst those outside the walls of VISY Park.
The remainder of the write-ups are at the bottom of the page.
Agree? Disagree? Feel free to weigh in on the discussion.
#1 - Andrew Walker
2014 Games Played: 14
2014 Performance Rating: 6
Defining stats (per game avg): 22.4 disposals, 5.1 marks & 5.8 R50s
Comments: Has had an injury-affected year that saw him struggle to impact as many games in a tough year for the Blues.
Off-season Status: Safe. Despite talk of trade-bait, 1AW has put this to bed signing on until 2017 and committing his future to the Blues, and will likely retire a one-club-player for Carlton.
#2 - Troy Menzel
2014 Games Played: 18
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 9.2 disposals,3.4 marks, 1.4 tackles & 1.3 goals
Comments: In just his 2nd year, he cemented his spot in the seniors and as Carlton’s most exciting young player. A Rising Star nomination in R16 rewarded him for his emergence in the competition.
Off-season Status: In news that brought joy to many fans, Menzel recently signed on to stay at VISY Park for another 2 years. Will look to build his tank in the off-season and push further up the ground in his bid to become a long-term midfielder at AFL level.
#3 - Marc Murphy
2014 Games Played: 20
2014 Performance Rating: 8
Defining stats: 24.1 disposals, 3.7 marks, 4.9 clearances & 4.9 tackles
Comments: Murph stepped up both on and off the field in 2014 – his 2nd year as captain of the Navy Blues. He led from the front and put his body on the line every time he took the field.
Off-season Status: Another to sign a long-term deal for Carlton, keeping him at the club until 2018. Will look to lead the team up the ladder in 2015 as his relationship with Mick and his leadership group grows, and he continues to become one of the best on-ballers in the competition.
#4 - Bryce Gibbs
2014 Games Played: 21
2014 Performance Rating: 9
Defining stats: 24.9 disposals, 5.6 clearances, 5 tackles and 0.9 goals
Comments: In a year that should yield his first club best & fairest, Gibbsy has been a shining light in a bleak year for the Blues. He’s one of 2014’s success stories as he has finally started to show the promise of an A-grade midfielder on a consistent basis. One gets the feeling that 2015 will see him elevate to that top echelon of elite midfielders.
Off-season Status: Entering 2014 as one of the most sought-after Restricted Free Agents, Gibbs let his football do the talking for most of the year, before signing up as a ‘Blue for Life’ in a 5-year deal that will tie him to the club until 2019.
#5 – Chris Judd
2014 Games Played: 11
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 19.8 disposals, 5 clearances & 3.5 tackles
Comments: Fighting off injury and a mid-season swirl of scrutiny, Juddy returned to end the year in vintage form and show his fans and critics alike that the champion isn’t done yet.
Off-season Status: The great man himself admitted that he’d all but decided to retire come end of year, however a late-season resurgence and positive vibe at the club changed his mind and will see him play on for another year in 2015 as he looks to fight for one more crack at success in Navy Blue.
#6 – Kade Simpson
2014 Games Played: 21
2014 Performance Rating: 9
Defining stats: 23.7 disposals, 76.1% DE, 6.3 marks & 3.4 rebound 50s
Comments: Vying for back-to-back B&F honours, the courageous wingman has played in defence and through the middle in 2014, and has been the rock (and heart) of the side through an adversity-laden season.
Off-season Status: Simmo is contracted until 2016 so will be another key player that remains at the club until his final AFL game. The vice-captain will be an important part of Carlton’s anticipated rise up the ladder next season.
#7 – Dylan Buckley
2014 Games Played: 8
2014 Performance Rating: 6
Defining stats: 13.4 disposals, 80.4% DE, 3.6 marks & 2.7 tackles
Comments: The name Buckley has returned to the hearts of Carlton fans as a Malthouse-driven switch to defence ignited his career. His courage and run is reminiscent of a young Kade Simpson – giving Blues fans a look into the future. A Rising Star nod in Round 2 was the impetus for many fans’ excitement and optimism.
Off-season Status: Yet another promising kid to re-sign this year – Buckley is now contracted to the club until 2016, but will no doubt have desires to remain in Navy Blue for much longer. Bucks could become a big part of the future at VISY Park, if he uses 2014 as a springboard into next season.
#8 – Matthew Kreuzer
2014 Games Played: 1
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 14 disposals, 13 hitouts & 3 marks
Comments: 2014 has been a tough year for the former #1 draft pick, as he’s battled injury for the better part of the season – only managing the 1 game.
Off-season Status: Out of contract in 2015, Kreuzer will look to have a big off-season and be fit and ready for Round 1. The Blues have badly missed his second and third efforts around the stoppage, and they’ll look to do everything possible to get their #1 big-man back to his best next season.
#9 – Kane Lucas
2014 Games Played: 6
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 12.3 disposals, 3.3 marks & 2.7 tackles
Comments: The young midfielder has failed to come on in 2014, appearing to fall out of favour with the selection committee early on – only managing the six games leading into the final round. Days may be numbered at the club, unfortunately.
Off-season Status: Uncontracted with unfulfilled potential, Lucas appears on his way out this off-season as he failed to make an impact or push for regular selection in 2014. Will likely be used as trade-bait in October, which could see him be moved onto another club or (failing a successful trade) let go before the last list lodgement.
#10 – Matthew Watson
2014 Games Played: 2
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 12.5 disposals, 3 marks, 3 rebound 50s & 2 tackles
Comments: Like Lucas, Watson has failed to make an impact this season, and will be on the block come seasons end. Has been trialled up forward in the seconds to some effect, which indicates where Mick sees him going forward (should he take that step up in 2015).
Off-season Status: His saving grace is that he’s contracted for another year, although time is running out for him to find a place for himself in Carlton’s Best 22. It will no doubt be a massive off-season for an equally massive young man, if indeed he remains in Navy Blue come 2015.
#11 – Robbie Warnock
2014 Games Played: 16
2014 Performance Rating: 5
Defining stats: 34.2 hitouts, 3.4 clearances and 1.9 tackles
Comments: Carlton’s tallest timber was forced to shoulder the rucking load for much of this season, however in these circumstances; he failed to solidify his spot as the #1 ruckman in the side. Now well-known for his inability to do much around the ground, he was usurped by rookie-listed Cam Wood and will face an uphill battle moving forward.
Off-season Status: Still contracted for next season, Warnock’s future in Carlton’s 22 is clouded as the return of Kreuzer and emergence of Wood have pushed the 208cm giant to the back of the queue. Could be traded in the off-season, otherwise will need to make huge improvements to his game if he wants to remain a Carlton (and AFL) player.
#12 – Mitch Robinson
2014 Games Played: 12
2014 Performance Rating: 6
Defining stats: 19.9 disposals, 4.7 marks, 2.3 clearances & 4.1 tackles
Comments: The much-maligned midfielder has been suspended 3 times this season, spending almost as much time off the field as he has on it. Despite this, he showed considerable improvement when he was playing, yet still gives Malthouse more headaches than just about any other player he’d have ever coached.
Off-season Status: Another player out of contract, with Robbo also unavailable for the last few rounds due to an altercation that saw him left with a fractured eye-socket and a sorry conscience. Will be put up for trade, however may get a reprieve from the coach if a good offer doesn’t come up. Still has plenty to offer the team if he can stamp out ‘that side’ of his game.
#13 – Chris Yarran
2014 Games Played: 20
2014 Performance Rating: 9
Defining stats: 16.5 disposals, 4.2 marks, 1.9 rebound 50s, 3.2 bounces & 0.9 goals
Comments: Yarran is another who has had a career-best season for Carlton in 2014, with his run and carry from the back half a key to the team’s fortunes. Now identified as one of (if not the) most important players in the side, his ability to run the ball out of defence (#1 for running bounces in the AFL) into attack (19 goals for the year) is up there with the best.
Off-season Status: Signing on for another 2 years in 2014, Yaz is now set comfortably inside Carlton’s Top 5 players and will look to continue to improve as he approaches his peak as an AFL player. He remains an important cog in the machine that is the Blues’ plan for success.
#14 – Brock McLean
2014 Games Played: 15
2014 Performance Rating: 5
Defining stats: 18.5 disposals, 3.9 clearances, 2.9 tackles & 0.9 goals
Comments: Whilst still putting up decent numbers on the field, Brock’s 2014 form has been a world away from his best – earning the ire of Carlton’s fans on numerous occasions. Approaching his twilight years as a footballer, we have most likely seen the best of him in his career.
Off-season Status: The word is that he’s likely to get another year in Navy Blue, perhaps more as insurance for the young brigade then anything. McLean is on notice and may struggle to see much senior action in 2015 as he is surpassed by younger, quicker and hungrier players around him.
#15 – Sam Docherty
2014 Games Played: 15
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 18.4 disposals, 5.1 marks, 2.6 rebound 50s & 2.5 tackles
Comments: Demanding his debut in Round 7, the Brisbane export and former-Blues supporter cemented his spot in the side in his first year at the club; and offering a lot of promise to support his potential. The trade that saw him come to Carlton with Pick 33 will be known as a huge steal for years to come.
Off-season Status: Tied to the Blues for the next few years, Doc will be a fixture of the future of Carlton and is fast becoming a fan favourite. Like Menzel, he will most likely look to spend more time with the midfield group in the off-season as his skills would be well-utilised in the middle.
#16 – Patrick Cripps
2014 Games Played: 2
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 12 disposals, 2 marks, 3 rebound 50s & 2 tackles
Comments: It was always going to be an ‘ease in’ year for the young first round draft pick as his aerobic fitness needed work before making an impact at the top level. He also battled injury, but did still manage to debut. There are big things to come in the future for this kid.
Off-season Status: The young extractor will look to have a big off-season, before attacking his second season with plans to break into the 22 early on. Cripps is seen as a long-term player in the midfield for Carlton.
#17 – Sam Rowe
2014 Games Played: 20
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 11.5 disposals, 80.1% DE, 5.1 marks, 2.4 rebound 50s & 7.9 1%ers
Comments: From the chopping block to being one of the most improved players of 2014, the big man’s story continues to delight. Finding a home in the back half this season, he seems to get better with every game and has allowed Henderson to play forward predominantly throughout the year.
Off-season Status: A well-earned 2-year contract was announced recently, and Rowe couldn’t hide the smile from his face. The Carlton will hopeful look forward to his continual improvement in 2015 and beyond.
#18 – Tom Temay
2014 Games Played: 0
2014 Performance Rating: 2
Defining stats: -
Comments: Failing to so much as push for a debut in 2 years on the list, Temay could be facing a certain fate post-season. Going missing for large chunks of time, and failing to impact VFL games has seen him drop to the bottom of the queue.
Off-season Status: Uncontracted and out of time, there is little chance that he’ll be on the list come 2015. Originally brought in with plenty of promise, his time at Carlton will be met with disappointment as he failed to make the grade.
#19 – Cameron Giles
2014 Games Played: 0
2014 Performance Rating: 3
Defining stats: -
Comments: Struck down with a season-ending injury mid-year, Giles will be delayed in his development at Carlton. Well-beaten on several occasions in defence for the Northern Blues, it became apparent that he still has a lot to learn before making an impact in the AFL.
Off-season Status: Giles has a big off-season ahead to make up for lost time and show the club that he has what it takes to make the grade. With the club’s low key position stocks, they’d be hoping he stays fit and makes big improvements next season and pushes for a debut.
#20 – Nick Holman
2014 Games Played: 1
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 8 disposals, 2 marks & 4 tackles
Comments: The young midfielder had a solid year in the VFL, and received a well-earned debut in Round 22. He still has a lot of development to go before making a meaningful impact, but he’s well on his way.
Off-season Status: Like Cripps, Holman will be looking to build on a positive first year as an AFL player, and push for more senior games in a bid to show his wares as one of the new breed at Carlton.
#23 – Lachie Henderson
2014 Games Played: 17
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 11.3 disposals, 5.2 marks & 1.6 goals
Comments: In a year inhibited by injury, Hendo spent most of the year up forward for the first time. Leading the goal-kicking with an equal season-high 28 (as at R22), Henderson hasn’t had the best year statistically – but his leadership skills alone make him an important part of Carlton’s future.
Off-season Status: With one year remaining on his current contract, Henderson will be looking to get back to 100% and break out as a key forward in 2015 – leading to (what he will hope is) a big payday and some promise of success in Navy Blue.
#26 – Andrew McInness
2014 Games Played: 1
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 11 disposals, 1 mark & 2 tackles
Comments: In a year where other, less-skilled players surpassed him in the pecking order, Andy Mac may struggle to find a place in the team going forward. Only managing the one game in 2014 (playing on AFLCA Winner Robbie Gray, mind you), he is one that may have his papers stamped.
Off-season Status: His disappointing year may come at a cost, as his struggles with form in a contract year would be unlikely to convince the coaching panel to sign him for another year.
#27 – Dennis Armfield
2014 Games Played: 7
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 7.9 disposals, 76.4% DE & 2.6 tackles
Comments: A really disappointing year for a guy who had played every game last year, with only really one good game to show for it. Has dropped down the order now and may have lost the confidence of the coaching team.
Off-season Status: Out of contract in 2015, Army will have another season to show his worth to the team. With some talented kids starting to make a splash, he will have to work extremely hard if he’s to avoid the chop next season.
#28 – Tom Bell
2014 Games Played: 12
2014 Performance Rating: 6
Defining stats: 14.1 disposals, 3.8 marks, 3.4 tackles & 0.8 goals
Comments: Despite missing a large part of the season with a finger injury, Bell made real inroads in his development as an AFL player. A few good performances late in the year will have supporters looking forward to what he can produce in the future.
Off-season Status: Signing on for another 2 years this season, Bell looks set to push towards the 50-game at Carlton as he aims to cement a place in the midfield. With Judd as a mentor for another season, here’s hoping Bell can have a breakout year in 2015.
#29 – Heath Scotland
2014 Games Played: 4
2014 Performance Rating: 4
Defining stats: 18.7 disposals, 4.2 marks & 3 tackles
Comments: Retiring in the middle of the season, the 268-game veteran called it a day after showing clear signs that the game had begun to go past him. Scotto has been a core part of the side for the last decade.
Off-season Status: Enjoy retirement Scotto, you’ve earned it.
#30 – Jarrad Waite
2014 Games Played: 15
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 14.3 disposals, 5.9 marks (inc. 2.1 contested), 3 tackles & 1.9 goals
Comments: Waite will finish season 2014 having played the equal-most season games since 2008. After indifferent form, injury and more suspensions, he will likely finish the season as Carlton’s leading goal scorer and remains one of the most talented and important players when on the field.
Off-season Status: An unrestricted Free Agent, Waite has received interest from rival club North Melbourne, whilst recent news says that Carlton are keen to improve their one-year offer to include the option for a second year – taking him through to 2016 and his likely retirement.
#31 – Luke Reynolds
2014 Games Played: 0
2014 Performance Rating: 2
Defining stats: -
Comments: Chosen in the rookie draft, expectations were low heading into the season. He struggled to make an impact in the seconds or push for elevation to the seniors despite playing most of the year. It must be noted that it was tough for all forwards in at the Northern Blues in 2014 due to limited opportunity/delivery.
Off-season Status: With rookie contracts a year-to-year proposition, it’s unlikely Reynolds will be retained for season 2015. However, whether or not the coaching staff have seen enough to give the 19 year old another chance, is the real question.
#32 – Nick Graham
2014 Games Played: 8
2014 Performance Rating: 5
Defining stats: 10.7 disposals, 3.6 marks & 2.5 tackles
Comments: 2014 was a year of improvement for the young blonde-haired midfielder, as he moved between the seconds and seniors on a regular basis. Playing 6 games (as at R22) together at the end of the season has given him some consistency and belief that he belongs in the team – something that should see him propel into 2015 on a good note.
Off-season Status: Likely to get another 1-2 year contract upon completion of the season, Graham will be looking to build on his moderate game tally from 2014 and cement a spot in the seniors next season.
#33 – Andrejs Everitt
2014 Games Played: 17
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 16.8 disposals, 5.2 marks, 2.2 tackles & 0.8 goals
Comments: Coming over from Sydney in the off-season, few could have predicted the underrated impact ‘Dre’ would have on the team in 2014. Played a variety of roles for the team and provided much needed flexibility in the side during testing times. Unfortunate knee injury kept him away for a handful of games at the end of the year.
Off-season Status: With the Blues for another year or two yet, Everitt is one of the trade successes of season 2014 and will be a part of Carlton’s Best 22 for years to come.
#35 – Ed Curnow
2014 Games Played: 14
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 21.3 disposals, 4.1 marks, 2.4 clearances & 5.2 tackles
Comments: Curnow should poll well again in this year’s B&F count despite only playing 14 games (as at R22), as he excelled as Carlton’s #1 stopper once again. Spent 8 weeks on the sidelines with a leg injury, but came back to have a positive impact in the run home – remains a key part of the team’s best side.
Off-season Status: Contracted to the club until 2016, Curnow has ran with the title of club tagger since taking over the role from Carrazzo in 2012/2013. Will be looking for another strong pre-season to hit the ground running next season.
#36 – Cameron Wood
2014 Games Played: 5
2014 Performance Rating: 6
Defining stats: 11.6 disposals, 23.4 hitouts, 4.6 marks & 3.2 clearances
Comments: Another to be given little hope at the beginning of the season, Wood played a lot of good footy in the VFL before finally getting his AFL chance in Round 18. He’s been serviceable around the ruck in Kreuzer’s absence, showing the value of having a ruckman that can compete around the ground – not just in ruck contests.
Off-season Status: A sure thing to be retained for 2015 – it’s just a matter of whether he remains on the rookie list or gains elevation to the seniors. With Kreuzer likely to be fit for Round 1, 2015, its more than likely Wood will get another rookie contract for next season.
#37 – Jarryd Cachia
2014 Games Played: 0
2014 Performance Rating: 3
Defining stats: -
Comments: Determined in his games at VFL level, he was senior emergency a few times, but couldn’t break through for a game at the top level. Disappointing year for the 23 year old midfielder ended with a shoulder injury.
Off-season Status: Can’t see him gaining elevation to the senior list, and hasn’t done enough to break through and show his worth in the seniors. Sadly, I think the Cachia rookie experiment will end this season and see him delisted.
#38 – Jeff Garlett
2014 Games Played: 9
2014 Performance Rating: 5
Defining stats: 8 disposals, 2.3 marks, 2.6 tackles & 1.3 goals
Comments: Garlett has struggled with off-field issues and personal demons in 2014 as he dropped away gradually to play his last game in Round 12. Played his best game in R6 v West Coach, then did nothing else (at either level) for the year. Huge drop from the heights we’ve seen from him since his debut.
Off-season Status: Like Robinson, he will face the trading block in the coming months to see if another team shows interest in the speedy small forward. Failing a good deal, Garlett may be retained for another year as a lifeline – that is, if he wants to stay.
#39 – Dale Thomas
2014 Games Played: 20
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 17.3 disposals, 5.6 marks, 1.9 rebound 50s & 2.8 tackles
Comments: Much-criticised on his switch from arch-rivals Collingwood, Daisy has slowly worked to regain the touch that made him one of the best players in the AFL just a few short years ago. Some encouraging signs late in the year give promise that he could yet return to his best in 2015.
Off-season Status: One year into a 4 year contract, Thomas has exceeded expectations by playing 20 games (as at R22) and slowly built up his fitness and running capacity. Look for a better, quicker Daisy in 2015.
#40 – Michael Jamison
2014 Games Played: 19
2014 Performance Rating: 7
Defining stats: 85% DE, 5.5 marks, 2.4 rebound 50s & 6.3 1%ers
Comments: Another big year for the battle-hardened fullback, Jamison has formed a formidable defensive combination with Sam Rowe, providing a good defensive matchup and drive from the back half.
Off-season Status: Recently re-signing until 2017, Jamison is one of the most important players in Carlton’s side, regularly taking the opposition’s best key forward despite giving away height almost every time. Supremely underrated amongst those outside the walls of VISY Park.
The remainder of the write-ups are at the bottom of the page.
Agree? Disagree? Feel free to weigh in on the discussion.
Last edited:
