-
LIVE: Richmond v Melbourne - 7:25PM Wed
Squiggle tips Demons at 77% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Opinion 2014 Draft ( Live discussion ) Mod notice post #6629
- Thread starter MileHigh
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Yes please!!!
Linear
Senior List
Would you rate Gibbs and Murphy inside or outside mids?
Doc2Drej
Debutant
Both both
Seems the AFL have all the draftees loaded but not published...at this point you can search their names in the homepage and a video will come up.
Warren's boy is a massive unit http://win-cdn220-is-3.se.bponlinew...RAFT_DM_MCKENZIE_WEB_S_1346548272__991732.mp4
Outside is where they'll do their best work isn't it? Murphy has been beaten enough already.
Carrazzo can take on another year in the guts and get we the Cripps, Whiley and co to start doing the dirty work. Bell is not an inside mid.
Doc2Drej
Debutant
We've got Levi
zee you're a star!
Linear
Senior List
I think they would both be better off as outside mids. Murphy has suffered enough with his lighter frame, and Gibbs was always questionable with his under the pack work. Seems better suited to outside.
- Jul 14, 2012
- 8,766
- 14,104
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I want McKenzie now
Great stuff zeeCFC
Enjoy the next day of watching AFL hungry jacks ads over and over with some draftee highlights
The second possession is often the one that really gets things heading in the right direction and if.........I mean when........the bigger bodies push the ball anywhere near Gibbs or Murphy, there will be a pretty good chance of success heading goal-wards.
Next year and some pressure starts coming onto Cripps and I reckon he's up for it.
They are complete mids, they are both great outside but we need to use them inside.
Like the look of this fella, good mix of strength, speed and skill.
What sort of draft position are we looking at?
You'd think second round to late first round range. He didn't play any games this year with injury except that last game there against the rep team. He then went to dominate the combine. Depends what recruiters saw of him in his juniors and how he interviewed. Was an AIS squad member so he's not an unknown quantity.
- Aug 25, 2014
- 1,138
- 2,405
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Norwood
I'm 100% on the Menadue bandwagon now. He moves so well through traffic and just seems to have special traits.. Most phantom drafts have him going just before our 2nd pick so we might have to use 19 on him, but it could be worth it. Looks a star in the making.
Enjoy the next day of watching AFL hungry jacks ads over and over with some draftee highlights
I'll only watch them after eating food.
- Dec 22, 2006
- 9,560
- 11,357
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspur
What are the knocks on Menandue, because that video is super super impressive, lightning quick, elite skills, good eye for goal and just looked like he had footy smarts.
Those other draft watchers out there, I've done a rough rankings list and would not mind some input into the list.
A few names may be lower/higher due to seeing them on a good/off day or not enough vision.
EDIT: This is NOT a phantom draft, just a rankings list.
A few names may be lower/higher due to seeing them on a good/off day or not enough vision.
EDIT: This is NOT a phantom draft, just a rankings list.
- Petracca
- McCartin
- Brayshaw
- Wright
- Ahern
- Laverde
- Durdin
- Langford
- De Goey
- Ellis
- Blakely
- Lamb
- Lever
- Goddard
- Duggan
- Weller
- Marchbank
- Pickett
- Vickers-Willis
- McKenzie
- Cavka
- Miller
- Gore
- McLean
- Menadue
- Cockatoo
- Garlett
- Nelson
- Wilkinson
- Evans
Last edited:
I'm not so sure about your picks #2 & #3 LemmingMaster
I think they may be flipped around
Can't see us taking Vickers-Willis and pretty sure we won't.
Adelaide couldn't possibly take Goddard, could they?
Langford higher than Lever? Don't see it myself.
Jets boys are being favoured pretty heavily there. All four of the key lads do look as though they'll go top 30.
Liking Wilkinson also but can't stop thinking of another Wilkinson that hasn't fared quite as well
I think they may be flipped around
Can't see us taking Vickers-Willis and pretty sure we won't.
Adelaide couldn't possibly take Goddard, could they?
Langford higher than Lever? Don't see it myself.
Jets boys are being favoured pretty heavily there. All four of the key lads do look as though they'll go top 30.
Liking Wilkinson also but can't stop thinking of another Wilkinson that hasn't fared quite as well
- Status
Similar threads
