If you can cope with watching Duffield being pushed off the ball like a rag doll sometimes , then maybe.Justin Bollenhagen...he did kick an AFL goal at least.
I'm at odds with the AFL Draft Machine though, all the players I prefer they label 'Smokey'. Even Mattingly in that category looks useful.
Do think we could use a developing medium/good skilled defender behind Duffield, Ibbotson & Clancee.