Well don't quote me as being one hundred percent correct, but it just looked like he couldn't deal with the knee issue again. He hobbled off the same way a few times.
Injury 2014 Injury List update (keep it all in here)
- Thread starter Aphrodite
- Start date
- Tagged users None
MC_Doggy_Frog18
Club Legend
So if got dasiy got concussed they would say he injured his ankle. WTF
BlueBelle
Chief Bluebagger
Not even the second time made sense buddy 
Wouldn't have thought so. Crazy brave if it is and he kept trying to run on it.
LanceRomance
Brownlow Medallist
My guess is torn meniscus and a pcl
Knock on ankle not a concern
- Sep 26, 2012
- 17,214
- 14,403
- AFL Club
- Carlton
What's the knee injury?
Dramoth
Premium Platinum
I saw it as purely a knee/lower leg injury. The ankle he did when he injured it playing against us in 2012 was his right ankle as well.
Personally, I would just leave him out for the rest of the season even if it is possible that he can make it back in.
JuddsABlue
Norm Smith Medallist
That MMM bloke was an absolute peanut
Commentators would replay an injury/incident 5 times, openly discuss it, the player would be on the bench, down the rooms, back on the bench with tape, then they'd cross to the MMM guy and he would have nothing but vague guesses that completely contradicted the vision and thought of the commentators, he did it several times
The leg that cripples for Daisy was his left leg, his left knee was taped, he tried to play on but couldnt and hobbled to the bench and the guys like "yeah think its his right ankle maybe"
And with Menzel after everyone saw the vision and it was clear as day shoulder injury, menz sits on the bench for 10 minutes and everbody from here to London knows hes hurt his shoulder, then 15 minutes later he comes on with "I think Menz might have hurt his shoulder"
The guy was a dead set peanut
Of all people I want to see iced for the year, its gotta be Juddy! If he pings a hammy round 23 and retires I'll riot
Commentators would replay an injury/incident 5 times, openly discuss it, the player would be on the bench, down the rooms, back on the bench with tape, then they'd cross to the MMM guy and he would have nothing but vague guesses that completely contradicted the vision and thought of the commentators, he did it several times
The leg that cripples for Daisy was his left leg, his left knee was taped, he tried to play on but couldnt and hobbled to the bench and the guys like "yeah think its his right ankle maybe"
And with Menzel after everyone saw the vision and it was clear as day shoulder injury, menz sits on the bench for 10 minutes and everbody from here to London knows hes hurt his shoulder, then 15 minutes later he comes on with "I think Menz might have hurt his shoulder"
The guy was a dead set peanut
Of all people I want to see iced for the year, its gotta be Juddy! If he pings a hammy round 23 and retires I'll riot
- Sep 26, 2012
- 17,214
- 14,403
- AFL Club
- Carlton
@FOXFootyLive: Season over for McLean, Ellard http://t.co/sTvtJXZCEw #afl
Brock torn calf. Ellard strained ligament in ankle.
Menz could play apparently. I hope they don't risk it. Put him away.
Daisy bone bruising. But not ruled out for year but just this week. Put him away too.
Brock torn calf. Ellard strained ligament in ankle.
Menz could play apparently. I hope they don't risk it. Put him away.
Daisy bone bruising. But not ruled out for year but just this week. Put him away too.
BlueBelle
Chief Bluebagger
I thought Ellard broke his leg?
- Banned
- #1,415
Injury toll for 2014
Docherty.
Judd.
Bell.
Henderson.
Walker.
Curnow.
Everitt.
Thomas.
Menzel.
Robinson.
Kreuzer.
Mclean.
Jamison.
Ellard.
Cripps.
Buckley.
Scotland - retired due to injury.
Duigan - retired due to injury.
Bootsma - flesh wound.
Cachia.
Giles.
Yarran.
Carrazzo - soft tissue injuries.
Tuohy - guessing he's carrying a knee injury.
Rowe - suddenly donning a protective glove on his left hand.
Is that accurate?
2014 has been a wonderful season. Our luck is sure to change next year.
Docherty.
Judd.
Bell.
Henderson.
Walker.
Curnow.
Everitt.
Thomas.
Menzel.
Robinson.
Kreuzer.
Mclean.
Jamison.
Ellard.
Cripps.
Buckley.
Scotland - retired due to injury.
Duigan - retired due to injury.
Bootsma - flesh wound.
Cachia.
Giles.
Yarran.
Carrazzo - soft tissue injuries.
Tuohy - guessing he's carrying a knee injury.
Rowe - suddenly donning a protective glove on his left hand.
Is that accurate?
2014 has been a wonderful season. Our luck is sure to change next year.
Last edited:
BlueBelle
Chief Bluebagger
God! When you actually list them
Think the Pies board may have more important issues to froth over - 67 points to Brisbane at the 'G.
Interesting to note - Fox put up the list of injured Collingwood players (inc. Maxwell). Had approximately 12 players - including a couple I'd never heard of.
Said to my mate - at this time of year you could put a similar list for just about every club.
(... of course, we wont hear that. All we will hear now is how injuries have robbed Collingwood of a spot in the Top 8).
JuddsABlue
Norm Smith Medallist
Considering Collingwoods injury woes from tonight was direct karma from them frothing and goo chugging over Daisy last night
Happy for Daisy to be sidelined if it's a 1 weeker, but prefer Menzal and other young kids to play given game time is so valuable to them
Happy for Daisy to be sidelined if it's a 1 weeker, but prefer Menzal and other young kids to play given game time is so valuable to them
- Sep 26, 2012
- 17,214
- 14,403
- AFL Club
- Carlton
No risking Menzel if his shoulder is injured. If it's not then fine. But why risk a potential serious shoulder injury in dead rubbers?
thylacine60
Premium Platinum
- Banned
- #1,424
I watch with my brain strapped and pumped with painkillers every week - and every week I cop another ABI.
JuddsABlue
Norm Smith Medallist
I just think if a young player is fit it's in their best interest to play
Before we know it they won't be dead rubbers but he won't have the experience we need from him
Obviously you don't risk him if it's 80-90%, but if he's fit he plays imo
