Analysis 2015 Forward structure

Remove this Banner Ad

Moe B said:
Plz dont mention walker... Watta hack!! I could back heel a footy straighter...
Click to expand...
No doubt, Billy....

dscf75201.jpg
 
MEB_ said:
Garlett WAS a good player for us up until 2014, when personal issues took over. He is not automatically a dud just because he no longer wears a Carlton guernsey.

Mick Malthouse, multiple premiership coach, CAN see room for him in the forward line. For him AND his 56 goals. You haven't actually given any examples of him being a hack kick, just repeated your opinion.

Got anything to back that opinion up with?
Click to expand...
The only thing that saved him was that finals game vs syd otherwise he wouldnt be wearing a carlton guernsey... Btw isnt an opinion what everybody is giving?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

MEB_ said:
Saying "I don't see any room for him" isn't a fact, it's an opinion.
Click to expand...
Yeah I never said I was stating a fact... Just like you saying that he's good enough in our team is an opinion... I strongly disagree that he's good enough!!! Where do you think his best position is?
 
Moe B said:
Yeah I never said I was stating a fact... Just like you saying that he's good enough in our team is an opinion... I strongly disagree that he's good enough!!! Where do you think his best position is?
Click to expand...

Saying he kicked 56 goals and was our leading goal kicker is not an opinion. I think his best position is in the forward line and there is definitely room for him in the team.
 
DaVillaBlues said:
Can't believe no one has mentioned Docherty, Doc snagged a couple of nice goals last season, actually seems like he has good attacking instincts and definitely should cone under consideration if the likes of Walker, Jones, Ellard struggle at times.

Ideally would love our mids (esp Murphy) to kick more goals, and Mick has indicated Yarran will be playing further up the ground next season (on the wing/pushing up to the HFF) which is exciting.

Suspect Jaksch (at least initially) will be played as a defender.
Click to expand...
I think doc will be a great get out of defence kicker, if that makes sense, even putting him through the guts would be interesting!!
 
MEB_ said:
Saying he kicked 56 goals and was our leading goal kicker is not an opinion. I think his best position is in the forward line and there is definitely room for him in the team.
Click to expand...
Mate he had 1 good year... I know he's had injuries and he's done some nice things, but we have been really persistent with him yet he cant repay the favour by being consistent!! Did take a ripper on Carlisles head though!!
 
Moe B said:
Mate he had 1 good year... I know he's had injuries and he's done some nice things, but we have been really persistent with him yet he cant repay the favour by being consistent!! Did take a ripper on Carlisles head though!!
Click to expand...

How can he be consistent when the coach moves him from the backline to the forward line and then back again...the year after his haul of goals?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

MEB_ said:
How can he be consistent when the coach moves him from the backline to the forward line and then back again...the year after his haul of goals?
Click to expand...
Really? Its the coaches fault? He has never really dominated any position, pretty sure if your changing positions all the time, it means they're tryna find a role for you to fill... Yet he's 28 and nobody knows his best position
 
Moe B said:
Really? Its the coaches fault? He has never really dominated any position, pretty sure if your changing positions all the time, it means they're tryna find a role for you to fill... Yet he's 28 and nobody knows his best position
Click to expand...

weell laddy, IF ya recall, he was in the backline, didnt like it, made a fuss, and was rewarded with a spot in the forward line. he then kicked 50plus goals.
Let me join the dots. One minute playing back , next minute playing forward and excelling. Sounds like he was able to change positions pretty well
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

JuddgementDay
  • Poll
Prediction 2024 - Consensus Best 23 - 7 Forwards
Replies
3
Views
334
The Dominator7
The Dominator7

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top