I don't agree that being a premiership player should have any bearing on these things. With 18 blokes on the field at any time, you end up with some average premiership players who don't deserve the extra kudos. Conversely, you end up with absolute guns who don't get the propps they should. See Johno Brown and Roo's position and tell me they aren't at least on par, when you look at their contribution to the game and their team over the course of their careers.
Couldn't agree more.