PerfectFooty
Perfect Cell
Over the course of this year i've heard this debate get dragged up again and again. So i figured, it's off season lets settle this in a friendly debate. The 2011 side vs the 2015 side put them against each other and who wins?
Melbourne 2011
13th on the ladder. 8 Wins 13 losses and 1 Draw
(2011 had two byes due to the Gold Coast)
Melbourne 2015
13th on the ladder. 7 Wins 15 losses
Melbourne 2015 vs Melbourne 2011
The 2015 side is a much better side at getting the football. the 2015 side is harder at the contest with many inside mids.
However this can be counter attacked. While the 2015 side is good for winning the ball the 2011 side possessed more leg speed something the 2015 side clearly lacked.
Melbourne 2015 has a key forward in Hogan the 2011 side does not have a KPF but relies more on a shared attack on the goals.
2011 has a flimsy defence 2015 looks more solid but it can also crack under pressure.
2015 is a fairly inconsistent side. capable of upsetting in big games but loosing to teams lower than them. the 2011 side is more of a bully, while they aren't so capable of beating teams higher than them, they will belt a side that is lower than them.
Melbourne 2011
13th on the ladder. 8 Wins 13 losses and 1 Draw
(2011 had two byes due to the Gold Coast)
Melbourne 2015
13th on the ladder. 7 Wins 15 losses
Melbourne 2015 vs Melbourne 2011
The 2015 side is a much better side at getting the football. the 2015 side is harder at the contest with many inside mids.
However this can be counter attacked. While the 2015 side is good for winning the ball the 2011 side possessed more leg speed something the 2015 side clearly lacked.
Melbourne 2015 has a key forward in Hogan the 2011 side does not have a KPF but relies more on a shared attack on the goals.
2011 has a flimsy defence 2015 looks more solid but it can also crack under pressure.
2015 is a fairly inconsistent side. capable of upsetting in big games but loosing to teams lower than them. the 2011 side is more of a bully, while they aren't so capable of beating teams higher than them, they will belt a side that is lower than them.