List Mgmt. 2015 TRADE discussion

[Vineyy]

Why would Collingwood bring in Aish if it meant Sidebottom would leave?

That's what I was thinking.

Don't think the rumour has any substance, but let us dream of Sidebum in red and blue for a moment

 

[Proper Gander]

Kennedy and Melksham can.

Bugg can't.

Oddly, this makes me happier. 2 of 3

 

[givemethecure]

Maybe we shouldn't be disappointed if we don't sign elite a grade midfielder talent this year. Maybe the elite a grade midfield talent was in our hearts all along.

 

[Proper Gander]

Maybe we shouldn't be disappointed if we don't sign elite a grade midfielder talent this year. Maybe the elite a grade midfield talent was in our hearts all along.

That sounds so obscure that it must be deep and, as such, accurate. Keep it coming

 

[CWaffles]

Think it was a random Herald sun article, sounds made up.

I wouldn't think we would be trading out a bloke we have had in for 2 years, seems like the Richmond supporters just cant let him go.

 

[DeesFan]

Richmond supporters cant let it go .. but if they don't they will go blind

 

[popin]

Been hearing it for months. Didn't really buy it until my actual source said that he could move (although not necessarily to Melbourne, more away from Collingwood) if both of Treloar and Aish come in.

Been hearing from? What kind of sauce do you have? Come on squeeze your sauce out??

 

[LeverPuller]

Been hearing from? What kind of sauce do you have? Come on squeeze your sauce out??

He knows a lot of people in the industry and sees them daily. I'll leave it at that.

 

[Mick39]

It wouldn't surprise me if Sidey wants out. Buckley has traded all the Kew Crew and he no longer enjoys the envrionment.

 

[popin]

He knows a lot of people in the industry and sees them daily. I'll leave it at that.

I'll call, your bluffing. Have a set and fess up because everyone uses that answer as an excuse on bigfooty. Gets tiresome how every off-season it's always collingwood rumours specially to sell papers

 

[LeverPuller]

I'll call, your bluffing. Have a set and fess up because everyone uses that answer as an excuse on bigfooty. Gets tiresome how every off-season it's always collingwood rumours specially to sell papers

Fair enough...I'm not saying you have to believe me. Sometimes some of the s**t he says blows my mind too but he generally doesn't tell me something unless he is sure.

For what it's worth I reckon it's probably unlikely still though. The reason why I came back to it was that I first heard it months ago, but my source is the third separate person I've heard it from.

 

[popin]

Fair enough...I'm not saying you have to believe me. Sometimes some of the s**t he says blows my mind too but he generally doesn't tell me something unless he is sure.

For what it's worth I reckon it's probably unlikely still though. The reason why I came back to it was that I first heard it months ago, but my source is the third separate person I've heard it from.

I don't care if he stayed or left, it would be good to read just one solid true collingwood trade story as we have twenty players linked to collingwood every year apparently

 

[stabler]

1 of 2 things need to happen for me to get excited about season 2016:

1) we land a big fish (and I don't mean Milky, Bugsy Malone or Ben Kennedy Jr)

Or

2) Hogan signs a massive contract extension


As a supplementary third option I'll say Christian Petracca fit and ready for rd 1. But really, we aren't gonna increase our membership numbers without some sort of shot in the arm (danklol)

 

[schmuttt]

1 of 2 things need to happen for me to get excited about season 2016:

1) we land a big fish (and I don't mean Milky, Bugsy Malone or Ben Kennedy Jr)

Or

2) Hogan signs a massive contract extension


As a supplementary third option I'll say Christian Petracca fit and ready for rd 1. But really, we aren't gonna increase our membership numbers without some sort of shot in the arm (danklol)

Don't forget Jack Trengove fit for round 1. I have actually completely forgotten this bloke was playing for us, it would be such a good story if he made it back.

 

[stabler]

Don't forget Jack Trengove fit for round 1. I have actually completely forgotten this bloke was playing for us, it would be such a good story if he made it back.

Would be heart warming as ****

 

[schmuttt]

I don't put it past Trengove to be as good as Menzel was late this year, the guy is a genuinely good footballer (Just a bit slow). Reminded me so much of Bartel in his first couple of years.

 

[The Dr]

Hypothetically, if Sidebottom did want out of the Pies and was keen to come to us, what would he be worth trade-wise? Pick 6 straight up?

 

[stabler]

Hypothetically, if Sidebottom did want out of the Pies and was keen to come to us, what would he be worth trade-wise? Pick 6 straight up?

Would prefer Fasolo

 

[Vineyy]

I don't put it past Trengove to be as good as Menzel was late this year, the guy is a genuinely good footballer (Just a bit slow). Reminded me so much of Bartel in his first couple of years.

Lets not forget what this guy was capable of.

 

[schmuttt]

Would prefer Fasolo

I rate Fasolo but Sidebottom would be a huge get.

Lets not forget what this guy was capable of.

Literally was just watching this.

 

[stabler]

Lets not forget what this guy was capable of.

That was epic. Man I miss trenners.

 

[schmuttt]

Hypothetically, if Sidebottom did want out of the Pies and was keen to come to us, what would he be worth trade-wise? Pick 6 straight up?

Most I'd give would be pick 6 and our 1st rounder next year. He is a genuine quality midfielder and can actually deliver the ball well on both sides.

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

If Howe wants to go to the Pies, him and Pick 6 should get the potential Sidebottom deal done.

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

Think it was a random Herald sun article, sounds made up.

Seriously? And how did they propose that Richmond paid for this so called Tyson? The only Tyson I know currently playing the game would take their first and then some.

 

[schmuttt]

Seriously? And how did they propose that Richmond paid for this so called Tyson? The only Tyson I know currently playing the game would take their first and then some.

Zero chance we'd trade Tyson. One of our most promising young players, people forget he played on one leg for most of this year.