Traded Adam Treloar [traded w/ #28 to Collingwood for #7, #65, 2016 first rounder]

[Two Planks]

Interesting snippet in today's Herald Sun (second last page) under the caption The Whisper...
RIVAL clubs circling Adam Treloar are hearing promises have been made to his partner about a potential lucrative job in the Melbourne PR industry by one influential suitor.

MMM

 

[captain cotch 9]

MMM

I didn't know Mick Malloy had that much pull

 

[Two Planks]

I didn't know Mick Malloy had that much pull

Isnt he the next president

 

[captain cotch 9]

Isnt he the next president

Of what? The Tigers?

 

[BluesRule]

VISY hiring again?

Visy money flows for Collingwood now.
Think the AFL banned those deals, but can it stop your partner getting a job?

 

[dlanod]

Visy money flows for Collingwood now.
Think the AFL banned those deals, but can it stop your partner getting a job?

Surely it should be counted in the cap, a la Phil Scully.

 

[BluesRule]

Surely it should be counted in the cap, a la Phil Scully.

But how far do you go. Phil Scully was obvious as he was working for the club.

If Richmonds sponsor Bingle hired someone in PR how could the AFL intercede? What about if it was a PR firm where a Tiger supporter worked, but was not a club sponsor? And how do we know said partner is not just getting market rate for their skills?

 

[Colonial]

But how far do you go. Phil Scully was obvious as he was working for the club.

If Richmonds sponsor Bingle hired someone in PR how could the AFL intercede? What about if it was a PR firm where a Tiger supporter worked, but was not a club sponsor? And how do we know said partner is not just getting market rate for their skills?

Same could be said for Phil

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[dlanod]

But how far do you go. Phil Scully was obvious as he was working for the club.

If Richmonds sponsor Bingle hired someone in PR how could the AFL intercede? What about if it was a PR firm where a Tiger supporter worked, but was not a club sponsor? And how do we know said partner is not just getting market rate for their skills?

If they're only getting offered a job contingent on the player joining a certain club, it should be pretty easy to intercede. And err on the Sidon including it. That's what they did with Scully, despite the Swans (his previous employer) providing references as to his quality of scouting.

 

[Roverjg]

If they're only getting offered a job contingent on the player joining a certain club, it should be pretty easy to intercede. And err on the Sidon including it. That's what they did with Scully, despite the Swans (his previous employer) providing references as to his quality of scouting.

If the rumour is true and the girlfriend is getting market rate then so be it (she works and would be giving up employment to come to Melbourne). However if it is like Scully Snr (he got a substantial pay rise to go to GWS (think it was nearly double the market rate). So if she is being paid substantially above market rate well then there may be an argument to include it in the salary cap.

I find it odd that if it is true that Treloar or his girlfriend would tell anybody about this

 

[Colonial]

If the rumour is true and the girlfriend is getting market rate then so be it (she works and would be giving up employment to come to Melbourne). However if it is like Scully Snr (he got a substantial pay rise to go to GWS (think it was nearly double the market rate). So if she is being paid substantially above market rate well then there may be an argument to include it in the salary cap.

I find it odd that if it is true that Treloar or his girlfriend would tell anybody about this

Yeah um no.
If she is getting a job for him to come down it should be in the cap.



Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[iBeng]

If the club has a direct hand, IE: The company is a sponsor of the club, it SHOULD be reported to the league and he SHOULD be only paid the wage shes entitled to. Anything MORE than that, and its obviously a sweetener to get a player outside the allowed method.

 

[dlanod]

If the rumour is true and the girlfriend is getting market rate then so be it (she works and would be giving up employment to come to Melbourne). However if it is like Scully Snr (he got a substantial pay rise to go to GWS (think it was nearly double the market rate). So if she is being paid substantially above market rate well then there may be an argument to include it in the salary cap.

I find it odd that if it is true that Treloar or his girlfriend would tell anybody about this

Scully got paid market rate. He got a promotion from part time scout to full time, which Sydney had acknowledged they would have offered him if they had the budget for another full time role.

Is she currently unemployed? If so, your logic suggests that any job offer is substantially above market rate.

 

[aloanfromsloane]

Yeah um no.
If she is getting a job for him to come down it should be in the cap.



Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

lol, you know people are allowed to have job?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[Colonial]

lol, you know people are allowed to have job?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

You mean like Phil?

Yeah that excuse didn't work with him either

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[TradeDraft]

Visy money flows for Collingwood now.
Think the AFL banned those deals, but can it stop your partner getting a job?

Should be Counted as part of the Salary Cap like we Tried to make Peter Moore our Ruck Coach but it would of Counted towards our Salary Cap

 

[Dangerousfield]

Even with their inflated salary cap, after re signing a number of highly rated players recently, GWS must be starting to feel the squeeze. Reckon Treloar is being offered much, much more by a couple of Melbourne clubs, so much more that he can't knock one of the offers back.

How the trade is worked out though will be interesting. This is the first year GWS don't have a whole heap of high draft picks so they will be keen to add a couple to help with recruiting their academy kids.

 

[DrMike]

Won the coaches ass. Award. 3 years ago

You mean the same age Treloar is now? Where's Treloar's Coaches Award then?

 

[Andre the Giant]

Wow Collingwood are actually going to give us a nice pick.

Very charitable of them

 

[DaVillaBlues]

Surely Richmond is in the box seat now if Treloar wants finals success at a big club, looks like Collingwood's rebuild is nowhere as successful or completed as everyone thought.

 

[Baird]

Surely Richmond is in the box seat now if Treloar wants finals success at a big club, looks like Collingwood's rebuild is nowhere as successful or completed as everyone thought.

Yes, what better club is there to go to for 'finals success' than Richmond

 

[aloanfromsloane]

Geelong lost Melbourne, Hawthorn lost to GWS, hawthorn lost to Richmond, St Kilda beat Essedon by 100+ ......see where I'm going with this?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[Go Woods]

Surely Richmond is in the box seat now if Treloar wants finals success at a big club, looks like Collingwood's rebuild is nowhere as successful or completed as everyone thought.

Back on track next week when we beat you up for the second time this season

 

[Baxter 26]

Yes, what better club is there to go to for 'finals success' than Richmond

I can't see Treloar going to the Pies, Tigers would be better chance than us.

 

[Go Woods]

I can't see Treloar going to the Pies, Tigers would be better chance than us.

It ain't going to happen I think he has already agreed to join Pies.