Best 22 in 2015

[Danny88]

I know he's injured but put him in ideal lineup. Otherwise Kennedy comes in and Bugg (400) to the bench.

in that case id prefer haynes over hampton

 

[captainMyCaptain]

So with Patfull in, our likely back 6 starts to look pretty decent

B: Haynes - (games 27), Davis - (games 64), Shaw - (games 191)
HB: Hampton - (games 46), Patfull - (games 182), Kennedy - (games 54)

 

[dlanod]

Crazy to think Kennedy has almost caught Davis on games played.

 

[gee whiz giant]

B: Adam Kennedy, Joel Patfull, Heath Shaw

HB: Curtly Hampton, Phil Davis, Nick Haynes

C: Lachie Whitfield, Ryan Griffin, Joshua Kelly

HF: Adam Tomlinson, Jeremy Cameron, Will Hoskin-Elliot

F: Rhys Palmer, Tom Boyd, Devon Smith

R: Shane Mumford, Adam Treloar, Callan Ward

INT: Dylan Shiel, Tom Scully, Stephen Coniglio, Toby Greene

Thats quite a close get from a Carlton supporter. In the modern game, you need a dedicated tagger, so Tommy Bugg to the INT and Tom Scully out.

 

[IanW]

Looking at these best 22s, Im not going to use the F-word.

 

[Ichabod Noodle]

Looking at these best 22s, Im not going to use the F-word.

Which F-word is that? F#cked or Finals

Neither next year, but the year after? I reckon one of them will get used.

 

[IanW]

Which F-word is that? F#cked or Finals

Neither next year, but the year after? I reckon one of them will get used.

The second one.

 

[Ellie Aquitaine]

B: Adam Kennedy, Joel Patfull, Heath Shaw

HB: Curtly Hampton, Phil Davis, Nick Haynes

C: Lachie Whitfield, Ryan Griffin, Joshua Kelly

HF: Adam Tomlinson, Jeremy Cameron, Will Hoskin-Elliot

F: Rhys Palmer, Tom Boyd, Devon Smith

R: Shane Mumford, Adam Treloar, Callan Ward

INT: Dylan Shiel, Tom Scully, Stephen Coniglio, Toby Greene

We don't need a first round pick with that line-up. We just need smart picks.

 

[go you pups]

All you guys need is another gun small forward to help out Smith, surely there will be a few that can be taken in the 2nd/3rd rounds of the draft.

 

[Sultan]

Treloar
Ward
Griffen
Shiel
Coniglio
Scully
Whitfield
Kelly
Greene
Smith

Surely one of the best and most promising midfield groups in the comp. What are the chances of everyone securing a spot week in week out?

 

[Colonial]

Just keeps getting better

 

[OrangeDuck]

Had a flick through the AFL player Ratings and seeing what our highest rated 22 would be now...

Shaw (99) - Patfull (148) - Mohr (306)
Hampton (333) - Davis (383) - Greene (219)
Scully (153) - Griffen (5) - Shiel (122)
Whitfield (262) - Cameron (182) - Coniglio (265)
Palmer (303) - Patton (391) - Smith (86)

Mumford (94) - Ward (22) - Treloar (61)

WHE (312) - Tomlinson (362) - Kennedy (331) - Bugg (400)

No Kelly, no Haynes.

 

[Raymann]

Had a flick through the AFL player Ratings and seeing what our highest rated 22 would be now...

Shaw (99) - Patfull (148) - Mohr (306)
Hampton (333) - Davis (383) - Greene (219)
Scully (153) - Griffen (5) - Shiel (122)
Whitfield (262) - Cameron (182) - Coniglio (265)
Palmer (303) - Patton (391) - Smith (86)

Mumford (94) - Ward (22) - Treloar (61)

WHE (312) - Tomlinson (362) - Kennedy (331) - Bugg (400)

No Kelly, no Haynes.

Kelly & Haynes are in for Hampton & Bugg

 

[Thrashor]

Second ruck is now the big gaping hole. I hope Rory has a great pre season.

 

[Ellie Aquitaine]

Second ruck is now the big gaping hole. I hope Rory has a great pre season.

Or Phillips gets fit. He's had a huge run of injuries that young man. Was on crutches at the NEAFL preliminary final.

 

[Ellie Aquitaine]

Kelly & Haynes are in for Hampton & Bugg

Kelly wouldn't have much of a rating as he's first year; Haynes out much of this year. It'll be a competition for spots. And Petracca would probably be playing NEAFL if we got him.

 

[captainMyCaptain]

Or Phillips gets fit. He's had a huge run of injuries that young man. Was on crutches at the NEAFL preliminary final.

I guess the other option is Stewart who has done a bit ruck work at the neafl level

 

[Thrashor]

I guess the other option is Stewart who has done a bit ruck work at the neafl level

Ok, I really like the look/size of Stewart. If he could play relief ruck and tall forward that would be great.

 

[Mullayo]

Promoted Stewart to the bench for KPF and ruck relief.
I always put Greene on the ball, Ward back to centre HB to use his experience.
It also gives us an experienced spine of stars apart from Tomlison who needs to step up and fill the Boyd void.
Weaknesses would be Hampton but he surrounded by veterans, and goals out of the half forward line.
McCarthy and Stewart stepping up would be massive but Mummy's ruck is the real concern.
I think this is an "F"-ing finals team for sure -we've caught up with the suns overnight.

-------------------------BEST 22-------------------------------

B: Adam Kennedy (331),Phil Davis (383), Joel Patfull (148)

HB: Heath Shaw (99), Callan Ward (22), Curtly Hampton (333),

M: Tom Scully (153), Ryan Griffen (05) Dylan Shiel (122)

HF: Stephen Coniglio(265) Adam Tomlinson (362), Lachie Whitfield (262)

F: Devon Smith(86), Jeremy Cameron(182), Will Hoskin-Elliot (312)

R: Adam Treloar (61), Shane Mumford (94), Toby Greene (219)


Int: James Stewart (664) Rhys Palmer (303) Josh Kelly (436),
Sub: Tomas Bugg (400),
INJ: Patton (391), Nick Haynes (414), Tim Mohr (303),

GONE: Boyd, Hunt, Gilham, Frost, Jaksch, O'Rourke, Giles

 

[dlanod]

Haynes Davis Kennedy
Shaw Patfull Plowman
Scully Treloar Whitfield
Palmer Cameron Shiel
Tomlinson Patton Smith
Mumford Ward Griffen

INT: Coniglio Greene Hoskin-Elliott Kelly

McCarthy in for Patton for the time being. Hampton, Buntine, Bugg and Townsend unlucky to miss out.

 

[Ichabod Noodle]

Haynes Davis Kennedy
Shaw Patfull Plowman
Scully Treloar Whitfield
Palmer Cameron Shiel
Tomlinson Patton Smith
Mumford Ward Griffen

INT: Coniglio Greene Hoskin-Elliott Kelly

McCarthy in for Patton for the time being. Hampton, Buntine, Bugg and Townsend unlucky to miss out.

Nice effort. I'd have WTF-1 (Hampton) ahead of WTF-2 (Plowman) but that's about it.

Who's going to do the chop out second ruck work though? Tomlinson/McCarthy not right, no one else there. Maybe Lobb will get the nod ahead of McCarthy. Does Stewart do any 2nd ruck work?

 

[dlanod]

Tomlinson has before. Obviously very underwhelmingly but he'd be the one I'm tapping in that team.

To be honest I'd have Plowman's spot as Plowman/Hampton/Buntine/Bugg/Townsend if I was cheating. They're all largely interchangeable as a defensive rebounder/mid role with different strengths and weaknesses.

 

[Bogan Juniors]

Nice effort. I'd have WTF-1 (Hampton) ahead of WTF-2 (Plowman) but that's about it.

Who's going to do the chop out second ruck work though? Tomlinson/McCarthy not right, no one else there. Maybe Lobb will get the nod ahead of McCarthy. Does Stewart do any 2nd ruck work?

Id have Buntine ahead of wtf 1 & 2

 

[LordoftheRings]

Still need one more KPD for our premiership run in a few years.

 

[IanW]

Still need one more KPD for our premiership run in a few years.

Davis/Mohr/Patfull is fine. It's the second ruck thats now the hole - but thats what Phillips and Downie are for.