Best and Fairest 2014

[Alfredo Rojas]

Who's the favourite so far?

Has to be between Gibbs & Murph can't see anyone else winning it

My tip ATM Gibbs, only real All Australian think we will have in. 2014, who agrees?

 

[james Dean]

1 Gibbs
2 Yarran
3 Simpson
Also we won't have any AA this year

 

[Alfredo Rojas]

1 Gibbs
2 Yarran
3 Simpson
Also we won't have any AA this year

I think Gibbs is good enough to be All Australian, rest haven't really stood out at the elite level

 

[JamisonRun40]

1. Gibbs
2. Yarran

White and Rowe to feature in the top 10.

 

[Alfredo Rojas]

1. Gibbs
2. Yarran

White and Rowe to feature in the top 10.

Rowe hasn't won me over yet, been smashed soo many times this season by monster forwards

But don't underestimate Murphy only real comp for Gibbs

 

[Robbo's my hero]

Rowe hasn't won me over yet, been smashed soo many times this season by monster forwards

Care to name them?

 

[Alfredo Rojas]

Care to name them?

JB, Hawkins, Buddy, Patton, Roughead
... But hopefully has good preseason and does better in 2015, anyways back on topic which is B&F

 

[Robbo's my hero]

JB, Hawkins, Buddy, Patton, Roughead
... But hopefully has good preseason and does better in 2015, anyways back on topic which is B&F

You brought it up not me. I'll give you Hawkins. You might have seen that game.

 

[Alfredo Rojas]

You brought it up not me. I'll give you Hawkins. You might have seen that game.

I think that's probs one of Blues biggest weakness ATM... Tall defenders top sides just have that reliability of not loosing too many of those battles eg
- Richards & Grundy excellent & reliable
- Lake & Gibson again excellent
- Lonergan & Harry Taylor excellent duo

Jamo & Rowe can either be really good or could get monstered, just my opinion

So whos your tip for B&F?

 

[Aphrodite]

Is this the B & F thread!

 

[Alfredo Rojas]

Is this the B & F thread!

It is , you guna lock it I bet lol
Its new not against the rules, why don't you give your opinion on the B&F winner for 2014?

 

[Sin City]

Has to be an extrovert

 

[The Blue Baggers]

still wide open ...

a strong final month from one of gibbs, murphy or simpson will probably see them win it

expect yarran to have a career high finish

ps; sam rowe to round up the top 5 !!

 

[kanye_best]

Yarran has had the most consistent season I think.
Can't recall Gibbs really getting going until a few weeks before he signed his contract.
Murph's been up & down. Simmo a chance.

 

[Alfredo Rojas]

Yarran has had the most consistent season I think.
Can't recall Gibbs really getting going until a few weeks before he signed his contract.
Murph's been up & down. Simmo a chance.

Reason I say Gibbs is because he has that brilliance about him, can rack the ball , pin point kicks, few goals a game, Simmo & Murph don't have that brilliance, Yarran does but not to that extent

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

1. Gibbs has had by far his best year and reckon he wins easy
2. Simpson, Mr consistency.
3. Murphy, was very good early in the years
4. Yarran, has had a great year even though you still think there is another gear.
5. Everett, reckon he will pick up a heap of coaches votes for the jobs that he has done.

 

[Alfredo Rojas]

1. Gibbs has had by far his best year and reckon he wins easy
2. Simpson, Mr consistency.
3. Murphy, was very good early in the years
4. Yarran, has had a great year even though you still think there is another gear.
5. Everett, reckon he will pick up a heap of coaches votes for the jobs that he has done.

Id put Murphy 2, I love Simmo but lacks that game winning brilliance but love his leadership and attitude

 

[cfc4life]

1. Gibbs
2. Yarran
3. Murph

Everitt, Rowe, White, Doc and Levi to push for top 10.

 

[Tony Lynn 15]

Despite missing a chunk of games I reckon Curnow will also be in the top 10.

 

[etsal1]

Dre would've polled well pre-injury. If he can get back this year for a couple games he might still go ok.

 

[ShanDog]

Rowe hasn't won me over yet, been smashed soo many times this season by monster forwards

Ah... You mean once, right? Against Hawkins? No other forward has "smashed him" at all.

Or is having a goal or two kicked on you a beating? If so, sakc every fullback ever.

 

[HBF]

Would love to see Yaz win it, but Gibbs has been so consistent this year.

 

[berisha]

Everitt to poll well I'd say.

 

[Alfredo Rojas]

Ah... You mean once, right? Against Hawkins? No other forward has "smashed him" at all.

Or is having a goal or two kicked on you a beating? If so, sakc every fullback ever.

Rowe isn't a top 10 afl fullback, he has potential but isn't at the elite or very good level yet, his just ok ATM

By the sound of things you must get a turn-on off average performances

If your saying Rowe is at the level of the likes of McKenzie, Ted Richards, Lake, Harry Taylor, Gibson, Talia, Hurley, Fletcher then that tells me either your in denial or you have small football IQ but I'd lean towards both

 

[Aphrodite]

Rowe isn't a top 10 afl fullback, he has potential but isn't at the elite or very good level yet, his just ok ATM

By the sound of things you must get a turn-on off average performances

If your saying Rowe is at the level of the likes of McKenzie, Ted Richards, Lake, Harry Taylor, Gibson, Talia, Hurley, Fletcher then that tells me either your in denial or you have small football IQ but I'd lean towards both

Very charming Alfredo.

Keep the personal attacks out of your posts and play nice!