Best of the 2009 Draft

[eth-dog]

Fyfe: has had 4 great seasons in a row. Is a out and out superstar of the AFL and could be unlucky enough to lead the Brownlow medel count at the end of the year.

Carlisle: has had one good season + 2 games.

Yeah you're right Carlisle is much better.

One poster had Carlisle ahead, and I'm pretty sure he was taking the piss.

 

[Wild Bill]

Egg on face...He's being compared to carey by some in the know..I suppose you reckon Conca is better than Heppell?

Carey???? Wow that is pathetic after 2 good games forward.

Remember when Hurley kicked 6 goals V Freo and then the next week kicked 5 V the dogs?? Good times but we called him an over rated forward and got that 100% correct. You have gone way too early predicting the Carlisle call is wrong.

 

[gillon]

People have short memories, Carlisle is top 5 on last year alone. Yes, he still has a lot to prove as a forward but you wont find many players his age having games like he's had the last 2 weeks.

Top 5 would be - Fyfe, Martin, Talia, Carlisle and Gunston. In no order, Fyfe clearly number one though. Cunnington stiff.

 

[dvas987]

Where's Kane Lucas?

 

[adas]

Fyfe
daylight
Flemington Straight
etc etc.

Freo supporters should wake up everyday and thank God/Jesus/Allah/Budda that they landed such an elite talent with pick 20..

If only Freo took Basti at 20 and North Fyfe at 21 rather than the other way around.

*sigh*