Bontempelli v Billings

[Adam H]

You can hang your hat on one quarter of Billings.
I can hang my hat on an entire season on Bontempelli - being younger than Billings - being an elite player in the competition, with more physical upside and development to Billings.

Yeah Billings has no physical development left in him your right.

 

[threenewpadlocks]

Yeah Billings has no physical development left in him your right.

When did I ever state that Billings wouldn't physically develop?
I just said Bontempelli would do so more than Billings. The fact that he's four inches taller has something to do with that factor.

 

[Adam H]

When did I ever state that Billings wouldn't physically develop?
I just said Bontempelli would do so more than Billings. The fact that he's four inches taller has something to do with that factor.

And, your point is ?

 

[ManOfClay]

Can't even read this thread. It's like Bulldogs supporters are arguing with thin air

 

[Adam H]

Can't even read this thread. It's like Bulldogs supporters are arguing with thin air

And here comes the bad breath.....

 

[Bulldog1954]

Youd have the double chance.

So we were going to be awarded 8 points and an extra 12% for the game?

We win that game we would still be sixth. And St Kilda would be 6 points behind Melbourne instead of 2

 

[joop]

You can hang your hat on one quarter of Billings.
I can hang my hat on an entire season on Bontempelli - being younger than Billings - being an elite player in the competition, with more physical upside and development to Billings.

Bont is obviously in front, but despite all the hype I don't really think there is a huge difference in them.

 

[ManOfClay]

Let's see if billings can put together a full season and maintain that average.

 

[joop]

Let's see if billings can put together a full season and maintain that average.

If he can actually stay injury free for a whole season id expect his stats to go up a bit as he'd be more likely to play midfield.

 

[King Bont]

If he can actually stay injury free for a whole season id expect his stats to go up a bit as he'd be more likely to play midfield.

Just let it go joop.
It doesn't matter

 

[Adam H]

Just let it go joop.
It doesn't matter

Given youve posted on this thread more than just about anyone are you sure.

 

[joop]

Just let it go joop.
It doesn't matter

Am I not allowed comment on Billings vs Bont in a Billings vs Bont thread?
If you don't like what I post, ignore me..simple.

 

[Zgope1]

View attachment 172602

Bont is obviously in front, but despite all the hype I don't really think there is a huge difference in them.

these stats point out what a culture we have of dumb stats that give little information about what really happens on a footy field

 

[Adam H]

these stats point out what a culture we have of dumb stats that give little information about what really happens on a footy field

But what stat do you want to describe Billings elite footskills?

 

[Zgope1]

But what stat do you want to describe Billings elite footskills?

when you look at stats that assess positive and negative impact on games, these two are incomparable. Bont miles ahead

 

[Adam H]

when you look at stats that assess positive and negative impact on games, these two are incomparable. Bont miles ahead

Again according to you.

 

[Zgope1]

Again according to you.

It's a fact. The champ data stats say it.

You continue to make s**t up by claiming things I say aren't fact.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

I'd take bontempelli 10 times out of 10.

 

[joop]

when you look at stats that assess positive and negative impact on games, these two are incomparable. Bont miles ahead

Whilst I agree stats can be over-rated, essentially you're disregarding some stats but believing others?

 

[Zgope1]

Whilst I agree stats can be over-rated, essentially you're disregarding some stats but believing others?

Im believing stats that take in more information, therefore higher quality

 

[Adam H]

Just saw why Billings is rated over Bont. Billings is a match winner and would have nailed those goals Bont choked on.

 

[FalcoX]

Just saw why Billings is rated over Bont. Billings is a match winner and would have nailed those goals Bont choked on.

can't say for certain till we see him play in a final. Might be waiting a while though...

 

[Blended]

When did I ever state that Billings wouldn't physically develop?
I just said Bontempelli would do so more than Billings. The fact that he's four inches taller has something to do with that factor.

Exactly. This is why everyone always states that Kouta was a better player than GAJ, because he is 4 inches taller... Or something like that!

 

[dinger]

Would prefer Luke Breust or Rioli TBH

 

[Bulldog1954]

Just saw why Billings is rated over Bont.

Maybe by you, but not by the vast majority of football followers.

Our young players helped us win 14 games - yours helped you win 6