List Mgmt. Bring James Stewart Home

[ksardog]

After 1 game he is an Elite KPF

If anyone over hypes anything on this board its u. There is no middle ground whatsoever

Im not saying he is elite, never said it but he has a s**t load of potential, and if u cant see that i cant help u.

We r crying out for key forwards to help cloke and for the future and we recruit washed up spuds like lynch and white.

We should be enquiring about him, having stewart and moore could set us up like getting reid and brown in their draft year.

 

[Pendles!]

It was effectively a choice between James Stewart (has now played 3 games) or Jackson Ramsay (has now 2 games) ?

Too early to say whether we stuffed that decision up, surely?

That's pretty simplistic.

Hine said after the draft that he didn't nominate him because he didn't want to tie up one of his picks a month before the actual draft. Considering we had 3 in the top 20 it was fair enough.

 

[Rorzza]

Let him go! He is gone! Won't be back! Though their is a small possibility if not signed with GWS already!

 

[danielnajdek]

After 1 game he is an Elite KPF

He's allowed to like Stewart as a player the same that you hype up Moore which your allowed to do.

 

[Mateyman]

Only on BF are you a hero after one 3 goal AFL game. If he's as good as everyone in this thread seems to think, 17 clubs should be exceptionally dirty they didn't get him.
From all reports he was taken well above expectations on draft day and was expected to last until much later had GWS not stopped picking at 27 and wanted him on their list. He may turn out to be a fine player but I wouldn't be slitting my wrists over him just yet

 

[ksardog]

Only on BF are you a hero after one 3 goal AFL game. If he's as good as everyone in this thread seems to think, 17 clubs should be exceptionally dirty they didn't get him.
From all reports he was taken well above expectations on draft day and was expected to last until much later had GWS not stopped picking at 27 and wanted him on their list. He may turn out to be a fine player but I wouldn't be slitting my wrists over him just yet

Wanted him before todays game and stated as much. Wait until next year when he adds more bulk to that frame

 

[regpies]

GWS have stockpiled talls knowing they will have good trade value in the future.

I'd think we didn't nominate him because it has to be done before trade week then we are committed to that draft pick and not able to trade, who knows what could've come up.

 

[MyManLynch]

After 1 game he is an Elite KPF

Yes...they will be trading Boyd & Cameron now......

 

[THATSGOLD]

Trade for Fasolo.

 

[ClaytonM]

He's allowed to like Stewart as a player the same that you hype up Moore which your allowed to do.

You forgot to mention his Grundy love.

 

[jjsmitty8]

I tend to agree, but they do hav a s**t load of tall forwards so u never know. They hav cameron, patton, thomlinson and boyd ahead of stewart, then theres jaechks and mccarthy.

Genuinely the worst attempt at Kristian Jaksch's last name I have ever seen lol.

 

[danielnajdek]

You forgot to mention his Grundy love.

That does my head in.

 

[Jelly Bean]

That's not right. If we had of nominated him we would have been forced to use a much higher pick given GWS took him at 27.

That's not right at all. First of all, we could not be forced to use any pick. If the price was going to be too high, we let him go. Secondly, no club obvioulsy rated him before our first pick, and therefore wouldn't have nominated him.

We would have had to make a call between Stewart and Ramsay, and to be honest could have probably had them both.

 

[motr]

That's not right at all. First of all, we could not be forced to use any pick. If the price was going to be too high, we let him go. Secondly, no club obvioulsy rated him before our first pick, and therefore wouldn't have nominated him.

We would have had to make a call between Stewart and Ramsay, and to be honest could have probably had them both.

There is no way we could have got Stewart with our last pick. We could have secured Stewart for our 2nd round pick, but with Dawes and Wellingham on the trade table, Hines couldn't afford to have that pick tied up during the trade process.

 

[ppoiter]

If anyone over hypes anything on this board its u. There is no middle ground whatsoever

Im not saying he is elite, never said it but he has a s**t load of potential, and if u cant see that i cant help u.

We r crying out for key forwards to help cloke and for the future and we recruit washed up spuds like lynch and white.

We should be enquiring about him, having stewart and moore could set us up like getting reid and brown in their draft year.

His point stands though doesnt it. I dont get why one decent game from him at GWS vs average opposition means we should be wringing our hands about not picking him up

 

[loki04]

That's not right at all. First of all, we could not be forced to use any pick. If the price was going to be too high, we let him go. Secondly, no club obvioulsy rated him before our first pick, and therefore wouldn't have nominated him.

We would have had to make a call between Stewart and Ramsay, and to be honest could have probably had them both.

Bingo, fact is Hine didn't rate him and imo stuffed up.

 

[loki04]

There is no way we could have got Stewart with our last pick. We could have secured Stewart for our 2nd round pick, but with Dawes and Wellingham on the trade table, Hines couldn't afford to have that pick tied up during the trade process.

You at least nominate him and see where the cards fall, Hine isn't forced to match a bid.

 

[ksardog]

Genuinely the worst attempt at Kristian Jaksch's last name I have ever seen lol.

Yeh i will cop that, but he wont ever be playing for us so who gives a s**t

 

[ksardog]

His point stands though doesnt it. I dont get why one decent game from him at GWS vs average opposition means we should be wringing our hands about not picking him up

The same average opposition that beat us? Do yourself a favour and look at few of the highlights. Remember he is nearly 200cm and look how good he moves.

 

[76woodenspooners]

What would James Stewart give us that Cory Gault doesn't?

(Serious question)

 

[Seedsfan]

What would James Stewart give us that Cory Gault doesn't?

(Serious question)

Just another developing key forward, Gault will be the third tall ruck and then guys like Cloke can't be around for ever and if we want to push Reid back we need 3 key talls

 

[popin]

What would James Stewart give us that Cory Gault doesn't?

(Serious question)

All i can see is that Gault can split a pack witch i like and james is your carlisle swingman.

 

[Bay Pie]

Stewart just doesn't look a key positon player to me. Rather a tall flanker like an Andrejs Everitt. The question marks around draft time were his lack of physicality for a supposed 'big' player. Has that been dismissed yet ?

Not concerned at all we didn't take him. Therein lies the issue with nominating and taking a father/son so early in the piece. I hope it works out well for us with Darcy Moore, in so much as other teams notably, Dogs, cheats and Suns think again about possibly tying up their 1st pick before trade week and 7 weeks before the draft.

I recall watching Tambling in 2005 in the pre-season and he played very well. I thought Richmond have a good player here. Very early days.

 

[morgoth]

We should have at least put a 4th round bid in for him.

Nothing.

 

[ksardog]

What would James Stewart give us that Cory Gault doesn't?

(Serious question)

Covers the ground like a midfielder, with his height, has the scope to play many positions forward or back.

Gault is more of a mark, take his kick player. Stewart can rome the ground with his great athletism