Carlton 2015?
- Thread starter Alfredo Rojas
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Alfredo Rojas
Pain&Gain
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #27
Gibbs is a A-grader... Others mentioned aren't A-graders sad to tell you honest truth... Yarran inconsistent... Rest won't contend all-australian positions, what I mean is elite talent
Other than Gibbs can't say have any AFL top level talent
Yeah that Yarran bloke.
Dime a dozen.
Dime a dozen.
Uh huh. AA means little when blokes like Hertier Lumumba and Maxwell can win them.
Alfredo Rojas
Pain&Gain
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #32
If Blues have so many A-graders then why are we on the 2nd half of the ladder?... If we have so much quality elite players like ones you have mentioned then why are we loosing games to Dees, GWS, Lions
Like the movie Philadelphia ... Answer me that question like I'm a 6 year old
Last edited:
Alfredo Rojas
Pain&Gain
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #33
Don't compare those 2 players now, All Australian years were reliable defenders
- Moderator
- #34
What have I stumbled across! 
Alfredo Rojas
Pain&Gain
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #35
What have I stumbled across!
Shouldn't you be locking it?
- Moderator
- #37
Do we already have a 2015 thread?
If not then why would I lock it.
Not sure if it will last long though.
Another traffic jam for Thy to deal with.
Alfredo Rojas
Pain&Gain
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #39
Oh well I'm sure I'll get over it, and post more ineligable things for the fun of it and wait for it to be remove again and I'll get over that too
- Moderator
- #40
41 posts in, how do you think this thread is going so far?
Dont get upset with others because you can't follow simple guidelines.
Your argument is self-defeating. If having the right number of A-graders means winning, YOU tell US why Dees, GWS and Lions beat us then.
Alfredo Rojas
Pain&Gain
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #45
Dunno you tell me? Why don't you try answering the post question yourself as a navy blue supporter lol
Insert 'smashing your face into a wall.gif' right here.
Jabba73
Hall of Famer
Okay, I am done.
Never seen anyone work so hard to derail a thread they started since Spudchamber wrote his last OP.
Obviously one of those walked into the wrong part of the conversation thingys ....
Never seen anyone work so hard to derail a thread they started since Spudchamber wrote his last OP.
Obviously one of those walked into the wrong part of the conversation thingys ....
Spud always had more spunk than this.
- Moderator
- #49
We're done.
Locked!
Locked!
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Moderator
- #50
Not every thought deserves a thread. The place becomes a little unwieldy.
This one became a list discussion and we have a list discussion thread.
If someone starts with an interesting point that is worthy of its own discussion, and can express it clearly, while also showing they have considered it themselves, then off we go. Any one liner OPs that call on the responders to do all the work look like starting threads for the sake of it. Then we end up jumping across multiple threads to read duplicated thoughts.
This one was flat out testing for weaknesses in the electric fence to see when it would be locked.
My advice to inexperienced posters .... read some threads, learn from some of the old stagers or the eloquent. That way, when you venture out on your own you attract readers, instead of finding yourself tarred and feathered by lunch time and forever judged accordingly. Forums are brutal.
Feel free to ask your friendly and oh so accommodating local moderators if you require advice and assistance. (except Immortal Tyrant ... you should only post when sober .... sorry to see you go)
This one became a list discussion and we have a list discussion thread.
If someone starts with an interesting point that is worthy of its own discussion, and can express it clearly, while also showing they have considered it themselves, then off we go. Any one liner OPs that call on the responders to do all the work look like starting threads for the sake of it. Then we end up jumping across multiple threads to read duplicated thoughts.
This one was flat out testing for weaknesses in the electric fence to see when it would be locked.
My advice to inexperienced posters .... read some threads, learn from some of the old stagers or the eloquent. That way, when you venture out on your own you attract readers, instead of finding yourself tarred and feathered by lunch time and forever judged accordingly. Forums are brutal.
Feel free to ask your friendly and oh so accommodating local moderators if you require advice and assistance. (except Immortal Tyrant ... you should only post when sober .... sorry to see you go)
- Status
