Carlton Supporters Phantom Draft'

[Doc2Drej]

Feel free to post your phantom drafts here

I will post mine soon

 

[zeeCFC]

Your credentials? Would think only about 5 of us have actually watched enough games to make a worthwhile contribution. Draft thread is always there for the others.

 

[Doc2Drej]

Your credentials? Would think only about 5 of us have actually watched enough games to make a worthwhile contribution. Draft thread is always there for the others.

Im no expert, just want to see people's opinions

 

[zeeCFC]

Im no expert, just want to see people's opinions

Fair enough...Lemmingmaster, TGR, HBF are the most frequent posting draft experts. Splendini and Sin City if they're around may give an opinion here or there while Harker and etsal are always informative. Those are the obvious posters that you should take note of.

Of the wider BF community, Offsider has good write ups, but his draft orders are notoriously bad. Knightmare can have a slight Pies bias but he's the most diligent in the forum, maybe not the best gauge of the draftees or the order.

 

[Doc2Drej]

Fair enough...Lemmingmaster, TGR, HBF are the most frequent posting draft experts. Splendini and Sin City if they're around may give an opinion here or there while Harker and etsal are always informative. Those are the obvious posters that you should take note of.

Of the wider BF community, Offsider has good write ups, but his draft orders are notoriously bad. Knightmare can have a slight Pies bias but he's the most diligent in the forum, maybe not the best gauge of the draftees or the order.

Thanks, just wanted to know who my fellow blues fans think will be drafted by which clubs. I enjoy Cal Twomeys phantom formguide on afl.com.au, but I prefer a club/pick-based phantom. Also after seeing what other posters think I probably wont take much note of #aspiringjourno's PD

 

[Doc2Drej]

1st round - first attempt
1 STK Petracca
2 MELB Brayshaw
3 MELB McCartin
4 GWS Wright
5 COLL Laverde
6 GWS Lever
7 GWS Ahern
8 GC Weller
9 COLL Moore
10 GEEL Pickett
11 WC Garlett
12 RICH Duggan
13 FREM Marchbank
14 ADEL Durdin
15 GC De Goey
16 NM Maynard
17 ESS Goddard
18 SYD Heeney
19 CARL Lamb
20 ESS Ellis

 

[Jeremias]

19. C'TON:.....Ellis (It will be a Jet)

I've seen you post this a couple of times over the past few days, and I'm interested to know how you came to that conclusion.

Just a hunch considering a few names have been discussed as being a good fit around our selections.....or something more concrete?

 

[Aphrodite]

Your credentials? Would think only about 5 of us have actually watched enough games to make a worthwhile contribution. Draft thread is always there for the others.

I don't see why someone needs to have 'credentials' to post a phantom draft.

Nothing wrong with the thread at all.

 

[zeeCFC]

I don't see why someone needs to have 'credentials' to post a phantom draft.

Nothing wrong with the thread at all.

I'm allowed to ask

 

[Aphrodite]

I'm allowed to ask

Of course you are and it will be a good exercise to see who gets the closest to the Top 20.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

1 STK Petracca
2 MELB Brayshaw
3 MELB McCartin
4 GWS Lever
5 COLL Ahern
6 GWS Leverde
7 GWS Wright
8 GC Weller
9 COLL Moore
10 GEEL pickett
11 WC DeGoey
12 RICH Durdin
13 FREM Goddard
14 ADEL Duggan
15 GC Ellis
16 NM Lamb
17 ESS Smith
18 SYD Heeney
19 CARL Langford
20 ESS Marchbank

 

[Doc2Drej]

1 STK Petracca
2 MELB Brayshaw
3 MELB McCartin
4 GWS Lever
5 COLL Ahern
6 GWS Leverde
7 GWS Wright
8 GC Weller
9 COLL Moore
10 GEEL pickett
11 WC DeGoey
12 RICH Durdin
13 FREM Goddard
14 ADEL Duggan
15 GC Ellis
16 NM Lamb
17 ESS Smith
18 SYD Heeney
19 CARL Langford
20 ESS Marchbank

I would be spewing if Marchbank was available @ 19 and we passed

 

[Azul]

I would be spewing if Marchbank was available @ 19 and we passed

'best available' or need?

I mean there's some concern over Jamo's longevity past 30 but we did pick up Jaskch and Giles in the past 12 months.

Meanwhile, our midfield isn't capable of running out a game against the top sides such as Port Adelaide.

If Marchbank is head and shoulders above the next best midfielder then sure.

 

[Doc2Drej]

'best available' or need?

I mean there's some concern over Jamo's longevity past 30 but we did pick up Jaskch and Giles in the past 12 months.

Meanwhile, our midfield isn't capable of running out a game against the top sides such as Port Adelaide.

If Marchbank is head and shoulders above the next best midfielder then sure.

IMO with one or both of our first 2 picks we should go with best available.

 

[Azul]

IMO with one or both of our first 2 picks we should go with best available.

Fair enough. I'm just thinking that we redressed the talls shortage with Jones and Jaskch.

So for need, I think it's definitely midfielders but it'd be nice if a tall were 'best available' with an early pick for a change!

 

[Doc2Drej]

Fair enough. I'm just thinking that we redressed the talls shortage with Jones and Jaskch.

So for need, I think it's definitely midfielders but it'd be nice if a tall were 'best available' with an early pick for a change!

Yeah, id have no problem with picking up goddard or marchbank with our first. Alternatively, we could kill two birds with one stone and get Lamb, a tall midfielder

 

[Weiterbot23]

Would it be fair to say that this year there is a lot more up in the air after pick 5-7 than normal?

The last couple of year the Bigfooty experts have pretty much agreed on the top 10-15 and there's been 1 slider (grundy, Aish).

 

[gillo94]

I see it going like this so far keeping in mind changes constantly leading up to draft night

1 Petracca to Saints
2 Brayshaw to Dees
3 McCartin to Dees
4 Wright to Giants
5 Laverde to Pies
6 Lever to Giants
7 Ahern to Giants
8 Weller to Suns
9 Moore to Pies
10 Marchbank to Cats
11 Pickett to Eagles
19 Goddard to Blue Boys

Way to early to tell

 

[gotheJUDD]

1. St.Kilda- Christian Petracca
2. Melbourne- Angus Brayshaw
3. Melbourne- Jake Lever
4. GWS- Patrick McCartin
5. Collingwood- Jayden Laverde
6. GWS- Peter Wright
7. GWS- Liam Duggan
8. Gold Coast- Lachie Weller
9. Collingwood- Darcy Moore
10. Geelong- Nakia Cockatoo
11. West Coast- Jarrod Pickett
12. Richmond- Hugh Goddard
13. Fremantle-Kyle Langford
14. Adelaide- Sam Durdin
15. Gold Coast- Paul Ahern
16. North Melbourne-Jordan De Goey
17 Essendon- Caleb Marchbank
18. Sydney- Isaac Heeney
19. Carlton- Jarrod Garlett
20. Essendon- Tom Lamb

 

[gillo94]

1. St.Kilda- Christian Petracca
2. Melbourne- Angus Brayshaw
3. Melbourne- Jake Lever
4. GWS- Patrick McCartin
5. Collingwood- Jayden Laverde
6. GWS- Peter Wright
7. GWS- Liam Duggan
8. Gold Coast- Lachie Weller
9. Collingwood- Darcy Moore
10. Geelong- Nakia Cockatoo
11. West Coast- Jarrod Pickett
12. Richmond- Hugh Goddard
13. Fremantle-Kyle Langford
14. Adelaide- Sam Durdin
15. Gold Coast- Paul Ahern
16. North Melbourne-Jordan De Goey
17 Essendon- Caleb Marchbank
18. Carlton- Jarrod Garlett
19. Sydney- Isaac Heeney
20. Essendon- Tom Lamb
21. St.Kilda- Corey Ellis

U missed a pick in there we are 19

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

I would be spewing if Marchbank was available @ 19 and we passed

I am going on the theory that with McCartin, Wright, Moore, Lever, Durdin, Goddard all considered well a head of Marchbank, we are getting what is considered the 7th best KPP and I can't be fcked going through past drafts but I would guess the strike rate of the 7th best Kpp would be very low. Considering we got Jaksch and Jones I would be much more comfortable taking a midfielder.

 

[gillo94]

I am going on the theory that with McCartin, Wright, Moore, Lever, Durdin, Goddard all considered well a head of Marchbank, we are getting what is considered the 7th best KPP and I can't be fcked going through past drafts but I would guess the strike rate of the 7th best Kpp would be very low. Considering we got Jaksch and Jones I would be much more comfortable taking a midfielder.

Just makes sense gettjng mid. Probs Blues thought at 7 all the best talls will be taken eg McCartin, Wright, Moore via F/S. I'd love Marchbank at 7 but could just be a lessor developed version of Jakach

 

[fnm_just a man]

'best available' or need?

I mean there's some concern over Jamo's longevity past 30 but we did pick up Jaskch and Giles in the past 12 months.

Meanwhile, our midfield isn't capable of running out a game against the top sides such as Port Adelaide.

If Marchbank is head and shoulders above the next best midfielder then sure.

.. figuratively speaking I assume.

 

[Blugazi]

Pick 1 St.Kilda – Christian Petracca
Pick 2 Melbourne – Angus Brayshaw
Pick 3 Melbourne – Pat McCartin
Pick 4 GWS – Jarrod Pickett
Pick 5 Collingwood – Jayden Laverde
Pick 6 GWS – Jordan De Goey
Pick 7 GWS – Jake Lever
Pick 8 Gold Coast – Lachie Weller
Pick 9 Collingwood – Darcy Moore F/S
Pick 10 Geelong – Peter Wright
Pick 11 West Coast – Nakia Cockatoo
Pick 12 Richmond – Liam Duggan
Pick 13 Fremantle – Corey Ellis
Pick 14 Adelaide – Hugh Goddard
Pick 15 Gold Coast – Kyle Langford
Pick 16 North Melbourne – Paul Ahern
Pick 17 Essendon – Daniel McKenzie
Pick 18 Sydney – Isaac Heeney - Academy Selection
Pick 19 Carlton – Sam Durdin
Pick 20 Essendon – Tom Lamb
Pick 21 St.Kilda – Reece McKenzie

 

[BlueTongue]

Pick 1 St.Kilda – Christian Petracca

Pick 2 Melbourne – Angus Brayshaw

Pick 3 Melbourne – Pat McCartin

Pick 4 GWS – Peter Wright (Replacement for Tom Boyd)

Pick 5 Collingwood – Jayden Laverde

Pick 6 GWS – Jarrod Pickett

Pick 7 GWS – Jake Lever

Pick 8 Gold Coast – Lachie Weller (After all the work they've put into him, I think he'll go here)

Pick 9 Collingwood – Darcy Moore F/S

Pick 10 Geelong – Sam Durdin

Pick 11 West Coast – Jordan De Goey

Pick 12 Richmond – Liam Duggan

Pick 13 Fremantle – Hugh Goddard

Pick 14 Adelaide – Caleb Marchbank

Pick 15 Gold Coast – Paul Ahern (A steal, I think this kid will be a gun)

Pick 16 North Melbourne – Nakia Cockatoo

Pick 17 Essendon – Kyle Langford

Pick 18 Sydney – Isaac Heeney - Academy Selection

Pick 19 Carlton – Corey Ellis (Could become what we wanted Lucas to be)

Pick 20 Essendon – Connor Blakely

Pick 21 St.Kilda – Brayden Maynard

This ^
Simply because I think Ellis will slide to 19 and we'll get him.
The rest I don't really care about