I don't think they will be getting ahead of ourselves, but I think Port still deserve favouritism.
Preview Changes V Port Adelaide (team in OP, no change, Grundy, BK and Schazza emergencies)
- Thread starter Kappa
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I don't think they will be getting ahead of ourselves, but I think Port still deserve favouritism.
- Jun 23, 2015
- 3,276
- 1,950
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Banned
- #152
The 3 players to really impress (excluding Young and Sinclair for match fitness) that you could look at for senior selection were:
Grundy Kennedy Scharenberg
With Seedsman BOG to halftime and thought to be rested for Port in the 2nd half
Greenwood could have been rested for the same reason but he hasn't played a lot of games back yet so maybe not
Either way a few selection headaches (of the good kind) this week
Grundy Kennedy Scharenberg
With Seedsman BOG to halftime and thought to be rested for Port in the 2nd half
Greenwood could have been rested for the same reason but he hasn't played a lot of games back yet so maybe not
Either way a few selection headaches (of the good kind) this week
I disagree. This sort of thing is synonymous with young playing lists.
...I'll be happy to be proved wrong though!
- Thread starter
- #154
If we go in with three 1st year players again
- Oct 7, 2014
- 10,484
- 13,258
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Banned
- #155
Seedsman doesnt get to come straight back in, im sorry.
Greenwood, Marsh, Scharenberg & Grundy all first ports of call
Greenwood, Marsh, Scharenberg & Grundy all first ports of call
- Thread starter
- #156
- Oct 7, 2014
- 10,484
- 13,258
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Banned
- #157
I didnt leave him out of that group on purpose, either - its amazing when a guy gets given such little chance you automatically factor him out of your weekly calculationsPoor Kennedy
Over rated in my humble opinion, and is playing for his career this year. He continually under performs when it counts, and again was not up to it last night. Really want to see the other options this year like Kennedy to see if he can offer us something, or maybe even Karnezis
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Magpie Monopoly
A Good Bloke
- Banned
- #159
I really think Moore needs to hold his spot for an extended period. I remember watching Daniher play his first few games and he was garbage, but now the bombers are really the beneficiary of a steady hand and not pulling the trigger at the first sign of his inexperience and body showing him up. His goal kicking has let him down but apart from that has been their sole serviceable forward.
I think we need to remember that we have been great this year, but this still is an important development season. I'm happy with missing finals if it means we get quality games into our younger guys who are part of our future plans, we will reap the benefits in the next few years.
IF he is ready to go, Grundy comes in (will be important vs. Lobbe and Ryder), and i'd probably omit Oxley.
IF Varcoe gets suspended, and he is ready to go, i'd like to blood Scharenberg.
Otherwise wouldn't mind if the team stayed the same, need to reward good team performances
I think we need to remember that we have been great this year, but this still is an important development season. I'm happy with missing finals if it means we get quality games into our younger guys who are part of our future plans, we will reap the benefits in the next few years.
IF he is ready to go, Grundy comes in (will be important vs. Lobbe and Ryder), and i'd probably omit Oxley.
IF Varcoe gets suspended, and he is ready to go, i'd like to blood Scharenberg.
Otherwise wouldn't mind if the team stayed the same, need to reward good team performances
PieMan!
All Australian
Fas is doing what he needs to do to stay in the team, someone who is under performing is Elliot.
Agree Elliot was very poor last night betas a few more credits in the bank than Fasolo. I think at some point we need to see some other options up forward
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
- Thread starter
- #162
Kicked 11 goals from 7 games, getting LOTS of goal assists and providing good pressure.
That's enough to get a role as a small forward in any team in the comp, and I feel like he is still building to his best.
TradeDraft
Post-Human
100% Agree - Keep Moore in the AFL and he will get more Benfit out of it. White is not going to get any better then what he is now.
Keep getting Moore Games alongside Cloke and Resting Ruckman
TradeDraft
Post-Human
WE HAVE TO WIN THIS GAME. BY PUSHING THE TOP 2 TEAMS TO THE ABSOLUTE LIMIT AND COULD OF WON BOTH.
PORT ARE LOT WEAKER SIDE THEN THEY WHERE LAST YEAR AND SO WE SHOULD BEAT THEM IF WE ARE GOOD AS WE SHOWN LAST 2 WEEKS.
THOUGH COULD BE A MASSIVE DANGER GAME AS PORT WILL MAKE IT THERE GF AND 1ST AFL GAME IN ADELAIDE AFTER PHIL WASH’S DEATH
PORT ARE LOT WEAKER SIDE THEN THEY WHERE LAST YEAR AND SO WE SHOULD BEAT THEM IF WE ARE GOOD AS WE SHOWN LAST 2 WEEKS.
THOUGH COULD BE A MASSIVE DANGER GAME AS PORT WILL MAKE IT THERE GF AND 1ST AFL GAME IN ADELAIDE AFTER PHIL WASH’S DEATH
Out: Oxley, Maynard, Moore
In: Kennedy, Grundy, Seedsman(Last chance for the year)
In: Kennedy, Grundy, Seedsman(Last chance for the year)
- Thread starter
- #166
I feel if Young doesn't come in this week he will never play for Collingwood again.
He has had a few VFL games back, now it's time to see if the coaches have him in their plans for September or have they already delisted him.
He has had a few VFL games back, now it's time to see if the coaches have him in their plans for September or have they already delisted him.
left at home
Hall of Famer
glad we at big footy aren't picking the team for bucks or the game plan,we would be
where we thought at start of the season whin the gold coast
where we thought at start of the season whin the gold coast
TradeDraft
Post-Human
I can sure you Young won’t play next week vs Port
TradeDraft
Post-Human
Magpie Girl
Premium Platinum
Why are all these Thursday night games being played?
TradeDraft
Post-Human
Bye and School Holidays I reckon
Source?
PicaBoo
Soldaat van Oranje
Is there any chance of Grundy playing or will they make him do him 1 full VFL match 1st?
Repentless
Repentless
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
