Create a 'Best 18' using one player from each club.

Sir Priddis

All Australian
Suspended
Jul 20, 2014
760
1,392
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
North Melbourne
Only one Hawthorn player?

Pretty sure such a team would be comfortably beaten by Hawthorn.
Trollface-Fishing.png
 
May 16, 2013
5,172
7,165
AFL Club
North Melbourne
B: Steven Morris (RICH) Daniel Talia (ADE) Dale Morris (WB)
HB: Michael Hibberd (ESS) Tom McDonald (MEL) Shannon Hurn (WCE)
C: Scott Pendlebury (COL) Joel Selwood (GEE) Gary Ablett (GCS)
HF: Brent Harvey (NMFC) Nick Riewoldt (STK) Robbie Gray (PA)
F: Troy Menzel (CAR) Lance Franklin (SYD) Jarryd Roughead (HAW)
Fol: Shane Mumford (GWS) Tom Rockliff - C (BL) Nathan Fyfe (FRE)
 
Players from another club

B: jaksch (Carl), mcfarlane (fre), Delaney (st k)
Hb: Houli (rich) , Davis (gws), Higgins (mm)
c: Vince (mel), greenwood (col) Goddard (ess)
Hf: gunston (haw), Franklin (syd), caddy (geel)
f: Betts (adl), Kennedy (wce), t boyd (wb)
r: Ryder (port), ablett (gc), beams (bris)
 
FB: Yarran (CARL) - Rance (RICH) - Murphy (WB)
HB: Hanley (BL) - Talia (ADEL) - Burgoyne (HAW)
C: Sidebottom (COLL) - Jones (MELB) - Heppell (ESS)
HF: Johnson (GEEL) - Riewoldt (STK) - Harvey (NM)
FF: Wingard (PORT) - Franklin (SYD) - Smith (GWS)

R: Naitanui (WCE) - Ablett (GC) - Fyfe (FREM)
Can just imagine small forwards running havoc on that backline as their opponents don't go near them
 
Feb 18, 2003
32,695
6,814
Hoppers Crossing
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Liverpool
B: Daniel Talia (Adel), Eric Mackenzie (WCE), Luke Hodge (Haw - Leadership Group)
HB: Pearce Hanley (Bris), Tom Lonergan (Geel), Bryce Gibbs (Carl)
C: Gary Ablett (GC - Captain), Jobe Watson (Ess - Leadership Group), Tom Liberatore (WB)
HF: Brent Harvey (North), Nick Riewoldt (St. K - Vice-Captain), Chad Wingard (Port)
F: Jack Riewoldt (Rich), Lance Franklin (Syd), Jeremy Cameron (GWS)
R: Aaron Sandilands (Frem), Nathan Jones (Melb - Leadership Group), Steele Sidebottom (Coll)
 

Veddom

Draftee
Dec 31, 2014
9
10
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Me Myself and I
All time:

B: B.Doull (Carl), J.Regan (Coll), I.Warne-Smith (Melb)
HB: A.McLeod (Adel), G.Jakovich (WC), E.J.Whitten (Foot)
C: D.Reynolds (Ess), M.Voss (BL), B.Skilton (South/Syd)
HF: L.Matthews (Haw), W.Carey (NM), H.Bunton (Fitz)
F: K.Bartlett (Rich), T.Lockett (St K), M.Pavlich (Frem)
Fol: G.Farmer (Geel), G.Ablett Jnr (GC), R.Ebert (PA)
Int: C.Ward (GWS)
Matthew Pavlich a better forward than John Coleman?
He can't even win a Coleman medal..
 
Matthew Pavlich a better forward than John Coleman?
He can't even win a Coleman medal..
Dick Reynolds was Essendon's greatest player, period. Pavlich is Fremantle's greatest player, period. I'm not a fan of Barry but you can't criticise him for those selections.
 

12Chill

Norm Smith Medallist
Jun 13, 2014
5,270
12,395
AFL Club
St Kilda
Had a go at an all time list... First draft and I included Sydney and South Melb just richest in a few extra players :p

BACKLINE:
G. Wanganeen [PTA] - G. Jakovic [WCE] - S. Silvagni [CARL]
A. McLeod [ADEL] - M. Pavlich [FREM] - E.J Whitten [FOOT/WBD]

MIDFIELD:
J. Stynes [MELB] - G. Ablett jnr [GCS] - H. Bunton [FITZ]
D. Reynolds [ESS] - I. Stewart [STK] - B. Skilton [SOUTH]

FORWARDS:
L. Matthews [HAW] - W. Carey [NMK] - G. Ablett snr [GEEL]
K. Bartlett [RICH] - T. Lockett [SYD] - P. Daicos [COLL]

INTERCHANGE:
M. Voss [BRIS] - C. Ward [GWS] - R. Park [UNI]
 
Had a go at an all time list... First draft and I included Sydney and South Melb just richest in a few extra players :p

BACKLINE:
G. Wanganeen [PTA] - G. Jakovic [WCE] - S. Silvagni [CARL]
A. McLeod [ADEL] - M. Pavlich [FREM] - E.J Whitten [FOOT/WBD]

MIDFIELD:
J. Stynes [MELB] - G. Ablett jnr [GCS] - H. Bunton [FITZ]
D. Reynolds [ESS] - I. Stewart [STK] - B. Skilton [SOUTH]

FORWARDS:
L. Matthews [HAW] - W. Carey [NMK] - G. Ablett snr [GEEL]
K. Bartlett [RICH] - T. Lockett [SYD] - P. Daicos [COLL]

INTERCHANGE:
M. Voss [BRIS] - C. Ward [GWS] - R. Park [UNI]
Why not include West as the Dogs and keep Whitten for Footscray? :p
 

Barry_Badrinath

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 23, 2011
19,104
62,066
Bathing in Premiership Glory
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Grand Finals at the Gabba
Matthew Pavlich a better forward than John Coleman?
He can't even win a Coleman medal..

You can only pick one player per club. So if I were to replace Pavlich with Coleman, I would need to drop Reynolds and replace him with another midfielder from Freo (Peter Bell?).

I like the Reynolds/Pavlich combo better than the Bell/Coleman combo.
 
Jun 14, 2014
1,497
1,834
AFL Club
Gold Coast
B: E. Wood, L. Dunn, E. McKenzie
HB: K. Simpson, C. Hooker, H. Shaw
C: P. Hanley, P. Dangerfield, I. Smith
HF: D. Martin, N. Riewoldt, L. Franklin
F: J. Elliott, T. Hawkins, R. Gray
R: T. Goldstein, G. Ablett, N. Fyfe

Adelaide: Patrick Dangerfield
Brisbane: Pearce Hanley
Carlton: Kade Simpson
Collingwood: Jamie Elliott
Essendon: Cale Hooker
Fremantle: Nat Fyfe
Geelong: Tom Hawkins
Gold Coast: Gary Ablett
GWS: Heath Shaw
Hawthorn: Isaac Smith
Melbourne: Lynden Dunn
North Melbourne: Todd Goldstein
Port Adelaide: Robbie Gray
Richmond: Dustin Martin
St. Kilda: Nick Riewoldt
Sydney: Lance Franklin
West Coast: Eric McKenzie
Western Bulldogs: Easton Wood
 
Feb 25, 2016
1,232
1,507
KFC
AFL Club
Melbourne
Bump
FB: Heath Shaw-Steven May-Jeremy McGovern
HB: Brodie Smith-Alex Rance-Kade Simpson
C: Nate Fyfe-Dayne Beams-Scott Pendlebury
HF: David Zaharakis-Jack Gunston-Jake Stringer
FF: Josh Bruce-Jesse Hogan-Chad Wingard
R: Todd Goldstein-Josh Kennedy-Patrick Dangerfield
 

thetruth000001

Team Captain
Sep 3, 2015
401
480
AFL Club
Collingwood
FB: Bartel(GEEL)Gibson(HAW)Wood(Dogs)
HB:Shaw(GWS)McGovern(WCE)Simpson(Carl)
C:Beams(BRIS)Abblet(GCS)Jones(MEL)
HF:Delideo(RICH)Rievwolt(STK)Goddard(ESS)
FF:Betts(ADEL)Franklin(SYD)Gray(Port)

R:Goldstein(NM)Fyfe(FRE)Pendlebury(COLL)
 
Smith (Syd) - Talia (Ade) - Gibson (Haw)
Shaw (GWS) - Reid (Col) - Simpson (Car)
Hanley (Bris) - Ablett (GC) - Goddard (Ess)
Gray (PA) - Riewoldt (StK) - Deledio (Ric)
Dahlhaus (WB) - Kennedy (WC) - Hogan (Mel)
Goldstein (NM) - Fyfe (Fre) - Dangerfield (Gee)
 

Hoops

Brownlow Medallist
Jul 30, 2004
10,135
7,357
Forever in contention
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Vixens
Bump
FB: Heath Shaw-Steven May-Jeremy McGovern
HB: Brodie Smith-Alex Rance-Kade Simpson
C: Nate Fyfe-Dayne Beams-Scott Pendlebury
HF: David Zaharakis-Jack Gunston-Jake Stringer
FF: Josh Bruce-Jesse Hogan-Chad Wingard
R: Todd Goldstein-Josh Kennedy-Patrick Dangerfield

Selwood would get a game in the midfield before Dangerfield.
 

Super Hans

marcus proudson
10k Posts Pokemon is Life SuperCoach Club Board Championship League Member
Apr 27, 2009
23,370
28,292
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
TrailBlazers, Juventus, Raiders
Smith - Rance - McGovern
Simpson - Hurley - Wood
Beams - Pendles - Dangerfield
Gray - Reiwoldt - Vince
Betts - Roughead - Cameron
Goldstein - Fyfe - Ablett
 
Nov 26, 2007
2,809
8,536
Queensland
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Hull City
B: Josh Gibson (Haw), Alex Rance (Rich), Cale Hooker (Ess)
HB: Pearce Hanley (BL), Phil Davis (GWS), Heritier Lumumba (Melb)
C: Marc Murphy (Carl), Patrick Dangerfield (Geel), Scott Pendlebury (Coll)
HF: Brent Harvey (NM), Nick Riewoldt (St. K), Marcus Bontempelli (WB)
F: Eddie Betts (Adel), Lance Franklin (Syd), Robbie Gray (Port)

Foll: Nic Naitanui (WCE), Gary Ablett Jnr (GC), Nat Fyfe (Frem)
 

TheAnt

Premiership Player
Jun 8, 2013
3,509
8,677
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Borussia Dortmund
B: Shaw (GWS), Rance (RICH), McDonald (MELB)
HB: Murphy (WB) , Hurley (ESS), Simpson (CARL)
C: Beams (BRIS) , Pendlebury (COLL), Dangerfield (GEEL)
HF: Gray (PORT), Riewoldt (STK), Harvey (NM)
F: Betts (ADEL) , Franklin (SYD), Rioli (HAW)
R: Naitanui (WCE), Fyfe (FREM), Ablett (GC)
B: E. Wood, L. Dunn, E. McKenzie
Impressive call before Wood's big breakout season
 
Feb 25, 2016
1,232
1,507
KFC
AFL Club
Melbourne
B: Josh Gibson (Haw), Alex Rance (Rich), Cale Hooker (Ess)
HB: Pearce Hanley (BL), Phil Davis (GWS), Heritier Lumumba (Melb)
C: Marc Murphy (Carl), Patrick Dangerfield (Geel), Scott Pendlebury (Coll)
HF: Brent Harvey (NM), Nick Riewoldt (St. K), Marcus Bontempelli (WB)
F: Eddie Betts (Adel), Lance Franklin (Syd), Robbie Gray (Port)

Foll: Nic Naitanui (WCE), Gary Ablett Jnr (GC), Nat Fyfe (Frem)
I thought about putting hooker in my team but after the suspension and all...
 
Feb 25, 2016
1,232
1,507
KFC
AFL Club
Melbourne
B - S Thompson (NM), E McKenzie (WC), C Hooker (Ess)
HB - D Talia (Adel), Harry Taylor (Geel), C Yarran (Carl)
C - C Ward (GWS), D Beams (Bris), S Pendlebury (Coll)
HF - M Bontempelli (WB), L Franklin (Syd), J Gunston (Haw)
F - J Riewoldt (Rich), Nick Riewoldt (STK), H Ballantyne (Freo)
R - P Ryder (Port), Gary Ablett (GC), N Jones (Melb)

Thought about chemistry/combinations. Having both Riewoldts up forward would be insane. Also went through each team and essentially picked the best player apart from some back/forward choices. I feel like I've come up with a strong team here with a mixture of everything.
This must be the tallest team ever :eek:
 
S Michael. J Tippett. J Patfull.
S Docherty. L.Henderson. J Adcock.
J Aish. M.Rischitelli. J.Polec.
J.Crisp. B Longer. J Polkinghorne.
S Mayes. M.Clark. C.Wood.

M Leuenberger. J.Redden. E.Yeo
the spud 18?
 
Feb 18, 2003
32,695
6,814
Hoppers Crossing
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Liverpool
Had a go at an all time list... First draft and I included Sydney and South Melb just richest in a few extra players :p

BACKLINE:
G. Wanganeen [PTA] - G. Jakovic [WCE] - S. Silvagni [CARL]
A. McLeod [ADEL] - M. Pavlich [FREM] - E.J Whitten [FOOT/WBD]

MIDFIELD:
J. Stynes [MELB] - G. Ablett jnr [GCS] - H. Bunton [FITZ]
D. Reynolds [ESS] - I. Stewart [STK] - B. Skilton [SOUTH]

FORWARDS:
L. Matthews [HAW] - W. Carey [NMK] - G. Ablett snr [GEEL]
K. Bartlett [RICH] - T. Lockett [SYD] - P. Daicos [COLL]

INTERCHANGE:
M. Voss [BRIS] - C. Ward [GWS] - R. Park [UNI]

Not bad!

B: Wanganeen (P), Silvagni (C), Jakovich (WC)
HB: McLeod (A), Whitten senior (Fo), Fyfe (Fr)
C: Ablett junior (GC), Barassi (M), Stewart (St. K)
HF: Ablett senior (G), Carey (NM), Reynolds (E)
F: Matthews (H), Lockett (Sy), Bartlett (R)
R: S. Coventry (Coll), Bunton (Fi), Skilton (So)
Int: Park (U), West (WB), Voss (B), Ward (GWS)
 
Back