Daniel Talia vs James Frawley

[Super Hans]

Probably the best two 'young' KPD in the league, who do you think is better?



Talia for me.

 

[Donakebab]

Frawley is not young. He's 25, has played over 100 games and is entering his 8th season. He's eligible as a restricted free agent at the end of the year.

But for the poll, Frawley comfortably.

 

[timtamWB]

Frawley is better, but also a lot older and by no means young.

 

[The Bomb]

Frawley.

 

[Islanda22]

Frawley can play on the big Gorrilas

 

[carnthedons]

Frawley can play on the big Gorrilas

Adam Goodes dislikes this

 

[Islanda22]

Adam Goodes dislikes this

No pun intended

 

[BlueJet]

Frawley, when fit, is close to the best full back in the comp, Talia is a few years behind in development but could reach the same level.
For the time being though, Frawley.

 

[thetradesman]

Talia easily

 

[headache1]

Hopefully I won't need to choose next year.

 

[timtamWB]

Hopefully I won't need to choose next year.

Yep, after Talia comes to the Dogs to be with his brother you won't have to choose either

 

[Bailey01]

Yep, after Talia comes to the Dogs to be with his brother you won't have to choose either

Talz will be a crow 4 life

 

[Go the Guts]

Yep, after Talia comes to the Dogs to be with his brother you won't have to choose either

Best of luck with that one.

 

[The Blue Baggers]

hope the blues can entice frawley @ the end of the year

 

[EagleOz]

I could see Talia coming back to Melbourne, Family has history with the bulldogs with his grand father playing in their premership

 

[Cleric]

Talia is a human blanket. Doesnt really do much damage himself, but very rarely does his oppostion kick more than a goal on him. The last few years he has destroyed every forward he has played on. Hes very dependable.

 

[Go the Guts]

Did another job on Riewoldt yesterday. One of his 2 goals was when Talia was off the field. Absolutely blankets him.

 

[Adam H]

Did another job on Riewoldt yesterday. One of his 2 goals was when Talia was off the field. Absolutely blankets him.

Riewoldt 23 touches 12 marks 5 inside 50's 2 goals.

What constitutes him winning the contest?

 

[Bailey01]

Riewoldt 23 touches 12 marks 5 inside 50's 2 goals.

What constitutes him winning the contest?

Conceded only 1 goal Talia

 

[Adam H]

Conceded only 1 goal Talia

None of the 12 marks taken on him.

 

[Bailey01]

None of the 12 marks taken on him.

So? hes gonna have his 10-12 marks a game anyway and they were up the ground so in terms of impact Talia did a great job limiting Roo's.

 

[OrdinaryJoel]

Talia limited NRoo's scoreboard pressure so it's a win to Talia. It was the same last season too.

 

[Adam H]

So? hes gonna have his 10-12 marks a game anyway and they were up the ground so in terms of impact Talia did a great job limiting Roo's.

No matter how you look at it Riewoldt had 12 marks clearly he won his position.

 

[Bailey01]

No matter how you look at it Riewoldt had 12 marks clearly he won his position.

His job is to kick goals not be a prolific ball winner and Talia limited his scoring

 

[Adam H]

His job is to kick goals not be a prolific ball winner and Talia limited his scoring

Talia and StKilda limited his scoring yet he still kicked 2 and had 12 marks 23 disposals. Not many CHFs get those numbers.