Dayne Beams trade

What's suitable

  • Total voters
    111

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Their should be an option for pick 4 and a quality player.

Pick 4 and Mayes(who had a worse season than his first).

Beams is a superstar coming into his prime, draft picks in the top 10 have about a 50% chance of being long term players and probably about a 10% - 15% chance of becoming a player like Beams. And the good money says that while Mayes should become a good player he most likely won't overtake Beams. So I don't think it's unrealistic at all.
 
a_fighting_fury said:
Pick 4 for what was pick 29 in the 2008 draft, seems adequate compensation to me. Cant blame the Pies for chasing more, but that doesn't mean they'll get it.
Click to expand...
Where he went in the draft means nothing. If you are going by that theory that's saying he was the 29th best player in his draft year, yet now he is top 15-20 in the entire league. Definitely worth pick 4 and a bit more.
 
Ashton Agar said:
Where he went in the draft means nothing. If you are going by that theory that's saying he was the 29th best player in his draft year, yet now he is top 15-20 in the entire league. Definitely worth pick 4 and a bit more.
Click to expand...
I'm aware of the development the Pies put into Beams and he's worth far more than his original draft position. I hope they get more (and pick 4 already is a substantial jump) but I reckon the Lions will be playing hardball.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Pick 4 plus a very good player. A pick is a gamble even at that high selection.

For me Brisbane would be getting a fair deal if it was pick 4 plus Pearce Hanley as has been suggested.

Sure Hanley looks to be an excellent player but Beams is a whole different level.

If you want quality in your club Brisbane, then be prepared to part with some.
 
Pick 4 and that is all, He wants to leave and is worth a top 5 pick, but nothing more.
 
MinerBoy said:
Pick 4 plus a very good player. A pick is a gamble even at that high selection.

For me Brisbane would be getting a fair deal if it was pick 4 plus Pearce Hanley as has been suggested.

Sure Hanley looks to be an excellent player but Beams is a whole different level.

If you want quality in your club Brisbane, then be prepared to part with some.
Click to expand...


:eek::eek::eek:
 
MinerBoy said:
Pick 4 plus a very good player. A pick is a gamble even at that high selection.

For me Brisbane would be getting a fair deal if it was pick 4 plus Pearce Hanley as has been suggested.

Sure Hanley looks to be an excellent player but Beams is a whole different level.

If you want quality in your club Brisbane, then be prepared to part with some.
Click to expand...

Yeah..... no

lol
 
drummond2fevola said:
:eek::eek::eek:
Click to expand...

Beams >>>> Hanley

Beams >>>>>>>> Pick 4

Pies don't have to trade him but will probably do so on compassionate grounds. They shouldn't get stooged either. Beams is close enough to top 10 in the league player wise - certainly top 20. And still very young with a lot of football to be played. Picks, even No.1 selections, will never be worth an established star in the prime of his career.

The deal might get done for less than that, but the Pies will be accepting unders. If the Lions think pick 4 on its own is a realistic offer though, and fair restitution, then they really need to give themselves an upper cut.
 
MinerBoy said:
The deal might get done for less than that...
Click to expand...

No kidding, not a chance in hell of the Lions trading our best player (who you seemingly grossly underrate).

MinerBoy said:
If the Lions think pick 4 on its own is a realistic offer though, and fair restitution, then they really need to give themselves an upper cut.
Click to expand...

They don't.
 
Big Sauce 21 said:
If beams is desperate to get out and will leave next year anyway collingwood will take whats on offer. Hanley and 4 wont be that's for sure
Click to expand...

He might leave next year and the Pies get nothing. Or his father may pass away in a few weeks and he decides he stays with the Pies after all and they miss out.

Beams wanting to leave isn't what determines what a fair trade is.

drummond2fevola said:
No kidding, not a chance in hell of the Lions trading our best player (who you seemingly grossly underrate.
Click to expand...

It's not about under rating Hanley. It's about fairly rating Beams.
 
MinerBoy said:
He might leave next year and the Pies get nothing. Or his father may pass away in a few weeks and he decides he stays with the Pies after all and they miss out.

Beams wanting to leave isn't what determines what a fair trade is.



It's not about under rating Hanley. It's about fairly rating Beams.
Click to expand...

Quality post mate. o_O
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top