Pretty sure it is ok provided that the footage is submitted to the VAFA prior to 2pm on the Monday after the game.
D3 Division 3 - 2014
- Thread starter eddie betts
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Nov 17, 2007
- 18,631
- 22,828
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Ummm... VAFA doesn't work that way. New clubs come in at D4.
- Nov 17, 2007
- 18,631
- 22,828
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Not sure. The only mention is in rule 22 of appendix A (Rules of Procedure at Tribunal Hearings):
22. Any recording of a VAFA game made by or at the direction of the Association shall
be available for use by both the reporting umpire or umpires and by the reported
player, and shall be admissible in evidence at the hearing of a charge or complaint
by the Tribunal.
So that pretty much covers Premier A but doesn't say anything about club video. I seem to recall that if copies were made available to the other parties by 12pm Monday it could be used. Maybe someone with more time than I can ring Brianspeaking tomorrow and get the right info?
I suppose there has to be a closing date... Seems a bit rushed.
TheDinosaur
All Australian
- Jan 28, 2013
- 968
- 1,008
- AFL Club
- Essendon
another big week for Div 3.
Blues v Bloods should be a cracker. Razorbacks are snapping at their heels.
Blues v Bloods should be a cracker. Razorbacks are snapping at their heels.
clint_mccoy
Team Captain
Today's games:
Emmaus St Leos - Power House
UHS-VU - St Francis Xavier
Albert Park - Richmond
Swinburne Uni - South Mornington
Northern Blues - Aquinas
Eley Park - La Trobe Uni
Emmaus St Leos - Power House
UHS-VU - St Francis Xavier
Albert Park - Richmond
Swinburne Uni - South Mornington
Northern Blues - Aquinas
Eley Park - La Trobe Uni
Does anyone struggle to understand how Emmaus and Northern have their reserves at the bottom of the ladder, while having their seniors at the top? It seems they dont possess huge depth, my theory is they must have injury luck then
The second time RC seniors beat the blues, one of their supporters made a comment that we had played their reserves. Not sure what they meant by that.
Anyway, RC are a real chance of finishing 4th. Tough game at Albert Park today, they lead for much of the second half but injuries seemed to take their toll on them in the fourth quarter. Massive rivalry game for them against Powerhouse next week. Winner takes all.
Thanks for your support.
SamWill
Draftee
- Nov 29, 2012
- 8
- 8
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Fast pace game decided by a point out in Preston. Blues are a quality outfit. Too much run for us in the last. Very interesting potential finals game in the coming weeks based on yesterday. Looks like any one of four sides could win it with Emmaus probably still the team to beat.
It's pretty rare that none of the finals teams know who their first round opponent will be with one round to go. It's been a great season. Even relegation is still up for grabs.
So every game has something riding on it this week.
ESL @ AOC. - animals need a win to take out the minor prem. Bloods could finish 3rd,4th or 5th.
EP @ SM - EP need to win by ~230 points to get above Latrobes percentage.
SU @ RC - SU need to win to guarantee 3rd, but cant finish lower than 4th. If they lose to RC, they might play them again the following week. RC needs to win by about 6 goals to overtake AOC's percentage.
UHS @ LT - UHS seniors have nothing to play for, and neither do their reserves. LT's seniors can avoid relegation with a decent win, and their reserves need a win or they might be playing UHS again the following week.
PH @ AP - Wow. This is going to be a huge day at AP. Seniors is winner takes all, and so is reserves. Unless of course AP win close and Eley Park also win by 200+ over SM.
NB @ SFX - NB could finish 1st, 2nd or 3rd. SFX need a miracle.
What a great weekend of football!
So every game has something riding on it this week.
ESL @ AOC. - animals need a win to take out the minor prem. Bloods could finish 3rd,4th or 5th.
EP @ SM - EP need to win by ~230 points to get above Latrobes percentage.
SU @ RC - SU need to win to guarantee 3rd, but cant finish lower than 4th. If they lose to RC, they might play them again the following week. RC needs to win by about 6 goals to overtake AOC's percentage.
UHS @ LT - UHS seniors have nothing to play for, and neither do their reserves. LT's seniors can avoid relegation with a decent win, and their reserves need a win or they might be playing UHS again the following week.
PH @ AP - Wow. This is going to be a huge day at AP. Seniors is winner takes all, and so is reserves. Unless of course AP win close and Eley Park also win by 200+ over SM.
NB @ SFX - NB could finish 1st, 2nd or 3rd. SFX need a miracle.
What a great weekend of football!
Last edited:
They have more to play for than UHS... I'd be concerned if I was Eley Park.
With clubs leaving / joining the Ammos, and Lilydale going in / out of Clubbies, how many times in recent years have 2 clubs even been relegated from D3? I would have thought whoever finishes 11th this year would probably be safe anyway. Let's face it only South Mornington really need a break, they finished 11th last year and stayed up when they probably didn't want to. In 2012 Westbourne and Powerhouse were the bottom 2 but both stayed in D3, only Hawthorn went down and that was a punishment thing.
EP and LTU are obviously both competitive enough to stay up, both have strong 2's and even Clubbies sides so have plenty of depth.
EP and LTU are obviously both competitive enough to stay up, both have strong 2's and even Clubbies sides so have plenty of depth.
There will be some certainties i think
Roy from Richmond
Dimma from SFX
Captain from Emmaus, forgot his name, and their full forward
Marcon from the Blues
And No.18 from Latrobe
clint_mccoy
Team Captain
Aquinas - Emmaus St Leos
South Mornington - Eley Park
Richmond - Swinburne Uni
La Trobe Uni - UHS-VU
Albert Park - Power House
St Francis Xavier - Northern Blues
South Mornington - Eley Park
Richmond - Swinburne Uni
La Trobe Uni - UHS-VU
Albert Park - Power House
St Francis Xavier - Northern Blues
Did they predict that?
Would love to know your source for that information bigwaz, sounds like you need a big muzz.
coollbananas
Rookie
- Aug 20, 2009
- 44
- 38
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Am I the only one who thinks it is ludicrous that the 3 clubs with Seniors and Reserves in finals are all playing at either different venues or on different days?
Aquinas at Clayton Saturday and then Essendon Sunday.
Swinburne at Clayton Saturday and Sunday.
Then worst of all Richmond reserves at Clayton Sunday and then have to drive out to Essendon to watch the seniors.
Aquinas at Clayton Saturday and then Essendon Sunday.
Swinburne at Clayton Saturday and Sunday.
Then worst of all Richmond reserves at Clayton Sunday and then have to drive out to Essendon to watch the seniors.
Thats a shocker, whats even worse is i dont even know who vs who next week, who does the highest placed loser play?
Who does the winner of emmaus and richmond play?
bloodsrus96
Rookie
- Jun 16, 2014
- 39
- 36
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
It will all depend on who wins.
If Richmond were to win, then the loser of Aquinas and Swinburne will be out (if northern beat AP)
For the second round, the highest ranked winner (you think will be Northern) will play the highest place loser. So if Emmaus were to get done against Richmond, they would face Northern in the Prelim.
If it goes by the ladder and Northern, Emmaus and Aquinas all win, then the prelims would be, Northern V Swinburne & Emmaus V Aquinas.
It'll be changed, no way do RC have the support staff to service the teams with how it is set up.
The VAFA obviously didn't think about that when doing the fixtures.
- Status
