How we would feel about losing Hogan is probably about the same as GWS would feel about losing Shiel or Treloar. They'd be gutted. There needs to be a way where the player can't just walk to the bottom club and their former club get zero compensation. Not sure how though...
GWS losing shiel or treloar would suck for them but I'm sure the other 5 billion first rounders they have will keep them happy
If we lose hogan to the dockers we would have to get nat fyfe and a first round atleast for me to not give up on afl