GWS vs Collingwood, Rd 22, 2014

[a mayes ing]

Marty Clarke Illness
Sam Dwyer nursing a hamstring
Scott Pendlebury nursing a quad
Jamie Elliott Hamstring
Heritier Lumumba Corked thigh
Alan Toovey Groin
Travis Cloke Ankle
Taylor Adams Finger
Dayne Beams Knee
Nathan Brown Shoulder
Nathan Freeman Hamstring
Ben Hudson Shoulder
Jonathon Marsh Hamstring
Adam Oxley Ankle
Ben Reid Hamstring
Matthew Scharenberg Knee
Nick Maxwell Ankle/Retired
Injuries from todays game:
Brent Macaffer knee
Clinton Young Hamstring
Dane Swan Hamstring

All you pies haters can eat it, you're all just annoyed you lost decent coin by betting on the Giants. Suck it! It definitely was a gutsy win, regardless of what you bigfooty dudes and dudettes would like to believe.

U seem to be adding players to your injury list that shouldnt be there so as to make it look bigger.
I feel that players that don't play in your team (VFL players) shouldn't be in the injury list.
Maxwell is retired, doesnt need to be in there.
Marsh, Huddo are VFL.
Pendles shouldn't be there as he is out in the field.

You have lost a decent amount of players, but a lot of teams had. Lions used to have the worst injury list in the comp in terms of experience but we are starting to get back.
I wouldn't say Pies won it, l would say Giants lost it from watching th game

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Pies in the eight. Go Sainters!!!!

 

[DuckToaster]

U seem to be adding players to your injury list that shouldnt be there so as to make it look bigger.
I feel that players that don't play in your team (VFL players) shouldn't be in the injury list.
Maxwell is retired, doesnt need to be in there.
Marsh, Huddo are VFL.
Pendles shouldn't be there as he is out in the field.

You have lost a decent amount of players, but a lot of teams had. Lions used to have the worst injury list in the comp in terms of experience but we are starting to get back.
I wouldn't say Pies won it, l would say Giants lost it from watching th game

They are all senior listed players, I didn't include our VFL injury list. Do you want to see it?

Lachlan HoweAnkleTest
Tom TyquinHamstring1-2 weeks
Dylan OrvalHamstringSeason
Ryan PendleburyPectoralSeason
Josh TurnerNeckSeason

Now stop trying to make this thread all about your young list, we get it. You have a good future. Now go inject your goo into another thread.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

U seem to be adding players to your injury list that shouldnt be there so as to make it look bigger.
I feel that players that don't play in your team (VFL players) shouldn't be in the injury list.
Maxwell is retired, doesnt need to be in there.
Marsh, Huddo are VFL.
Pendles shouldn't be there as he is out in the field.

You have lost a decent amount of players, but a lot of teams had. Lions used to have the worst injury list in the comp in terms of experience but we are starting to get back.
I wouldn't say Pies won it, l would say Giants lost it from watching th game

Maxwell retired because of injury, of course hes on the list.
Marsh and Hudson are on our list (albeit none of our rucks are injured so its not likely we'd call on him but Marsh was playing well and close to selection)'
Agree you cant count Pendlebury but a half fit Pendles is not nearly as effective as a fully fit one.

 

[Testekill]

Irony alert

Oh yes, it is ironic that we beat you while losing a brownlow medallist in the opening quarter and beat them without them having to flop horribly.

 

[Jack Bradley]

When he's 23 and played 43 games and only kicks multiple goals 6 times in a season

Quiet you

 

[MAGPIE2013]

Carlton 2012 although Freo in 2011 take the cake.

We had 10 out of our best 22 playing half way through the season.

Pies train too hard and wonder why they keep losing players to injuries.

We have 17 players on the injury list. Period. That is monumental, no team has had the Injury profile we have had this year.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Oh yes, it is ironic that we beat you while losing a brownlow medallist in the opening quarter and beat them without them having to flop horribly.

Like rain, on your wedding day

 

[Babylove]

U seem to be adding players to your injury list that shouldnt be there so as to make it look bigger.
I feel that players that don't play in your team (VFL players) shouldn't be in the injury list.
Maxwell is retired, doesnt need to be in there.
Marsh, Huddo are VFL.
Pendles shouldn't be there as he is out in the field.

You have lost a decent amount of players, but a lot of teams had. Lions used to have the worst injury list in the comp in terms of experience but we are starting to get back.
I wouldn't say Pies won it, l would say Giants lost it from watching th game

Injury list for Pies as of this morning (from the Pies website)
NameInjuryStatus
Marty Clarke Illness Test
Sam Dwyer Hamstring Test
Scott Pendlebury Corked quad Test
Jamie Elliott Hamstring 1 week
Heritier Lumumba Corked thigh 1 week
Alan Toovey Groin 1 week
Travis Cloke Ankle 3-4 weeks
Taylor Adams Finger Season
Dayne Beams Knee Season
Nathan Brown Shoulder Season
Nathan Freeman Hamstring Season
Ben Hudson Shoulder Season
Jonathon Marsh Hamstring Season
Adam Oxley Ankle Season
Ben Reid Hamstring Season
Matthew Scharenberg Knee Season
Nick Maxwell Ankle Retired

You can add to that list Swan, Macaffer & Young. Also note that Maxwell is retired because he's injured otherwise he would have played to the end of the year. And Hudson would have likely played a few games to give Witts and Grundy a chop out had he not be injured (he's an upgraded rookie).

 

[Testekill]

Like rain, on your wedding day

I'm still waiting on a free ride.

 

[MAGPIE2013]

U seem to be adding players to your injury list that shouldnt be there so as to make it look bigger.
I feel that players that don't play in your team (VFL players) shouldn't be in the injury list.
Maxwell is retired, doesnt need to be in there.
Marsh, Huddo are VFL.
Pendles shouldn't be there as he is out in the field.

You have lost a decent amount of players, but a lot of teams had. Lions used to have the worst injury list in the comp in terms of experience but we are starting to get back.
I wouldn't say Pies won it, l would say Giants lost it from watching th game

Do you even know anything about out list. They are all freeking senior players. Dont even get me started on our 'vfl' injury list budy cause that is another story in itself. Our Injury list of off the charts and we have just had 2 acls in less than 24 hours, no club can beat that horrible luck

 

[MAGPIE2013]

U seem to be adding players to your injury list that shouldnt be there so as to make it look bigger.
I feel that players that don't play in your team (VFL players) shouldn't be in the injury list.
Maxwell is retired, doesnt need to be in there.
Marsh, Huddo are VFL.
Pendles shouldn't be there as he is out in the field.

You have lost a decent amount of players, but a lot of teams had. Lions used to have the worst injury list in the comp in terms of experience but we are starting to get back.
I wouldn't say Pies won it, l would say Giants lost it from watching th game

Do you even know anything about out list. They are all freeking senior players. Dont even get me started on our 'vfl' injury list budy cause that is another story in itself. Our Injury list of off the charts and we have just had 2 acls in less than 24 hours, no club can beat that horrible luck

 

[DuckToaster]

Do you even know anything about out list. They are all freeking senior players. Dont even get me started on our 'vfl' injury list budy cause that is another story in itself. Our Injury list of off the charts and we have just had 2 acls in less than 24 hours, no club can beat that horrible luck

Apparently other clubs have had it just as bad as us

 

[The Filth]

Oh yes, it is ironic that we beat you while losing a brownlow medallist in the opening quarter and beat them without them having to flop horribly.

So what's your excuse for the Dogs position on the ladder?

 

[MAGPIE2013]

Apparently other clubs have had it just as bad as us

They can start by matching this weekends injuries.
-2 hamstrings to mids
-2 acls

 

[DuckToaster]

They can start by matching this weekends injuries.
-2 hamstrings to mids
-2 acls

Dogs have been able to play their top two draft picks this year too...

 

[a mayes ing]

Apparently other clubs have had it just as bad as us

IIRC, we have lost 1600-1800 games of experience at one point due to injury in this season.
And that is just my team. I can imagine Hawks have lost a fair chunk of their list as well.

 

[Pie eyed]

Great win by the Pies.

No right, but got it done.
Mick will be green, cooking his sausages.

 

[MAGPIE2013]

IIRC, we have lost 1600-1800 games of experience at one point due to injury in this season.
And that is just my team. I can imagine Hawks have lost a fair chunk of their list as well.

Be realistic buddy. Put your hate for our club aside and have a look at our injury list. It is beyond belief. We are the 4th youngest list team in the comp atm due to our injury profiles

 

[Pie eyed]

IIRC, we have lost 1600-1800 games of experience at one point due to injury in this season.
And that is just my team. I can imagine Hawks have lost a fair chunk of their list as well.

4 Kevin Bartlett's and a Dustin Fletcher.

 

[The Filth]

Can I just say that as a supporter I am proud of my team today. Although it "was only GWS", with the injuries and the lack of form in recent weeks it was a good effort to rally and win today. It would have been easy just to chuck it in.
Best game I have seen from Thomas and solid game from Broomhead. Well done boys.

 

[jerry springer]

* the haters

 

[Giant Pete]

I'm not just saying that based on this game alone. Every time I see Treloar play, I see nothing remarkable about him; just another Inside Midfielder who's very prone to mistakes.

Considering Collingwood's injuries (which are twice as bad as GWS's) & the fact that GWS were playing at home, losing was an absolutely putrid effort. They're overrated.

Thanks nostrildamus.. I'm sure you were saying as much after our win last week and their loss. How are their injuries twice as bad as ours?

 

[SuperSub17]

Lol haters gonna hate.

 

[Lawls]

Collingwood would be the worst top 8 team of all time if they made it.

The 2009 Essendon team says hello